What do you think about this upgrade?

Ruffian998

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jul 18, 2004
Messages
211
About three years ago I believe, maybe 2 and half, I'm not quite sure, I built my cousin a computer:

P4 2.4C
Abit IS7-E
2x256mb PC3200 Corsair Value Select
Geforce Ti4200 128mb

Well anyways, he's wondering what he can do to upgrade his computer and I feel like he's pretty much in a tough spot. Yeah he could get a new processor, but then he'd also have to get a new videocard to notice any difference in games and with AGP pretty much gone, I feel his best bet is to go with a full revamp.

So I recommended a new computer to him and I was wondering what you all thought about this setup:

AMD 64 3500+
Asus A8N-E (I'm a fan of Asus, I currently own an A8V, but I'm open to suggestions on this)
2x512mb of PC3200 Corsair Value Select
eVGA 6800GS 256mb PCI-E
ENERMAX Whisper II EG465P-VE 460W Power Supply

Do to price constraints, the 3500+ will most likely be the highest he'll go in terms of CPU, but I was wondering what you all thought about the motherboard, maybe your alls recommendations. Also, I read somewhere on Anandtech that there might be an announcement of a 7800GS soon? They mentioned they found support for it in the latest batch of drivers from Nvidia. Also, what do you all know about that powersupply? Here's the link for it:

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?item=N82E16817103464

All comments and suggestions will be greatly appreciated.
 
I realize its far from upgradeable, but what I'm saying is if I were to upgrade him, the costs wouldnt be much different.

Intel P4 3.4E - 282.80
Geforce 6800GT AGP (similar to the 6800GS) - $300 +

plus a new powersupply because he'll need one with the new videocard anyway, plus he wants the extra ram as well.

So I just cant justify just upgrading his current computer with it will cost around the same to give him a new one with better upgrade potential plus better overall performance since he'd be making the switch to AMD. But if you have any other suggestions, please make them.
 
Ruffian998 said:
About three years ago I believe, maybe 2 and half, I'm not quite sure, I built my cousin a computer:

P4 2.4C
Abit IS7-E
2x256mb PC3200 Corsair Value Select
Geforce Ti4200 128mb

Well anyways, he's wondering what he can do to upgrade his computer and I feel like he's pretty much in a tough spot. Yeah he could get a new processor, but then he'd also have to get a new videocard to notice any difference in games and with AGP pretty much gone, I feel his best bet is to go with a full revamp.

So I recommended a new computer to him and I was wondering what you all thought about this setup:

AMD 64 3500+
Asus A8N-E (I'm a fan of Asus, I currently own an A8V, but I'm open to suggestions on this)
2x512mb of PC3200 Corsair Value Select
eVGA 6800GS 256mb PCI-E
ENERMAX Whisper II EG465P-VE 460W Power Supply

Do to price constraints, the 3500+ will most likely be the highest he'll go in terms of CPU, but I was wondering what you all thought about the motherboard, maybe your alls recommendations. Also, I read somewhere on Anandtech that there might be an announcement of a 7800GS soon? They mentioned they found support for it in the latest batch of drivers from Nvidia. Also, what do you all know about that powersupply? Here's the link for it:

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?item=N82E16817103464

All comments and suggestions will be greatly appreciated.



That's almost the same system I had....except I had a Radeon 9700. I was considering my upgrade paths too, and basically it boiled down to getting a better AGP graphics card and perhaps some RAM. When I thought about it, I realized that this upgrade would have to hold me over till at least Windows Vista came along...which would be the end of next year and I'd have to manage playing some really nice games at very crappy frame rates for another year. I decided I'd rather spend the money on a more upgradeable path than to just plunk it down on a good grfx card alone and just went ahead and bought a new system (see sig). I don't think u can upgrade him. Get him a new sys!
 
Not really quite sure what his budget is, he never really told me. I just showed him this config because I know its not anything below what I would get at the moment. I might ask him how high he wants to go and see if he might want to get a 7800GT for more playability on down the road since he doesnt really upgrade all that much.
 
That system is easily upgradeable.

Buying a 6800GT and a 3.4 is a bit overkill.

You can get a 3.0 P4 with HT for $184, and a Radeon 9800pro for $100. $50 for an extra 512 of RAM, and you have a system that can handle any game that is out right now or will come out in the next year.
 
I certainly wouldn't upgrade to a nearly 3 year old 9800 Pro that's for sure.

Seems like this guy doesn't upgrade often really so you need something that lasts. I would make sure to put 2 gigs of ram in that system if he's going to wait another
3 years to upgrade.

It doesn't need to be expensive ram, Corsair value select will get it done.

Other than that it's mainly about he much he wants to spend. I would certainly get nothing lower than say the PCI-E GeForce 6 or Radeon X8xx series
 
ThisMonsterLives said:
I certainly wouldn't upgrade to a nearly 3 year old 9800 Pro that's for sure.

Seems like this guy doesn't upgrade often really so you need something that lasts. I would make sure to put 2 gigs of ram in that system if he's going to wait another
3 years to upgrade.

It doesn't need to be expensive ram, Corsair value select will get it done.

Other than that it's mainly about he much he wants to spend. I would certainly get nothing lower than say the PCI-E GeForce 6 or Radeon X8xx series

The 9800pro is three years old now? Wow, for some reason I remember it coming out last year. I'm a bit out of the upgrade scene though, I'm still running a 9500pro, but that plays games fine for me (well, the games I play).
 
Back
Top