What's the difference between 2xAA and 4xAA ??

ShePearl

Limp Gawd
2FA
Joined
Apr 16, 2004
Messages
429
It's my understanding that 1080p with 4xSSAA works in 2x horizontal + 4x vertical, hence 4xSSAA.

1920x1080p with 4xSSAA = internally renders at 3840x2160p and scale it down to 1920x1080p.
1920 x2 = 3840 horizontal
1080 x2 = 2160 vertical.
Hence, 4xSSAA.

My question is... how about 2xSSAA ? Does 2x apply to horizontal or vertical only ?
 
You are apparently referring to the Transparency SuperSampling settings in the Nvidia Control Panel. Transparency SuperSampling is commonly referred to as TrSSAA or TRAA.

If you use Nvidia Inspector, you can choose 2x1, 1x2, 2x2, 3x3, and 4x4 SuperSampling, which is commonly referred to as SSAA, and is technically OGSSAA (ordered grid supersampling AA). It is made clear there what you are choosing.

Now that I've made clear what you are really asking, the answer to your question isn't simple because, while that's how SSAA works, it's not how MSAA and TrSSAA works. I don't understand this part well enough to be sure I have it right, but I think that what they do is only upsample part of the data instead of all of it.
 
Ok. Let me be more specific. There are games with in-game SSAA support. For example... Tomb Raider (2013).

Tomb Raider (2013) has 2xSSAA and 4xSSAA in the option.

1920x1080 resolution with 4xSSAA would mean...
1920 x 2 = 3840 horizontal
1080 x 2 = 2160 vertical.
Hence, 4xSSAA at 1080p would mean rendering at 3840x2160p internally, and scale down the image to 1920x1080p for output.

How about 2xSSAA in Tomb Raider ? The the factor x2 apply to horizontal or vertical ?
 
Oh, I see. It's quite rare for a game to support SSAA in its options. The only other game besides Tomb Raider that supports SSAA that I can find mention of is The Witcher 2 (they called it Uber-Sampling).

All the talk about Tomb Raider and SSAA is about bugs with TressFX and SSAA. Players of both TW2 and Tomb Raider have complained bitterly about huge performance hits with SSAA enabled. TW2 "optimized" the Uber-Sampling resulting in greatly improved performance, so I wouldn't be surprised if they switched from 2x2 to 2x1 or something like that.

The complaints about SSAA performance in Tomb Raider makes me think it's 2x2 and 4x4, especially comments like a guy with dual GTX 690 in Quad-SLI at 2560x1600 getting only 20 or 30 FPS with 4xSSAA. Now THAT sounds like 4x4 OGSSAA to me. The original form of AA is computationally extremely expensive, which is why you almost never see it in game options.
 
The HardOCP Tomb Raider review just went up. After seeing that no single-GPU card (with the possible exception of the GTX Titan) can handle 4x SSAA at 1920x1080 (see page 6, that is without TressFX), I'm feeling pretty confident in my assumption that Tomb Raider uses 2x2 and 4x4 OGSSAA.
 
The HardOCP Tomb Raider review just went up. After seeing that no single-GPU card (with the possible exception of the GTX Titan) can handle 4x SSAA at 1920x1080 (see page 6, that is without TressFX), I'm feeling pretty confident in my assumption that Tomb Raider uses 2x2 and 4x4 OGSSAA.
No. It's simple Mathematics.
Tomb Raider has 2xSSAA and 4xSSAA in the option. They're all OGSSAA,
2xSSAA is either 1x2 SSAA or 2x1 SSAA
4xSSAA is 2x2 SSAA.
There's no 8xSSAA (aka 4x4 SSAA) in Tomb Raider.
 
Back
Top