Western Digital Green or Black

Green for storage and black for os
Posted via [H] Mobile Device
 
Green for storage and black for os
Posted via [H] Mobile Device

True. But IMHO there are better 1TB hard drives than that particular WD Black for $5 less. In most currently available revisions, the 1TB WD1001FALS is one of the slowest 1TB hard drives currently available in terms of physical sequential-speed performance whereas the currently manufactured revision of the 5405 rpm 1TB WD Green is about as fast (sequentially) as most 7200 rpm 1TB Black WD1001FALS drives (but the random access speed of the Green is obviously slower than that of the Black).
 
And if price is similar than I always recommend Samsung over wd as there products have been more consistently stable in the last couple years.
Posted via [H] Mobile Device
 
True. But IMHO there are better 1TB hard drives than that particular WD Black for $5 less. In most currently available revisions, the 1TB WD1001FALS is one of the slowest 1TB hard drives currently available in terms of physical sequential-speed performance whereas the currently manufactured revision of the 5405 rpm 1TB WD Green is about as fast (sequentially) as most 7200 rpm 1TB Black WD1001FALS drives (but the random access speed of the Green is obviously slower than that of the Black).

If you're going to buy a 1TB drive, which would you pick?
 
I'd probably go for the 1TB Samsung F3 or the 1TB WD Blue.
 
This is a better drive then both.. Ask around & you will find very very few complaints with modern samsung drives. There fast cool & quiet.
 
if you pick between the two. I would go with the black, screw that green stuff.
 
I have WD Black 1T disk (WD Caviar Black WD1001FALS 1TB). I'm really disappointed with it. It's very noisy. The noise is low frequency vibration buzzing noise. It's audible all the time and is very disturbing. I would say noise is coming from motor or rotating platters. It's also very hot (42-43 C) while other disks in my case are only 32 C. One of the worst disk I've ever had.
 
I have WD Black 1T disk (WD Caviar Black WD1001FALS 1TB). I'm really disappointed with it. It's very noisy. The noise is low frequency vibration buzzing noise. It's audible all the time and is very disturbing. I would say noise is coming from motor or rotating platters. It's also very hot (42-43 C) while other disks in my case are only 32 C. One of the worst disk I've ever had.

I have 2 in RAID-0, they're very quiet and with the room at a mild 22c they're about 34/35c. Maybe i'm lucky, i don't know.
 
Quote of the day.

In terms of *performance*, Black is best, followed by Blue, with Green bringing up the rear - however, in terms of price, Black is also the most expensive of the three grades per gigabyte. Green is the least expensive (and is also the energy-sipping champ of the three drive grades); however, performance sticklers should steer clear (one method that the Green drives use to rack up the energy savings is dropping down to lower spindle speeds).

You *can*, depending on your use patterns, actually use a Green drive satisfactorily as a main drive (I do in Mighty Mouse, for example) - however, the [H]orde gleefully uses me for target practice because I dare to NOT buy the latest and greatest.
 
The problem with Green drives, is that they seem to die alot more then Black and Blue drives
 
I actually run both of these drive in my computer.

The Black is nice for the performance as it is my gaming drive, but it is very noise when seeking and writing. When just spinning it's fine.

The Green is Quiet in Everything. no problem with either saving, seeking, playing MKV's, or anything else i do with it.

The Samsung F3 and F4 drive are very good as well. They are a very very close match and sometimes even faster then the WD Black.

I have no idea what Loco Laptop is talking about with regards to the Green drive being crap. They are quite reliable. Storage Review.com goes into this at depth and while there is no such thing as a perfect drive, these are very good drives.
 
I have a Black and it is noisy. It also takes a long time to spin up after it's been asleep. OK for an OS drive but annoying for a storage drive.
 
My WD Caviar Black WD1001FALS 1TB is great. Quietest and coolest of my installed drives (8 degrees C cooler than an older WD and a really old [and loud] Seagate, at the moment.). I did have a DOA before this current drive, but 100% smooth sailing since.

One nice thing about Caviar Black is the 5 year warranty (versus 3 year in the Green and most other drives). It makes me feel better, at least. Also might be good for your purposes if you don't think you'll be running out of space anytime soon.
 
Back
Top