What causes hard drive heat?

Briliu

Limp Gawd
Joined
Apr 19, 2006
Messages
269
So I'm sitting here at work, doing my work stuff, and I started thinking about hard drives (I recently had one fail so it was on my mind)...

I've done a lot of reading recently on hard drives but it occurs to me that I have not read WHAT causes the heat in a hard drive. Thinking about it my self I can only come up with a few sources, some of them very minimal:

  1. Air to Platter Friction
  2. Electric motor current
  3. Electric motor friction
  4. Read head stepper motor thing
  5. External on board circuitry heat
  6. Internal circuitry (if there is any?)
  7. Read head (not friction, but the electrical energy through the traces)

I dont believe there are any other sources of real heat generation inside that little box. The last two are probably minimal at worst, but then again, I dont know!


So my question to you all is:

What causes hard drives to heat up so much?



My personal opinion is that the air/platter friction is the main source. Assuming, obviously, that there isnt a vaccuum inside the case. Which leads me to this, even a relativly mild vaccum in the case should do two things, reduce platter friction and thus heat generation, and reduce the amount of torque required to keep the disk spinning, reducing heat again and also energy required to operate.

What are you thoughts?
 
If i had to guess, the heat from the PCB but mostly the motor and bearings
 
Its pretty much a combination, mostly of the FILTERED air/platter friction. Yes, the inside of a HDD is not a vacuum, but basically a sealed and very clean mini room much like the insides of Intels factories where even one spec of dust can cause catostrophic crashes. You see that small little hole on the HDD that states DO NOT COVER UP THIS HOLE FOR ANY REASON? Thats the breathing/filtering hole for the HDD.

As HDD's have gotten larger, more platters have typically been required and thus there is a dramatatic increase in spinning surface air for the area to have friction on, thus more heat. Not only this, it causes the HDD to be more expensive and heavier and HDD makers realize this and that is why the big push for more space with less platters.

Another part is due to the heat from the friction of the bearings and motors, though not as much.

Personally, when SSD's become more cost effective and mainstream, the 60 year old technology that is magnetic data storage may finally be on its way out the door, as its been our biggest bottle neck the last decade. And this coming from somone who's Seagate took a shit on the 4th of July along with all my non backed up data for no apparent reason other the moving it into a new case :mad:
 
I'm kinda curious. Why wouldnt they want to eliminate the air inside the case? I read that the head floats on a cushion of air, but that could be (i think?) designed around by having a stiffer arm. I'd think any weight gain would be out weighed by the drop in heat/energy.
 
^I dont think having a super stiff arm would work. Not only would it weigh more (slower seek times?), but it would probably be super sensitive to bumps and vibrations causing a head crash.
 
Touch the motor hub on the bottom of a hard drive and it is usually pretty hot - I'd say that the motor probably causes most of your heat.
 
Close proximity to hard-drives of the opposite gender, hormones.
 
I would posit the electric motor current and friction as the main source of drive heat...that thing is spinning at thousands of RPM, but definitely some source of friction causing the heat. After all, the drives are mechanical, which would have heat sources from friction.
 
I think its the motor inside, these things spin at very high RPM's for extended periods of time. Also, i am guessing heat is generated when the seek heads move back and forth across the disk, this is just a guess because whenever my hard drives are under heavy use, their temperatures increase.
 
Back
Top