What does it mean when....

pigpen

2[H]4U
Joined
Aug 17, 2004
Messages
2,408
My system keeps crashing when i have two sticks of generic ram running in Dual Channel, but runs stable as a horse when i take one of the sticks out. Is it a timings issue? Is there some kind of config that needs to be done that i'm missing? Is it board failure?

Any help would be greatly appreciated!
 
Oh yeah, this is when everything is running stock also. I've never run dual chanel before, but i've had these two sticks together running single and they both are in good working order.
 
Are they identical sticks of RAM? If not, they probably have slightly different timings.

You could try switching which is in the first slot..

Or manually relaxing your timings.

Or raising the RAM voltage.

Is this a Athlon XP, P4 or Athlon 64 system?
If it is an Athlon XP, don't bother with Dual Channel, running them both on the same channel will give you identical performance. (within 1-2%)

P4 or Athlon 64 it is worth trying to get it working.

==>Lazn
 
Thankyou very much for replying. It's a P4. They are not identical (if by identical you mean the same manufacturer.) The timings is something i thought about too. Will different timings cause an error with Dual Channel? Will relaxing decrease the performance gain from running dual channel? By relaxing, do you mean manually setting them equal to each other. The one i have in there right now is 2.5;3;3;6. Haven't looked at the other. Would it be correct thinking to set both equal, using the lowest common denominator?

Thankyou very much for your help. Wrestling with a new board install for 4 hours and making absolutely no progress can be wicked stressful. :(

Lazn_Work said:
Are they identical sticks of RAM? If not, they probably have slightly different timings.

You could try switching which is in the first slot..

Or manually relaxing your timings.

Or raising the RAM voltage.

Is this a Athlon XP, P4 or Athlon 64 system?
If it is an Athlon XP, don't bother with Dual Channel, running them both on the same channel will give you identical performance. (within 1-2%)

P4 or Athlon 64 it is worth trying to get it working.

==>Lazn
 
pigpen said:
Thankyou very much for replying. It's a P4. They are not identical (if by identical you mean the same manufacturer.) The timings is something i thought about too. Will different timings cause an error with Dual Channel? Will relaxing decrease the performance gain from running dual channel? By relaxing, do you mean manually setting them equal to each other. The one i have in there right now is 2.5;3;3;6. Haven't looked at the other. Would it be correct thinking to set both equal, using the lowest common denominator?

Thankyou very much for your help. Wrestling with a new board install for 4 hours and making absolutely no progress can be wicked stressful. :(

You got the idea. And yes relaxing timings to the least common denominator is the best thing to try, it will decrease performance some, but not as much as dual channel with increase performance for a P4.

You may be stuck having to sell what you got and buy a pair of identical sticks though (same MFG, same series, or a matched pair)

==>Lazn
 
Lazn_Work said:
You may be stuck having to sell what you got and buy a pair of identical sticks though (same MFG, same series, or a matched pair)==>Lazn

:(

I can live with that. Having a bunk board would be much worse, so it's not all that bad. Thankyou for the help though. I'll mess with the timings as soon as i get home.
 
So, all these headaches trying to troubleshoot and i end up isolating the problem on accident. Basically, something is faulty with the first DIMM slot. Put one stick in the 1st bank, windows crashes. Take that same stick and put it into the 2nd (leaving the 1st empty) stable. Am i correct that this is a problem with the board and not something that can be fixed with a bios tweak or something of the like?
 
pigpen said:
So, all these headaches trying to troubleshoot and i end up isolating the problem on accident. Basically, something is faulty with the first DIMM slot. Put one stick in the 1st bank, windows crashes. Take that same stick and put it into the 2nd (leaving the 1st empty) stable. Am i correct that this is a problem with the board and not something that can be fixed with a bios tweak or something of the like?

It unfortunatly sounds like it. You can try a different memory stick, or upping the voltage, but that does sound like a bad DIMM Slot. (make sure nothing is touching the MB improperly too, like a misplaced standoff in the case)

Now you get the fun job of RMAing the board.

==>Lazn
 
Lazn_Work said:
Now you get the fun job of RMAing the board.

==>Lazn

gotta love the egg. I emailed them about the situation and they offered to refund instead of just a return. think i'll try a different manufacturer this time (was a jetway.)

thankyou for all your help Lazn!
 
Back
Top