What CPU for my build?

Glendor

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jan 17, 2005
Messages
279
I'm building a HTPC, and I want to reuse a few parts to save money. I read the Ultimate HTPC Build Guide thread, and CrimandEvil recommended the Athlon II 240 for the budget builds, and the 630 for the gamer/htpc build.

I don't own either of those, but I do have these three CPUs, which do you think would be my best option?

Athlon x2 4450e (lowest tdp) on a basic AM2+ board
Athlon x2 4400+ (s939) on a high-end 939 board that probably wouldn't be used otherwise

I've already pieced it together with the 4800+ and AM2 board, and it seems to work fine, but I'm wondering if the 4400+ on the nicely optioned s939 board would be suitable in the HTPC. If so, I could use the AM2+ board in a backup gaming rig I'm building.

Here are the other components:
Antec Fusion Remote Max case
Muskin 600w PSU
2x2gb DDR2 (or 4x1gb DDR on the s939 board)
HD 6670 GPU
LG BlueRay
160gb & 500gb drives
SiliconDust HDHomerun cablecard tuner
 
Last edited:
Are you *buying* these components or are they things you already have?
 
Either the 4400 or 4450e are your best option. Both have more than enough power. Most people will recommend the 4450e for the lower power and heat output, assuming you are putting this in a smaller HTPC case.

I use a socket 939 x2 4200 in mine, and even in a tiny HTPC case it does just fine with the stock cooler. Combine your setup with decent integrated graphics 4200 series or better or a cheap video card from the 4000, 5000, or 6000 series and you will be good to go for pretty much anything. If you want more video and audio options, the newer cards are obviously better, but even a lowly 4000 series card will get most things taken care of.
 
Either the 4400 or 4450e are your best option. Both have more than enough power. Most people will recommend the 4450e for the lower power and heat output, assuming you are putting this in a smaller HTPC case.

I use a socket 939 x2 4200 in mine, and even in a tiny HTPC case it does just fine with the stock cooler. Combine your setup with decent integrated graphics 4200 series or better or a cheap video card from the 4000, 5000, or 6000 series and you will be good to go for pretty much anything. If you want more video and audio options, the newer cards are obviously better, but even a lowly 4000 series card will get most things taken care of.

I'm going to start the rebuild tomorrow. The s939 mobo and 4400+ will go in and the AM2 mobo well go into my backup gamer with a Phenom II 840 on it.


Any comment on the final build?
Antec Fusion Remote Max
Mushkin Enhanced 550w PSU
ASUS A8N SLI Deluxe
AMD 4400+
CORSAIR H50
4x 1gb Kingston DDR400
XFX HR 6670
Seagate 160GB
LG Blueray
Logitech Dinovo kbd/mouse
SiliconDust HDHomeRun tuner
 
Back
Top