What's the Final Verdict on ATOM?

Ashton

2[H]4U
Joined
Nov 13, 2004
Messages
2,514
What's the verdict on the Atom? When it first came out all I could find was "DONT BUY IT!!!!" but I'm starting to see more positive reviews in more and more places now. Anyone have any hard-and-fast info, or is the jury still out?
 
Depends on what you'll be using it for. For say, file servers or just really basic web browsing and low energy status, sure go for it.

If you really want preformance, go for a BE-2400 or 4X50e from AMD. Beats the hell out of the atom for a few watts more.
 
I'm lookinjg at notebooks/netbooks, such as the EEE or Dell E, I have an EEE 701, purposefully avoiding the Atom because I heard it had heat problems, now it seems people are saying otherwise. I'm going to be in the market for a new work laptop soon and am seeing the Atom popping up more and more now.
 
It's great for what it does. You're not going to game or watch 1080p video on it. For web surfing, watching lower res video, and basic office use it's fine (the 1024x600 screen's the real bottleneck with thinks like excel). Nothing on the market comes close to doing as much with as small of a battery as the atom does. When it comes out, the via nano will probably have somewhat better performace, altough it's not expected to be quite as power miserly. Those assumptions could be wrong since the only hardware testers have gotten to play with are using last generation desktop chipsets. The atom's biggest liability powerwise is the old chipset that takes 3-4W of power at idle. If Via's new chipset does better there it could counter slightly higher idle numbers for the CPU itself.
 
I think it was an odd (idiotic?) choice Intel to spend the money developing a low power Atom processor and then pairing it up with the ancient, inefficient 945 chipset. Who cares what the chip uses if the chipset counteracts any benefits? And as I type this, I'm reading the post above mine - so I agree with DanNeely.

They should have developed a whole low power platform if they are going to take this market seriously. It's not like Intel couldn't afford the added R&D expense!
 
Atom is a nice chip. It just doesn't do well at heavy-lifting, so outside of more regular desktop stuff, including light gaming, it's a very anemic chip.

But hey, what do you expect from what is essentially an embedded CPU? :)
 
They should have developed a whole low power platform if they are going to take this market seriously. It's not like Intel couldn't afford the added R&D expense!

I suspect it was caution since intel wasn't sure how much of a market this chip would have when they started on it a few years ago. both thier existing ULV and Via's similar offerings never had anyhting beyond niche presences in the market. Assuming that the atom would be the same isn't unreasonable and I could see them deciding to hold off on a new chipset until they dieshunk the chip into the PDA power envelope. Afaik x86 across the entire line of CPU ranges has always been Intels long term objective with this chip. If they're not working on a chipset than can idle around 1v now they're just begging for someone else to clobber them in a year or two.
 
Was playing around with an EeePC 1000 and MSI Wind both with the N270 and it is more than adequate for handling tasks and even multitasking. Played WC3 and web-browsed without a hiccup until I got rid of them both after preordering the Sammy NC10. Faster than a Athlon XP mobile and Pentium M (think there was a Centrino sticker) notebook. I was very skeptical about 1core and wasn't going to jump on netbooks til the 2core Atoms but after playing around, well, I preordered another 1core netbook right? :D
 
Was playing around with an EeePC 1000 and MSI Wind both with the N270 and it is more than adequate for handling tasks and even multitasking. Played WC3 and web-browsed without a hiccup until I got rid of them both after preordering the Sammy NC10. Faster than a Athlon XP mobile and Pentium M (think there was a Centrino sticker) notebook. I was very skeptical about 1core and wasn't going to jump on netbooks til the 2core Atoms but after playing around, well, I preordered another 1core netbook right? :D

I'm thinking the multi-core hype is a load of bunk. I was doing from graphics work last night (very simple taking text and making it flow in a circle) and my dual-core, 64-bit 2.33ghz, 3gb ram beast froze for over 30 seconds to calculate even the simplest change (3px width resize)

As for generic tasks I see no need to worry about multi-core laptops. my Old Dell 8100 and my eee 701 both opperate excelently on single-core low end chips (both ~900mhz)

My biggest concern is with battery life and size in a notebook. While the eee is great for travel and personal use it's too small for major programming, and likewise I dont want a behemoth that is as large as my desktop's case... This is one reason I wa slooking at Atom because it was supposed to give such amazing battery life and still have decent performance
 
I wouldn't care multi-core all hype, but single core Atoms are more than capable of handling simple tasks. Atom isn't made for task-heavy programs and shouldn't be expected to be a substitute to beefier CPUs. While the Atoms have a low TDP, the chipset is old and inefficient - somewhere I read that the CPU drains 2w? but the mobo eats like 35w. Talking about notebooks btw... dunno about desktop Atoms.
 
lowtechk. You've got that backwards re powerdraw. At idle my wind draws ~7W total, full load is ~15W, it's the desktop model that's paired with the real power pig chipset.

I've seen the idle power broken down as: ~1W CPU, 2-3W LCD, 3-4W chipset. (numbers are approx and not all sources agreed)
 
I'm lookinjg at notebooks/netbooks, such as the EEE or Dell E, I have an EEE 701, purposefully avoiding the Atom because I heard it had heat problems, now it seems people are saying otherwise. I'm going to be in the market for a new work laptop soon and am seeing the Atom popping up more and more now.


See the big heatsink on the left? That's the chipset. The tiny heatsink on the right is what cools the Atom. It definitely doesn't have heat problems.

Atom rocks if you want to use it for home server stuff. Router, firewall, QoS, NAS, etc. I have yet to see anyone actually test the dual-core Atom system with a Radeon 4000 or 3000 series PCI card for H.264 decoding. In theory, it could work as a 1080p media center if one of those cards works.
 
I'm lookinjg at notebooks/netbooks, such as the EEE or Dell E, I have an EEE 701, purposefully avoiding the Atom because I heard it had heat problems, now it seems people are saying otherwise. I'm going to be in the market for a new work laptop soon and am seeing the Atom popping up more and more now.

The Dothan in the 701 is far hotter than any Atom.
 
Back
Top