Western Digital hotswap = backplane power cycle?

alamone

Gawd
Joined
Sep 30, 2008
Messages
592
I just want to see the experiences of any of you out there, but in my experiences using the WD greenpower and caviar black drives (the 1TB variants) as well as the 640GB AAKS drives, I find that they cause most, but not all, of my backplanes to go awry if you attempt to hotswap them in.

Basically, when you hotswap a WD drive in, all other drives on the same backplane *lose power* for about a split second, and come back online. In other words it ends up power cycling all the other drives on the same backplane. This is obviously bad for raid, as it's like having several drives fail simultaneously just because you hotswapped a drive in.

I've seen this behavior on my 3-in-2 athena/SNT cages, my 4-in-3 kingwin cages, and reportedly it also happens on the norco 4020 with the 4 drive per backplane model. However, on the backplane on my fusion 500P, it does *not* happen, and hotswapping does not lead to dropped drives, so either it's something about the backplane not being in spec, or the WD drives not playing nice in some manner, maybe grounding problems? I don't know quite what it is.

Anyone else see this problem? I know a lot of people use WDs for raid arrays, but have they ever tried hotswapping to see the behavior of their backplanes? (Obviously, if you're going to try it, do it where dropped drives wont cause loss of data.) I only have a few WD drives so it's not a big deal - I just use them as JBODs, but I'd like to see what other people's experiences are. Thanks
 
Also, I forgot to mention, for the 3-in-2 SNT/athena cages, the problem only occurs if the bay you hotswap in was previously in the "off" state, you hotswap the WD in, and you turn it on by pressing the button, since the SNT/athena cages have individual power switches. If you just leave all the power switches on, and hotswap the WDs, it doesn't seem to cause an issue.

I thought maybe it was also particular to my power supply, but it happened on two diff powersupplys - my pc power and cooling silencer 750 and my antec signature 850.
 
I have all of the drive you mentioned and have not had any problems hotswapping any of them. I have a Norco 4020, some Athena 3in2's and some iStarUSA 3in2's and have not seen any of the problems you mention above.
 
Back
Top