What is wrong with my video card??!

slowbiz

2[H]4U
Joined
Aug 24, 2004
Messages
2,457
Here's my problem.

I just bought Doom 3 along with a new Nvidia GeForce FX 5900XT card with 128MB memory. The game looks amazing and runs smoothly until I encounter any enemies. Then it runs really choppy and I end up dying because I can't see what's happening. The strange thing about this all, is that I've tried the game on about every quality setting you can change, and it runs just the same on high quality as it does on low quality. Smooth until any battles. It's really annoying because the video card was expensive and I thought I would get to run high end games with it just fine. Also, I just got Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic, and it's the same thing there. The game runs sketchy when there's a battle scene, but I'm surpassing the system requirements by quite a bit.

Can someone help me out and point out my retardation?

Oh yeah, I had another question too.
Does your cpu's FSB limit the speed your memory runs at ever? My FSB is 400, and I think it's making my ram run at 266 MHz instead of 400.

Intel Pentium 4 2.0 GHz, 400 MHz FSB
ECS 848P-A Motherboard
512 MB of PC3200 ram
Nvidia GeForce FX 5900XT 128 MB
WD 80 GB, 7200rpm, 2mb buffer Hard Drive
LG 8X DVD-RAM drive
The need to play Rise of the Triad again.
 
Well, i would say your processor is holding you back significantly. The cpu has a lot less to do when there are no enemies on the screen. It doesn't have to do the AI and the physics and can just focus on the rendering of the screen. ( i could be way off). My brother was having similar problems with his athlon xp 2000+ setup. No enemies, it would run fine. As soon as something came at him, it was a slide show. The thing that worked for him was a cpu upgrade.

You should be able to check what your ram is running at by downloading a program called cpu-z from www.cpuid.com . It has a memory tab that tells you everything you need to know about your ram. Get it and see if it is running at 266DDR.
 
That's a good little program.

It's saying that my memory is running at these specs.

Frequency - 133 MHz
FSB : DRAM - 3:4
CAS# LATENCY - 2.5 clocks
RAS# to CAS# delay - 3 clocks
RAS# precharge - 3 clocks
Cycle Time (tras) - 6 clocks

I don't know what any of that means. I just know that my bios is running the ram on an automatic setting. How should I change it.

I'm still confused about the doom thing... how can it be my cpu? After reading the doom 3 hardware guide, I figured that I should be able to run the game smoothly under 640x480 at low quality settings. But it runs literally the same at that setting as it does at 1024x768 at high quality. This is screwed up. I don't want to buy a new cpu.

BTW, one of my favorite bands is from New Mexico... The Shins. You're lucky if you see them live.
 
slowbiz said:
But it runs literally the same at that setting as it does at 1024x768 at high quality.

Thats because your even more cpu limited at lower resolutions.
 
See what happens if you turn off the fastwrites option in the bios. Also, set the AGP aperature size to about half of your RAM and see what happens (if it isn't already there that is.) I personally had serious issues with it freezing up exactly as you described when I had fastwrites on. The problem went away and the game ran smoothly as one could expect for a 9600 Pro (what I had at the time) the moment I turned off fast writes.

About the memory speed, yes, PC3200 ram should be running at 200x2, aka 400 just like your FSB supposedly is. Change the ratio setting to 1:1 (or an equivalent like 3:3 4:4 or whatever the board calls it.) The thing I'm wondering about there is the fact that 3:4 doesn't sound like the correct ratio at all to me. Are you SURE your FSB is 200x2 (400)? You may want to check that too... I'm not so great at doing the math for those ratios in my head, but, that makes me think you are running 166x2 instead for your FSB.


Oh, and you aren't MORE cpu limited at lower resolutions. Merely, it's the same, so, you will see a minimal loss of FPS at higher resolutions since the effect of the CPU is the same until you run into the point where the video card itself can't keep up. In other words, it's really more accurate to say it the other way around -- that the cpu limitation is more obvious at lower resolutions.
 
Comdey "Should have bought a 9800pro/XT" option :D

I'd also opt for uninstalling the drivers, running driver cleaner and re-installing them. Possibly reinstalling your chipset drivers too boot.
 
I also recommend, if nothing else works, doing a fresh install of XP (or 2000). It solved some performance issues of mine last night.
 
With it getting into battle and slowing down like that, it usually points to an issue on the CPU end, since that where AI is done. The above information is correct in telling you to be sure all of your BIOS settings are correct. A fresh install of XP wouldn't hurt either.
 
That's an interesting problem...

I agree that is sounds like CPU limitation, but I am wodering about that 5900XT. Remember that nVidia did it opposite of ATi. The 5900XT is a lower version of their card and I wonder how that it affecting your game play. Anand shows a 5900Ultra pulling only ~50FPS (average) when not CPU limited. If I remember correctly, the 5900XT actually performs a good bit less than a 5900Ultra.

Anyone got a good review with the 5900XT in Doom3?
 
Nazo said:
About the memory speed, yes, PC3200 ram should be running at 200x2, aka 400 just like your FSB supposedly is. Change the ratio setting to 1:1 (or an equivalent like 3:3 4:4 or whatever the board calls it.) The thing I'm wondering about there is the fact that 3:4 doesn't sound like the correct ratio at all to me. Are you SURE your FSB is 200x2 (400)? You may want to check that too... I'm not so great at doing the math for those ratios in my head, but, that makes me think you are running 166x2 instead for your FSB.
With a 400mhz fsb cpu (100x4) ddr is supposed to run at 266
533fsb= ddr333
800fsb=ddr400=pc3200(this is why p4s benifit from dual channel)

the board is running the memory as it should be for that CPU.
you can try changing the ratio if its available on that board i dunno but i doubt youll get much performance increase running it asynchronously.
however you should be able to tighten up those latency timings.
 
Rori said:
That's an interesting problem...

I agree that is sounds like CPU limitation, but I am wodering about that 5900XT. Remember that nVidia did it opposite of ATi. The 5900XT is a lower version of their card and I wonder how that it affecting your game play. Anand shows a 5900Ultra pulling only ~50FPS (average) when not CPU limited. If I remember correctly, the 5900XT actually performs a good bit less than a 5900Ultra.

Anyone got a good review with the 5900XT in Doom3?

Well, I'm using a PCX 5900, which is just a 5900 XT for PCI-Express. The card is not top-notch, but it's pretty good at what it does. I can play KotOR without freezes when I see enemies (though it does slow down a touch). Doom 3 runs pretty much fine for me, too.

2 things though that will make your gaming experience a touch better:

1) Overclock that sucker. The XT is renouned for its overclocking potential, which is why nVidia stopped distribution after a short time.

2) For Doom 3, if you're not already doing it, use the image cache tweak. A quick guide:
- Open up your doom 3 config file (should be in the Doom3\Base directory)
- set the following variables to the values listed:
- seta image_useCache "1"
- seta image_cacheMegs "128"
- seta image_cacheMinK "20480"
I can almost guarantee this will bump your framerate up while walking around, and you might be able to play high quality without seeing performance hits (or at least acceptable ones); however, if the problem really is that you're CPU-limited, then it will not help during battles.
 
Mine does that too, you know what helps? The damn ram. I have 512mb of ram and it craps out and loads/page files like no other. Even sometimes i'll run into random slowdowns (rare but happens) and the game will just drop to about 25 frames per second. Then, however, I look down and my Hard drive LED is on yet there is nothing in the backround. Guess what that is? PAGE FILING *PUKES*. Try running a gig of ram . I will be as soon as I can afford it. Also, when I exit the game, it takes like five minutes because of the ram (or lack thereof). When things are loaded in, I notice the games speeds up significantly. This may, or may not be your problem, but i'm sure it will help.

PS. Your processor isn't exacly the fastest, so i'd recommend overclocking that, getting a new CPU/Motherboard combo, or the fastest that your board can handle. I would recommend overclocking if you aren't afraid.
 
Vermicious Knid said:
With a 400mhz fsb cpu (100x4) ddr is supposed to run at 266
533fsb= ddr333
800fsb=ddr400=pc3200(this is why p4s benifit from dual channel)

the board is running the memory as it should be for that CPU.
you can try changing the ratio if its available on that board i dunno but i doubt youll get much performance increase running it asynchronously.
however you should be able to tighten up those latency timings.

Lots of good info here, thanks guys.

What should I change the latency timings to? My computer is completely free of overclocking, because I'm not sure how far it would be safe to push it, and for that matter, how to push it. The video card has an overclocking program with it, but I don't know what I should set it to. Can anyone help me out with that? :confused:

Also, there was no fastwrites option in my bios. Is there another name for it? Also, I set my AGP aperature size to 256. Is that alright for my 128 mb card? What does that do?
 
AGP aperature is the amount of system memory the system can reserve for holding textures/etc to transfer over to AGP later. In other words, a sort of buffer to try to sort of increase your effective total ram to the video card + that buffer. Of course, system memory used to be so much slower it wasn't hardly any help at all, but, with memory getting faster these days, it's a lot less useless if something uses is right. Anyway, everyone says that the rule of thumb is to set it to half of your actual physical ram (probably it never actually uses the full amount you set, just that it is able to) so if you have 512MB, then 256MB is correct, but if you have 1GB, you might want to set it to 512MB.

Anyway, sorry about the whole memory timing thing. I forgot that Intel was using a 4x multiplier instead of 2x like I'm used to. Still I really don't understand why memory at 133 is synchronize to a fsb at 100 when it even explicitely says 3:4 ratio... Well, anyway, most people see the largest benefits from 1:1 memory ratios and a really high FSB. You'd need to at least get your FSB up to 133 to make this work right though. You can try it and see what happens though, it's nearly impossible to damage a processor or anything that way, and, that's probably one of those Intels that underclock themselves if they hit the 50C range anyway. That memory is fine until 200MHz (unless it's crap like mine, then 183 or so...) So just overclock to whatever your board/cpu can handle. And, if it turns out that 3:4 really isn't synchronous after all, you might see some small benefit to changing the ratios around to get that memory up to 200 versus what you were using before (then again, synchronous might be overall more beneficial.)

As for fastwrites, I'm amazed it's not in your BIOS. I've seen it from pretty far back. Oh well, I don't believe there's another name for it, so if you don't see it, maybe it's basically already off due to just not being available to that system for whatever reason. Probably not a big deal.
 
Nazo, he is runing FSB: DRAM @ 3:4 100:133, yes i may have mispoken saying it was 'syncronous' but it is Intel's spec.
setting it to 1:1 would actually REDUCE his memory bandwidth(would lower it down to ddr200 instead of current ddr266)

as for the memory timings try reducing them one at a time, testing the system for stability after each change(prime95, 3dmark, whatever)
ie: try 2-3-3-6 first then if that works try 2-2-3-6... i think 2-2-2-5 is as low as you can go

Depending on the quality of the ram you may or may not be stable at any of these regardless of the mhz its running at.

if your going to try this or overclocking the cpu, just make sure you know where the bios reset jumper(find it in mobo manual) is beforehand incase you set something to high and the system fails to boot, dont panic just reset the BIOS and all will be well again.


as for wether or not any of this will solve your original problem: I know not, but at least youll be learning how to tweeeeek :)
 
With your memory being ddr400 running at 266 it wouldn't surprise me if you could push 2-2-2-5. That's a severe underclock, and I'm guessing it would accept it, although it's not guaranteed. That is undoubtably why you're seeing the skipping and "slideshow". Your cpu can't talk to everything fast enough. getting another 512mb of ram wouldn't hurt, but before you go throwing that in there, consider whether you'll be keeping the computer around for a while, or upgrading soon? If you plan on upgrading any time in the near future, you might as well get a new motherboard/processor and snag the ram with it. Although it would be a noticable boost. Just my 0.02.
 
Did you make sure you restarted the game completely when you changed resolutions? What detail level are trying to run in?
 
Intel Pentium 4 2.0 GHz, 400 MHz FSB
512 MB of PC3200 ram

The combination of these two is your bottleneck, especially the RAM.

Also, try to install XP SP2 -- it really made a difference on my system, gained 10fps in most games.
 
NowhereMan said:
Intel Pentium 4 2.0 GHz, 400 MHz FSB
512 MB of PC3200 ram

The combination of these two is your bottleneck, especially the RAM.
the bottleneck of those two is the CPU not the RAM

checked out the mobo specs, has a 848P chipset, basically the same as an 865 minus the dual channel memory... if your looking to upgrade, you can get a 3.0ghz 800fsb pentium4 for less then $200.
 
Vermicious Knid said:
the bottleneck of those two is the CPU not the RAM

512RAM is a bottleneck when you play games like Doom3 and FarCry. But like I said, it is a combination of the two.
 
Vermicious Knid said:
Nazo, he is runing FSB: DRAM @ 3:4 100:133, yes i may have mispoken saying it was 'syncronous' but it is Intel's spec.
setting it to 1:1 would actually REDUCE his memory bandwidth(would lower it down to ddr200 instead of current ddr266)

That's why I was saying he'd have to raise the FSB to make 1:1 a viable option... From what people say, 1:1 is FAR better due to a lot of timing latencies and all involved.

Anyway, if you can't get the FSB up high enough to do any real good, then, look and see if there are other options for changing the ratio. If you could get the memory up to 200x2, it could do a lot better. Remember that if you set it up to a higher frequency, you'd be well advised to first set the timings back to manufacturer recommended settings, then, after testing the stability of the higher clock on your system, slowly step the timings down. However, keep an eye on your benchmarks and things. Memory is often best run at it's intended timings unless the target timings are radically different. I read a whole little article about why this is so (basically comes down to effectively "shutting the book before the reader/writer is done with it.") So, I tested quite thoroughly and discovered that it was indeed true even at such a low speed (at the time I was running it on my system that didn't support memory ratios, so the highest I ever saw was roughly 145, and that was with a pretty high FSB overclock that was just barely stable.) With the lower latency setting 2-2-2-5, it had a slightly lower bandwidth than with the intended settings of 2-2-2-6. I figure you'd have to have ram intended for something high like 12 and be setting it low like 6 for this to actually make the memory work better that way.

BTW, with my crappy memory, I could set it to DDR400 speeds, but, it would ALWAYS mess up after over an hour even when I set the timings well above what the manufacturer recommended. So be sure to prime95 for a good while when stability testing. I'd recommend a minimum of an hour and fifteen minutes as that is what it took to expose the weaknesses in this ram.
 
Ok, to try and answer all the questions at once...

I'm running direct x 9.0c
I did the SP2 update
I've got all the bios, and videocard updates.
I'm running the game at medium detail at 1024x768

Where can I get a 3 ghz P4 cpu for under 200? I think I'm going to buy a new cpu and another 512MB stick.
 
Back
Top