When Going Online Will Send You To Prison

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
I know it sucks but, if you don't like the punishment, you probably shouldn't have committed the crime.

Sometimes, as part of their parole, people who are convicted of computer-related crimes are allowed to return to the Internet with official police monitoring software installed on their computers. Other times, they are simply prohibited from using the computer entirely. Often this is a punishment applied to sex offenders — people caught in possession of child pornography, sexual predators, pedophiles — but it's also applied to hackers.
 
This article is quite funny.
Throughout all of this, he was getting bolder. He was taunting the authorities on his Twitter feed, saying things like "wat u got?" and "come at me bro."

Oh and his pickup line for his wife: "Tits or GTFO."
 
I'd give him a nice WoW-styled permaban from the internet.
 
Having no computer access whatsoever seems like an extreme and unusual punishment if you're let out of prison. There aren't many jobs you can do these days without the need for a computer.
 
Having no computer access whatsoever seems like an extreme and unusual punishment if you're let out of prison. There aren't many jobs you can do these days without the need for a computer.

There are plenty of jobs that do not absolutely need a computer. Will make it a bit harder given his skill set? Yes. But such is the punishment of what he did. If you got busted on child molestation, I can almost guarantee you wouldn't be allowed to work with children either, which if you were an elementary school teacher is kind of what you were trained to do.
 
Having no computer access whatsoever seems like an extreme and unusual punishment if you're let out of prison. There aren't many jobs you can do these days without the need for a computer.

He is still on parole, that is like saying that if somebody shots somebody and gets out of jail they should be allowed to buy a gun the minute they get out as people need guns to hunt.

In this case, keeping the guy in jail is just a waste of tax payer money, let him out but keep him from the internet for a short while. Once his parole is up he gets back online again.
 
Ive found that rule to be dumb tbh.

If you do time for breaking and entering, are you no longer allowed to go into houses?

Stealing car: Can't own car any longer?
 
Ive found that rule to be dumb tbh.

If you do time for breaking and entering, are you no longer allowed to go into houses?

Stealing car: Can't own car any longer?

If you get caught breaking and entering you will probably do some jail time. Same if you steal a car.
 
Ive found that rule to be dumb tbh.

If you do time for breaking and entering, are you no longer allowed to go into houses?

Stealing car: Can't own car any longer?

Dude how old are you?

Laws are not that black and white, and you can't use the same logic to translate every relatable situation to the same logic. The world doesn't work that way, and if it did we would stil be stuck in the stone age, where we would be cutting off people's hands if they stole!
 
Ive found that rule to be dumb tbh.

If you do time for breaking and entering, are you no longer allowed to go into houses?

Stealing car: Can't own car any longer?

The difference is that a computer is the tool he used to illegally access other systems, which makes that different then B&E or stealing a car.

But let''s assume you are convicted of B&E, I'm sure your parole officer would have you locked back up if you are picked up with a set of lock picks in your pocket.
 
Ahh, the good old days of AOL chat room punters, malicious IMs, etc.

The story kind of surprised me in the fact that the government computers still have very lax security like they did back in the early 90's.
 
Having no computer access whatsoever seems like an extreme and unusual punishment if you're let out of prison. There aren't many jobs you can do these days without the need for a computer.

It's a condition of his Parole, not permanent. At least not yet.
 
The difference is that a computer is the tool he used to illegally access other systems, which makes that different then B&E or stealing a car.

So let's say you cut up drugs inside an apartment or home, using it as a "tool" to conceal your activity. Now you shouldn't be able to own a house?

That tool argument you made could be interpreted very broadly.
 
Ive found that rule to be dumb tbh.

If you do time for breaking and entering, are you no longer allowed to go into houses?

Stealing car: Can't own car any longer?

Not the same man.

1st, sometimes it is possible for a felon to get his 2A rights restored, particularly if he didn't commit a violent crime with a weapon.

2nd, the breaking and entering actually is a bad analogy, doesn't fit.

3rd, the stealing cars isn't right either, but if you had set he was a get-away driver on a bank job then no owning cars and no driver's license might be appropriate. Might let him drive commercially for work only, that kind of thing.

Still, once a person has served their time, unless the person is shown to have some mental issues, I am not for these kinds of restrictions once they are off parole.
 
So let's say you cut up drugs inside an apartment or home, using it as a "tool" to conceal your activity. Now you shouldn't be able to own a house?

That tool argument you made could be interpreted very broadly.

This house home thing is a ridiculous analogy canna.
 
So let's say you cut up drugs inside an apartment or home, using it as a "tool" to conceal your activity. Now you shouldn't be able to own a house?

That tool argument you made could be interpreted very broadly.

Your really reaching on this one.

The house wouldn't be the tool, but if a parole officer visited who was convicted of cutting uup and distributing drugs and found a table on which an electronic scale and piles of baggies was sitting they might take issue with it.
 
My main concern with restictions like this is that they often are tacked on long after the punishment has been decided and handed out, which to me is at best legally questionable.
 
Dude how old are you?

Laws are not that black and white, and you can't use the same logic to translate every relatable situation to the same logic. The world doesn't work that way, and if it did we would stil be stuck in the stone age, where we would be cutting off people's hands if they stole!

Well, it would make it harder for them to steal again without hands :D
 
So let's say you cut up drugs inside an apartment or home, using it as a "tool" to conceal your activity. Now you shouldn't be able to own a house?

That tool argument you made could be interpreted very broadly.

The house isn't the tool, the equipment to cut would be the tool in this case.

Lets replace the activity with hacking and see if it sill works?

So lets say you hack inside your apartment or home, now should you be able to own a house? Yes.

Did anyone take this guys house? No.

Looks like that doesn't hold water.
 
Dude how old are you?
The world doesn't work that way, and if it did we would stil be stuck in the stone age, where we would be cutting off people's hands if they stole!

They need to go back to this for stealing.

How many people steal in Saudi Arabia the numbers are low because its not worth your hands.

The laws in North America are too soft and its why the prison system is packed examples need to be set instead of everyone paying to keep criminals in jail so they can get reeducated by better criminals just to come out and do it again.
 
He is still on parole, that is like saying that if somebody shots somebody and gets out of jail they should be allowed to buy a gun the minute they get out as people need guns to hunt.
But how many jobs require a gun?

I literally can't think of any job I could do that would pay more than peasant-grade poverty level crap that doesn't require the use of a computer at some point or another, even if just to log my time every week.
 
But how many jobs require a gun?

I literally can't think of any job I could do that would pay more than peasant-grade poverty level crap that doesn't require the use of a computer at some point or another, even if just to log my time every week.

If you would have read the article, you would know that he uses a lab of offline computers and programs for a living by transferring code to the company he works for with a thumb drive he gives to his girlfriend or by printing out code on paper and providing it to the company that then has someone else enter it into a web-connected computer. It's not that he's not allowed to touch a computer at all, he just can't mess with one that has an Internet connection.
 
They need to go back to this for stealing.

How many people steal in Saudi Arabia the numbers are low because its not worth your hands.

The laws in North America are too soft and its why the prison system is packed examples need to be set instead of everyone paying to keep criminals in jail so they can get reeducated by better criminals just to come out and do it again.

Too soft, which is why we have such a massive prison population. :rolleyes:

Personally, unless it's oil, I wouldn't look to Saudi Arabia for anything.
 
If you would have read the article, you would know that he uses a lab of offline computers and programs for a living by transferring code to the company he works for with a thumb drive he gives to his girlfriend or by printing out code on paper and providing it to the company that then has someone else enter it into a web-connected computer. It's not that he's not allowed to touch a computer at all, he just can't mess with one that has an Internet connection.
He's lucky, or his employer has hired him at slave wages, as most large companies will not allow such special conditions or even hire someone that doesn't have constant access to email.

Even our facilities guys have to be on-call via email monitoring, and surely a smartphone with email would be considered a computer.

Its some BS IMO.
 
Too soft, which is why we have such a massive prison population. :rolleyes:
BTW, an interesting fact is that if you look at the percentage of the US population that has been incarcerated, its actually not higher than other countries.

Whats different in the United States is that the criminals we do arrest tend to get longer prison sentences, and just like at a timeshare if you have 100 people only staying 2 weeks out of the year each its not going to be as full as 100 people saying 2 months out of the year.
 
BTW, an interesting fact is that if you look at the percentage of the US population that has been incarcerated, its actually not higher than other countries.

Whats different in the United States is that the criminals we do arrest tend to get longer prison sentences, and just like at a timeshare if you have 100 people only staying 2 weeks out of the year each its not going to be as full as 100 people saying 2 months out of the year.

Right, mandatory minimum sentencing, all that crap. It's a mess.
 
Ive found that rule to be dumb tbh.

If you do time for breaking and entering, are you no longer allowed to go into houses?

Stealing car: Can't own car any longer?

If you do time for B&E or stealing a car, you can get in serious trouble if you are ever found with tools that would allow you to do those crimes. How's that for your bass ackwards analogy.
 
So let's say you cut up drugs inside an apartment or home, using it as a "tool" to conceal your activity. Now you shouldn't be able to own a house?

That tool argument you made could be interpreted very broadly.

How do you cut drugs with a house/apartment?
 
My main concern with restictions like this is that they often are tacked on long after the punishment has been decided and handed out, which to me is at best legally questionable.

I don't have any facts to support your claim, but I can say that if your claim is correct then I would have a problem with it as well.
 
But how many jobs require a gun?

I literally can't think of any job I could do that would pay more than peasant-grade poverty level crap that doesn't require the use of a computer at some point or another, even if just to log my time every week.

Actually people are making an assumption that he can't use a computer as part of his duties as an employee. Did someone see something in the article that says otherwise?
 
Didn't read the article earlier, but this guy's on parole, which means he was released early, 18 months into a 27 month sentence. Once his parole's over he can do whatever he want, so this isn't excessive at all.
 
One thing that confused me is that he says he drops his code onto removable storage, gives it to his wife, and she takes it to the office.

How is any of that "using the internet". Why can't he take his own hard disk in to the office?
 
One thing that confused me is that he says he drops his code onto removable storage, gives it to his wife, and she takes it to the office.

How is any of that "using the internet". Why can't he take his own hard disk in to the office?

It says he puts it on a flash drive, gives it to his wife, and she emails to his boss. For large batches of code or when his PO doesn't want her acting as a middle man, he prints it out and mails it. Makes it sound like he works remotely and not necessarily able to "drive to the office."

the article said:
"I have a transfer USB," he says. "It's over there. Little blue one. I plug it in, throw the code on there, zip it up and toss it to the wife." From there, Kylie emails it to his boss. Since Higinio's parole officer doesn't want Kylie acting as a middle-man between Higinio and the Internet, for larger batches of code he is forced to actually print the code out and mail it to his boss, who then has someone else type it up.
 
I also think this guy is smart enough not to argue with the judge over nitpicky intricacies of what he can get away with.
 
BTW, an interesting fact is that if you look at the percentage of the US population that has been incarcerated, its actually not higher than other countries.

Whats different in the United States is that the criminals we do arrest tend to get longer prison sentences, and just like at a timeshare if you have 100 people only staying 2 weeks out of the year each its not going to be as full as 100 people saying 2 months out of the year.
The first part of your paragraph is incorrect. I'm not sure where you gleaned this "interesting fact" but it's wrong. On any given day we have over 2.2 million people behind bars if we count prisons, jails, juvenile detention, and direct supervision. That number rises to nearly 8 million if we count all the people on direct supervision (probation and parole).

Our prison population rose significantly after the 1950's and never came back down. The 1950's coincides with the deinstitutionalization of our mental health facilities and, as a result, our prisons and jails have become de facto mental health institutions. Over 60% of our prison population have significant mental health issues and more than half have serious substance abuse issues.

In 2008 our incarceration rate was roughly around 500 per 100,000. Since then it's nearly doubled (it currently sits around 700 total per 100,000 but 900 per 100,000 when strictly counting men. Females are a relatively insignificant part of our prison population although their rise is alarming--they only account for roughly 7% of our prisoners). Even back in the 50's, however, our crime rate and prison population were alarming compared to other countries. (Canada incarcerates around 100 per 100,000, UK around 150 per 100,000, and Germany around 75 per 100,000).

We currently have about 5% of the world's population yet we incarcerate 25% of world's prisoners. Our incarceration rate is nowhere near the rest of the world's...and not in a good way. When people talk about American exceptionalism I don't think this is what they have in mind.



The second point that people in the US are convicted and sentenced to longer sentences than other comparable countries is accurate.


The problem with the US system isn't in the sentencing. The slippage is in the apprehension. Only a fraction of all crime is reported and only a fraction of that reported crime is adjudicated. Once it is, however, our prosecutors enjoy an over 90% success rate with only around 4% choosing trial (where defendants lose more often than not).
 
There are plenty of jobs that do not absolutely need a computer. Will make it a bit harder given his skill set? Yes. But such is the punishment of what he did. If you got busted on child molestation, I can almost guarantee you wouldn't be allowed to work with children either, which if you were an elementary school teacher is kind of what you were trained to do.

He broke into the computers of the state's gestapo. Computers that were paid for with money that was stolen from him to begin with.

To compare that to a child molester is absurd statist claptrap.
 
It says he puts it on a flash drive, gives it to his wife, and she emails to his boss. For large batches of code or when his PO doesn't want her acting as a middle man, he prints it out and mails it. Makes it sound like he works remotely and not necessarily able to "drive to the office."

That makes more sense. I listened to the episode in my car and missed the "email" part.
 
The first part of your paragraph is incorrect. I'm not sure where you gleaned this "interesting fact" but it's wrong. On any given day we have over 2.2 million people behind bars if we count prisons, jails, juvenile detention, and direct supervision. That number rises to nearly 8 million if we count all the people on direct supervision (probation and parole).
Its from a documentary I watched on US prisons. No offense mope, but with the availability of the internet, why not post a source instead of always just saying "that's wrong, I say so"? You do that in every thread, and I understand it takes ZERO effort to do so, but is a bit annoying. You also completely misread what I posted.

I know that we have more bodies in prison at any particular point in time, and I've said as much that our incarceration rate is very high. The reason though is not that we incarcerate a higher percentage of our population, but that each spends more time in prison, and this is common sense why the incarceration rate would increase accordingly.

For example, if any prison sentence you could get would be a life sentence, would the jails be more or less full than if any prison sentence you got was a 1 days sentence (and thus the # of prisoners per 100K population be higher)? It doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure out that if everyone got a life sentence that prisons would be massively over capacity, and virtually empty if people only had a 1 day sentence because they would cycle out so quickly. That's grade school logic.

So all that remains to be proven then is if prison terms for apples to apples crimes are longer in the United States and if they have increased in the last few decades: https://prospect.org/article/six-charts-explain-why-our-prison-system-so-insane
State after state (and the federal government) in the '90s passed laws lengthening sentences for many crimes, particularly drug crimes. If you got convicted, you'd stay in prison far longer. About half the states also passed "three strikes and you're out" laws mandating that anyone convicted of a third felony would be sentenced to a long prison term—usually life or 25 years. Many states required the third felony to be a violent crime, but California's law was the most strict, requiring that any felony send a repeat offender to jail for 25 years to life.

In practice, this policy meant that people received life sentences for things like stealing a piece of pizza. After thousands of people received such terms, California voters amended the law in 2012 to require that the third conviction be a violent felony.
http://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-22912075

Contrast that with prison sentences in Norway, which carry a maximum penalty of 21 years as another extreme. You can literally chop up and eat a whole classroom of school children, say you'll do it again because you love the feeling you get watching the parent's reactions, and get a max of 21 years, with unsupervised parole after 7 years, and are typically released at 14 years, with few serving out a full 21 year sentence.

And I'm not saying that its even necessarily good or bad, I'm just pointing out information. We've seen massive drops in violent crime in the United States, while good law abiding citizens are seeing relaxed gun control and self-defense legislation siding with them in recent years, empowering the people against the small criminal element.
 
Its from a documentary I watched on US prisons. No offense mope, but with the availability of the internet, why not post a source instead of always just saying "that's wrong, I say so"? You do that in every thread, and I understand it takes ZERO effort to do so, but is a bit annoying. You also completely misread what I posted.

I know that we have more bodies in prison at any particular point in time, and I've said as much that our incarceration rate is very high. The reason though is not that we incarcerate a higher percentage of our population, but that each spends more time in prison, and this is common sense why the incarceration rate would increase accordingly.
My doctorate in criminology (which I've posted a screenshot of in the past in these threads and taken a lot of shit for that) makes me a source. If you don't want to believe the data I'm providing you, you are more than welcome to avail yourself of internet sources (which are non-academic, FYI, and don't carry as much weight as my professional statements regarding the subject matter. In an academic setting, citing even something as low-level as personal communication from me on a message board would have more worth than citing wikipedia, for example).

In any case, I did not misread your claim. I read your claim, evaluated it, and rejected the truth of your statement. I even provided a select few of your oft cited countries to illustrate the point of how far off from reality your statement is.

Here are the data again:
In 2008 our incarceration rate was roughly around 500 per 100,000. Since then it's nearly doubled (it currently sits around 700 total per 100,000 but 900 per 100,000 when strictly counting men. Females are a relatively insignificant part of our prison population although their rise is alarming--they only account for roughly 7% of our prisoners). Even back in the 50's, however, our crime rate and prison population were alarming compared to other countries. (Canada incarcerates around 100 per 100,000, UK around 150 per 100,000, and Germany around 75 per 100,000).
 
Back
Top