What Woz Thinks About Kim DotCom

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
It looks like Kim DotCom has a new cheerleader. This is kinda funny considering anyone that has ever used Megaupload (except Woz) knows exactly how and why it was used but hey, you can't blame DotCom for wanting a little celebrity support. ;)

"I scratch my head wondering why the studios went after the guy doing more than can be imagined to remove the links the studios wanted removed," Wozniak wrote. "Heck, I use my iDisk (MobileMe) and dropbox to share files by sending links to friends. They might even be copyrighted materials. I might even send a song in an e-mail to my son, although if I think he'll keep it I will use the 'Buy gift' feature in iTunes. But there are so many legitimate uses to peer-to-peer file sharing and cloud storage."
 
RIAA/MPAA have such big balls they'll probably go after the Woz too. There seems to be no extent as to who they'll go after.
 
Hahaha I'd like to see them go after him! That would be the day geeks rise and destroy the RIAA/MPAA!
 
Have you ever used Megaupload? If so how did you use it? If not... are you suggesting that anyone and everyone who used it is a pirate? That includes all the government employees and military folks that are registered users?

"anyone that has ever used Megaupload knows exactly how and why it was used"

I am sure some folks used it for less than honorable means... but I sincerely doubt it was anyone that has ever used it.

To hold Megaupload responsible is no more than trying to hold Youtube responsible for copyrighted material found on Youtube or gun manufactures for crimes committed while using guns. Or better yet... computer manufactures for all the cyber crime/hacking being committed cause all of that is done using computers.

And from the look of things... the government's case is less than air tight and the use of somewhat illegal and improper evidence gathering methods imo.

Sides there are folks who say all bittorrent users are pirates too... odd given that some companies use bittorrent or peer-to-peer to distribute patches/files.

The government should of gone after the uploaders... seems it's always the downloaders or the hosting company's fault over pirating... uploaders always gets ignored... guess cause that's not where the money is at.
 
I used Megaupload to download a lot of things. Drivers (old, new), custom drivers, INF files, etc., custom ROM's, custom software from someone with no means of distribution, things like that. Songs, movies and such I figured were there, but I never touched that side of it. There were plenty of legitimate uses. I know there were a lot of illegal uploads, too, but there is illegal content on DropBox, too. I'll bet there is child porn on DropBox folders, too...

There has to be some other reason other than content as to why they arrested and are after this guy.
 
They'll never go after Woz - he's got the funds to fight their extortion schemes.
 
I used Megaupload to download a lot of things. Drivers (old, new), custom drivers, INF files, etc., custom ROM's, custom software from someone with no means of distribution, things like that. Songs, movies and such I figured were there, but I never touched that side of it. There were plenty of legitimate uses. I know there were a lot of illegal uploads, too, but there is illegal content on DropBox, too. I'll bet there is child porn on DropBox folders, too...

There has to be some other reason other than content as to why they arrested and are after this guy.

There's a theory that since DotCom is supposedly opening his own company to help musicians and artists break away from the RIAA that he became a target BY the RIAA. Since the RIAA and MPAA seem to own a large portion of Congress and the Senate there are rumors that this is why he got busted, because they don't want someone coming along and destroying them with better ideas.

Again, its all just a theory, but considering how outrageous this has gotten and all the bullshit the government has come up with it doesn't seem so crazy...and plus, its not like our government hasn't done stuff like this before!!!
 
I only ever used MegaUpload to share legitimately acquired Linux ISOs with friends. :)
 
guess it's time to shut down the post office, roads, storage units, shipping companies they are all directly responsible for anything trafficked and stored in their systems.
 
Youtube/Google is responsible for copyrighted material found on Youtube. They get takedown requests and infringement cases all the time. Should be same rules for Megaupload. Same rules for me (and HardOCP). I would be a multimillionaire otherwise, having been at it for decades.:eek:
 
I've gotten manuals, drivers, game saves, mods, How To's and all sorts of stuff via MegaUpload and various torrents. I haven't "aquired" anything that wasn't mine in over a decade.
 
I would love to chime in on how much I personally have used mega-upload but I don't want to incriminate myself. So I'll just say I know where Steve is coming form but I also see where Bettie is coming from.
 
Youtube/Google is responsible for copyrighted material found on Youtube. They get takedown requests and infringement cases all the time. Should be same rules for Megaupload. Same rules for me (and HardOCP). I would be a multimillionaire otherwise, having been at it for decades.:eek:

Yes but so did Megaupload. Why go after Dotcom and not the owners of Youtube/Google? Why dont the government raid their offices and seize their servers? There are tons of copyrighted material on Youtube... and yes it gets taken down when asked. Same for Megaupload.
 
Megaupload also provided copyright holders those tools for sending takedown requests, and complied with takedown requests, and has paperwork behind them all.

Youtube/Google is responsible for copyrighted material found on Youtube. They get takedown requests and infringement cases all the time. Should be same rules for Megaupload. Same rules for me (and HardOCP). I would be a multimillionaire otherwise, having been at it for decades.:eek:
 
Kim DotCom is a scumbag. Everything I ever read about Woz made me have a lot of respect for him. Until this--now I respect him just a bit less.

I don't care about why MU was really taken down, it doesn't change the fact that DC is a DB, and I'd be perfectly happy if he rots in a jail cell for how he conducted his business life until now.

Aside: I think we all know that the MU take-down was totally illegit, and was just an act of desperation by the dying record labels that have clearly padded the pockets of a few important people...
 
Aside: I think we all know that the MU take-down was totally illegit, and was just an act of desperation by the dying record labels that have clearly padded the pockets of a few important people...

Lost not mix up important with powerful. They have lots of power but if they all died society wouldn't miss them. :D
 
Did any of you guys actually follow the case when Kim was arrested? The reason they don't go after youtube etc is that they actually take stuff down when it is reported. Megaupload was not only not taking stuff down, they would generate new links for it and even pay, straight up pay, people to upload knowingly pirated content. This was documented in internal emails amongst top level employees, and common policy. Why megaupload over other pirate services? They operated within ( <--key) the US and were the largest of the services, so why not go for the biggest fish, especially when the head of it (aka dotcom) is known for being a huge POS (google him, making hundreds of millions of dollars on pirated stuff via megaupload was not his first trip into scummy dealings). As for Steve's comment and the responses, I was suprised when they shutdown the service as to how many people claimed to use it for legit files. I, along with literally everyone I knew who had used it, only ever used it to DL illegal stuff. I don't think there was any conspiracy at play here. They just went after the biggest pirate service that actually had a base in the US. I'm honestly suprised Woz would want to deal with this guy at all, and have to think he is a bit nieve to the extent of Kim's criminal history.
 
Did any of you guys actually follow the case when Kim was arrested? The reason they don't go after youtube etc is that they actually take stuff down when it is reported. Megaupload was not only not taking stuff down, they would generate new links for it and even pay, straight up pay, people to upload knowingly pirated content. This was documented in internal emails amongst top level employees, and common policy. Why megaupload over other pirate services? They operated within ( <--key) the US and were the largest of the services, so why not go for the biggest fish, especially when the head of it (aka dotcom) is known for being a huge POS (google him, making hundreds of millions of dollars on pirated stuff via megaupload was not his first trip into scummy dealings). As for Steve's comment and the responses, I was suprised when they shutdown the service as to how many people claimed to use it for legit files. I, along with literally everyone I knew who had used it, only ever used it to DL illegal stuff. I don't think there was any conspiracy at play here. They just went after the biggest pirate service that actually had a base in the US. I'm honestly suprised Woz would want to deal with this guy at all, and have to think he is a bit nieve to the extent of Kim's criminal history.

Yeah, the issue wasn't that MU was hosting illegal content (as they had a well-documented paper trail of take-downs). The issue was that they'd comp., subsidize, and promote heavy-traffic accounts--accounts that they knew were hosting illegally-posted files--in order to attract more traffic, and reward the heavy-traffic user accounts. So essentially knowingly and willingly advertising pirated content. That was the issue that most people seem to have glossed over when it happened (and oddly enough, the reason he was taken down in the first place). MU servers (funnily enough, they bought server time from a larger company) merely possessing illegal content was not the legal reasons that the site was taken down.

I do believe, however, that the force with which he was met was not proportional to what he (and others at MU) was conducting. I think he's a douchebag slimeball, and people like him do nothing but bad things for companies and economies, and they're just out to reap the most money even if it means screwing over thousands of people, but at the same time, all of the circumstances surrounding it (the alleged music service claimed to being launched soon--alleged), is a bit too convenient to ignore completely.

He's still a douchebag.
 
I only ever used MegaUpload to share legitimately acquired Linux ISOs with friends. :)

Lol! Me too! :)

Did any of you guys actually follow the case when Kim was arrested? The reason they don't go after youtube etc is that they actually take stuff down when it is reported. Megaupload was not only not taking stuff down, they would generate new links for it and even pay, straight up pay, people to upload knowingly pirated content. This was documented in internal emails amongst top level employees, and common policy.

This.

No one likes this type of take down by the U.S, the lame $500M in losses claim, the way he was raided, etc. etc. etc. but there is no way in hell I would be caught defending Kim DotCom.
 
Lol! Me too! :)



This.

No one likes this type of take down by the U.S, the lame $500M in losses claim, the way he was raided, etc. etc. etc. but there is no way in hell I would be caught defending Kim DotCom.

I am trying to be somewhat reserved over this matter, myself. If it turns out that what he did was legal, then I reckon that I am going to start one up. Perhaps, though, I will donate much of the profit to charity or something. Maybe ditch it when I get to the first million.
 
Maybe just an old hacker thinking that the feds came down to hard on Kim Dotcom.

People don't seem to remember that the first Woz/Jobs "collaboration" was when Woz built a blue box (a device to steal free long distance phone calls) and Jobs noticed it and said "we should sell this".
 
Woz is awesome. Always interesting to hear what he has to say. And yet again, he makes a valid point.
 
Back
Top