WD7501AALS sucks or fast?

MagicMan84

Limp Gawd
Joined
Apr 9, 2008
Messages
326
WD is sending me the 750GB Black in replacement for a "Newegg'd" 640GB Black that recently went bad.

Is the WD7501AALS drive considered as fast as the WD6401AALS?

The extra 100GB won't be worth it to me if the speed is going to be slower.
 
from my understanding, the 640 is a 2x320, whereas the 750 is a 3x250.

im not too computer knowledable, but most i have read says the denser drive is faster....
 
from my understanding, the 640 is a 2x320, whereas the 750 is a 3x250.

im not too computer knowledable, but most i have read says the denser drive is faster....

Actually, The Black line all use the same 334GB platters. I'm not sure how they achieve 750GB using 3 334GB platters, but I read that one of the heads is wasted.

My 1TB black and my 640GB black both measure the same access time. I'm hoping the same is with the 750GB version, but I'm wondering why it's considered to be the "slowest" black drive out of the 3. Doesn't make sense.
 
i have had the 750 black for little over a year and used it for my boot drive till recently when i bought a vraptor and use that for my boot drive. i benchmarked both to see how close the 750 was the to vraptor using hdtune 2.55
western digital WD1500HLFS 150GB 74.7 mb/sec 119.5/sec 102/sec 7.2ms 169.3 mb/sec

western digital WD7501AALS 750GB 63 MB/SEC 114.7 MB/SEC 90.4 MB/SEC 13ms 133.1 mb/sec
the blacks are pretty close to the vraptors IMHO
 
i have had the 750 black for little over a year and used it for my boot drive till recently when i bought a vraptor and use that for my boot drive. i benchmarked both to see how close the 750 was the to vraptor using hdtune 2.55
western digital WD1500HLFS 150GB 74.7 mb/sec 119.5/sec 102/sec 7.2ms 169.3 mb/sec

western digital WD7501AALS 750GB 63 MB/SEC 114.7 MB/SEC 90.4 MB/SEC 13ms 133.1 mb/sec
the blacks are pretty close to the vraptors IMHO

I appreciate your reply, but 13ms is quite poor for a Black edition WD.

The access time is what's important for me since I will be using it as my OS drive.

My current drives all get 11.x ms. It's too bad Newegg doesn't know how to properly package drives or I wouldn't be in this position. :mad:
 
I'd truly appreciate it if others could also post random access time scores for the WD7501AALS.
 
why not grab a vraptor, look around there are some good deals for them. i got mine for $99 shipped on ebay
 
why not grab a vraptor, look around there are some good deals for them. i got mine for $99 shipped on ebay

It's only because I'm in the RMA process with WD.

They chose to send me the 750GB Black through advanced RMA, even if the drive which went faulty (Thanks to Newegg) is the 640GB Black.
I doubt they would send me a Raptor. :D

I wasn't planning on complaining, but 13ms is too slow if that is what's to be expected.
 
you can always sell it and get something different, i bet there would be plenty of takers for it
 
Back
Top