When a "review" is really a Press Release

Unfortunately, it seems as though almost every site is guilty of this. AnandTech recently did such an article on Seagate's 7200.9 hard drive. Even [H]ard|OCP is not innocent of this. I remember one such "article" on Intel's 65 nm process, which was essentially a roadmap and nothing concrete. I hope that these and other sites have learned their lesson based on reader responses.
 
xonik said:
Unfortunately, it seems as though almost every site is guilty of this. AnandTech recently did such an article on Seagate's 7200.9 hard drive. Even [H]ard|OCP is not innocent of this. I remember one such "article" on Intel's 65 nm process, which was essentially a roadmap and nothing concrete. I hope that these and other sites have learned their lesson based on reader responses.

I don't think HardOCP titled this as a "Review" but rather a "Technology Preview" coupled with some opinions.
 
I think that they're just trying to let you know what lies on the road ahead. I don't think anyone would look at this and think "I HAVE TO HAVE THIS NOW".

Technology previews are important to consumers because it gives them an idea of what is coming up. As long as they're not making recommendations based of these "previews"... I don't see a problem with it.

-Matt
 
Eh, good points, but I still don't care for it. Kyle Bennett has flamed The Inquirer for its rumors and future-looking articles, but what I see is pretty much the same thing from this article. Not to mention that there are many more PC industry companies who post roadmaps but got no coverage. Anyways, I'm glad that there haven't been more of these since then.
 
Back
Top