What's the difference between the different cores and sockets??

Second

n00b
Joined
Apr 16, 2001
Messages
30
I just recently killed my old rig (T-Bird 1.4, Epox 8k7a, ect) and it's been a long while since I've kept up with what's out now a days or even half the stuff I learned when I built this system. I want to switch to intel and get away from AMD for my replacement cpu/mobo. The problem is I don't know what's different between the cores (Northwood, Prescott, etc.), how it relates to the different sockets, and not to mention all the different chipsets I see on these mobo's. Which is the newest core? And like what's the difference between a P4 2.8 GHZ prescott Socket: LGA 775, and a P4 2.8 GHZ prescott Socket: 478? And how do different chipsets factor into it? This kind of answer might not be easy to explain, but I don't mine reading if there is a FAQ or guide on this stuff I would really appriciate it, or if someone could just explain this to me. Thanks
 
First off, I would do another AMD setup as the current AMD 64's are for the most part kicking Intels ass no matter what CPU it is from them. Look at the current benchmarks and you'll see what I mean.

Northwood is Intels last years core that has been real popular due to its stabile and extreme overclocking potential with the right mobo and Ram. Prescrap was launched with a much longer pipeline, more cache and more embedded instructions. The end result however was a MAJOR power hog CPU that many boards wern't able to run due to the power requirements as well as the heat generated from it caused shockwaves of fustration through the industry. Its performance was also just as dissapointing, the exact same or even worse then the older Northwood cores. Prescotts are also more expensive.

Current Northwood CPU's and prescotts use the 478 pin intel socket. The chipsets are currently the 865, 875 with the new 915 chipsets coming out with PCI express, DDR2, T Socket 778, as well as host of other options.

These new boards are not compatible with current Northwood and Prescott cores. They also have the new "T" socket which has seen tremendous reliability problems as the pins are actually on the socket itself and not the CPU like it has been since day one of CPU's. Many people have resulted killing CPU's and mobo's as a result of poor alighnment or just plain bad luck from these sockets.

Also, pleminary testing shows that these new 915 chipset platforms are showing a very small increase over current Northwood CPU/chipset's and at a much higher price. In short, Intel has got problems, and they know it.

Athlon 64's has been, in short, kicking Intels ass. The new 939 pin versions offer dual Channel support for unregistered DDR memory. They come in the regular Athlon 64 flavor with locked multipliers and 512k cache and are cheaper and the FX's series have unlocked multipliers for more extreme overclocking and 1meg of cache.

The orginal 940 pin versions of the Opteron FX series had to used Registered memory which most people wern't to happy about. The 754 socket Athlons were the first ones to come out, and only support single channel RAM but have double the cache of the 939 pin versions. I"ll let the benchmarks speak for themselves on how well these platforms go against eachother, so I'll leave it to you to research for sake of keeping this post short.

Read up, research, ask questions, weigh your personal optoins and then plan.

Here are some benchmarks for more information

http://www.anandtech.com/cpuchipsets/showdoc.aspx?i=1965
http://www.anandtech.com/cpuchipsets/showdoc.aspx?i=1956
http://www.anandtech.com/cpuchipsets/showdoc.aspx?i=2056
http://www.anandtech.com/cpuchipsets/showdoc.aspx?i=2065
http://www.anandtech.com/cpuchipsets/showdoc.aspx?i=2091
http://www.anandtech.com/cpuchipsets/showdoc.aspx?i=2149
 
Intel based machines are easier to make stable and reliable. Not that an Athlon itself is unstable. I am speaking about the shitty board manufacturers that make Athlon boards. Most of them are crap and there are all the SIS/VIA/Nforce Driver issues.

With an Intel based machine you hook it up, load the drivers and your off and running. In my opinion it's a more headache free platform. The new LGA775 does suck. But with carefull installation of your CPU it has some advantages over socket 478. Such as not ripping the CPU out of the socket when you try and remove a fan and heatsink.

The Willamette core is old and not worth your time. Few boards support them and they only go up to about 2.2GHz anyway.

The Northwood has several versions. They are on a 400/533/800FSB buses and only models with 800MHz FSB support HT with the exception of the 3.06GHz 533MHz processor. It has HT enabled. The HT enabled 800MHz FSB parts are the ones to look to for the best performance. They run cool and OC like mad with the right board and ram. Popular combos are P4C800-E Deluxe (Asus) and IC7-MAX3 (Abit) with a 2.4C or 3.0C northwood. Those two chips are serious overclockers. 2.4's can hit 3.2+ and 3.0C's are able to do 3.6-3.8+ in some cases. Other Northwoods are great OC'ers too, but those two are very popular and come to mind.

The Northwood is highly overclockable as is Prescott. In reality the Prescott isn't that much slower than Northwood per clock cycle. Also as Prescotts increase in clock speed they eventually overtake the Northwood in performance. They feature more L2 cache, but that is likely to offset the 31 stage pipeline.
 
Sir-Fragalot said:
Intel based machines are easier to make stable and reliable. Not that an Athlon itself is unstable. I am speaking about the shitty board manufacturers that make Athlon boards. Most of them are crap and there are all the SIS/VIA/Nforce Driver issues.


A bit of over generalization. I attribute it to the hardware itself and not software related for many issues though software is a possiblity, don't get me wrong. SiS has been crap and will always been crap, so thats a given. The Via vs nForce war has been back and forth, many people will attribute that Nvidia's drivers are better while others will say VIA, so to say that they all suck is a bit presumptious. Its a matter of personal reference and experience.

Not to say that they both haven't had their issues. I don't don't care what manufactuer you are or what you make, you WILL have bad hardware or software at times, its a given. That being said, there are kick ass boards that run stabile and fast. Just ask all the people who run A64 setups, and their are ALOT.

To say that Intels boards are easier to setup and stabile may have been the case in the early Intel vs AMD years, but now, that argument no longer holds any water.
 
I think it does. From a percentage standpoint the issues I encounter with AMD vs. Intel are numerous to say the least. Chipset/driver issues are much more prominant on AMD based machines than Intels. Also amongst board manufacturers I'd say most boards are relativeley decent if they are built with Intel chipsets whereas most of the AMD boards out there would never find a home in a machine I own because they are crap.

That's not saying that all the Athlon based machines that come in are crap. Far from it. Our shop machine is an Athlon 64 3200+ and it's great. But the machines that come in that won't POST or have stability issues related to the mainboard are usually AMD systems.

One's with fried processors are always AMD unless the board and PSU are screwed as well. In which case something catastrophic occured and the CPU didn't survice. Intel CPU's are nearly indestructable when it comes to heat and voltage issues. (With the exception of internal vcore settings at 1.7 or higher.)

I think that the AMD 64 is a badass enthusiest CPU. But I don't recommend them for Joe Blow of for people building thier first system. Nor would I recommend socket LGA775 for first time builders either.

I think it's funny that when installing Windows on an Intel machine, before installing the chipset drivers the machine's perfectly stable. When installing on an AMD based machine they are unstable and or have odd quirks until the chipset drivers are installed. In which case the problems continue or they are resolved. Sometimes you've got to try different versions of the chipset drivers to solve the issues.

I can't stand that shit. The only boards I would consider for AMD based machines are MSI (If not OC'ing) Abit and Asus. Pretty much everything else has been a pain in the ass.

If a system has a fried board almost always the Intel CPU is good and in most cases if it's an AMD the CPU may be fried.

To give you an Idea I work in IT for my day job and I've got 500 machines to work with. 120 of which are Macs. We've got 3 or 4 AMD based machines with totally suck ass.

My second job as a service tech, I get all brands and types of machines. From what I see machines come in for and my experiences loading OS's and restoring machines, I'd say your average AMD based machine is crap. Only if the machine that was purchased is high end or it was custom built with quality parts from well established manufacturers is it not crap.

As an example I see alot of Dell machines even though we don't sell them and don't work on them under warranty. Depsite their reputation in the consumer sector I think they're crap. Then again so is Compaq and most brands in general.

This is just my experience which amounts to working on over 1000 different machines personally per year. My experiences between AMD and Intel have always been better on the Intel side. Fewer to no fried CPU's, less chipset driver issues and far better memory compatibility.
 
Back
Top