What is difference between Caviar Green and Black?

rjolin01

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Aug 31, 2008
Messages
1,399
I keep hearing, and by hearing I mean reading, people say that the Western Digital Caviar Green is for low power useage and that Caviar Black is for gaming and faster accessing. My question is why is this? They both have 32mb cache and are 7200RPM HDD's. What make the Black worth the extra $10? I want to get a 1TB HDD, but I use my PC equally for gaming as web browsing.
 
The Green isn't a 7200 RPM drive. AFAIK Western Digital doesn't quote a rotational speed for the green series, but it's widely believed to be 5400 RPM. The Greens are generally much slower than the Blacks, while using less power and making less noise. The Blue series however, do run at 7200 RPM, and have speeds much closer to the Black drives than to the Greens. Mainly slower in seek times due to the Black series have dual actuators, allowing them to center the head on a particular track more quickly. Again, using more power and making more noise.

Dustin
 
So blue is middle ground? This is probaly best for my need as far as part time gaming and part time browsing? Or is the greens 32mb cache make it faster than the blues 8/16mb cache?
 
Blacks have dual processors are well, not sure if the Blues have them.
 
I also read that Caviar Black is better than a Raptor? If rotational speed is more important wouldnt a raptor with say 16mb be better than a Caviar Black?
 
The Raptors are faster in random seeks and responsiveness thanks to their 10,000RPM speed. But modern 7200RPM drives with 333GB or 500GB platters can have higher sustained transfer rates (large files). Much better value in my opinion.
 
So in short I should just get the 1TB caviar Black I been eye'n? Just want something that boots decently, forgot that part in OP, and wont take forever to load games or programs.
 
I switched back to 7200RPM drives from my WD740ADFD Raptor and I don't miss it at all. The difference isn't as apparent as it used to be, the new hotness is SSD and the Raptors just don't make sense financially these days (even moreso than before). Go for the Black.
 
If you're planning to use the drive as your main apps/games/OS drive, then get the Black. If you plan on using it as a storage drive (speed is not important), then go for the Green. The difference is that the Green runs quieter, cooler, uses less power, and is also slower in terms of seek/access/write speeds.
 
Greens aren't really meant to be OS drives at all. They are slow, cool and quiet (really quiet, however for your average rig you can't hear the difference). One shouldn't really use them as anything other than archiving. For my own rig I pair my WD20EADS up with a 300G VR as OS and doc.
 
Greens aren't really meant to be OS drives at all. They are slow, cool and quiet (really quiet, however for your average rig you can't hear the difference). One shouldn't really use them as anything other than archiving. For my own rig I pair my WD20EADS up with a 300G VR as OS and doc.

Right, although they can serve a bigger purpose than just archiving. I have my two WD10EADS drives storing my photos, music, and video collections. They're more than fast enough for playing videos, music, or browsing the photos.
 
Black drives has dual core processors in them, more cache, and both ends of the spindle shaft are secured (other drives have one end secured). I don't think the greens or blues have more than a 3 year warranty...the blacks have a 5 year on them.
 
Back
Top