WD GP 1.5TB drive troubles

djBon2112

Supreme [H]ardness
Joined
Jul 29, 2006
Messages
5,279
Hello all.

I'm having a problem with two of my four WD GP drives. For clarity, here's clifs of my server's story for the past 6 months:

1. Original system (Dual-core Xeon 1.86GHz on a Supermicro board) was running 4x WD GP 1.5TBs in Windows Software RAID5 without problems for several months.
2. Decide I want to use less power, buy my current Atom system (in sig). Same SB, etc.
3. Move array over to new Atom board. Array works fine.
4. About 1-2 months later, performance of system starts dropping significantly. RDP is painfully slow, but I can still stream my music from the server.

At this point OS drive was separate from the array, but this is where the WD GP drive problems start.

6. Windows Server 2k8R2 install crashes and refuses to boot, I lose the RAID array and data (this was months ago and no longer concerns me).
7. Reinstall Server 2k8R2. Try to rebuild array. It seems one drive (drive 3/4) is being very slow. I try testing it by itself. 2.5 MB/s read performance! :eek:
8. I decide to run Linux software RAID. I try for a few weeks but can't get this going due to 7.
9. Give up, use single disk. Working fine for 2 months during my move.

And now, we get to last night.

10. Try again to set up server. Wouldn't boot into WHS install for the longest time. It turns out a SECOND drive (4/4) has ground to a halt, though this one seems to crash anything accessing it. Currently using the remaining 2 disks on the WHS, both as system and data.

So, has anyone else had this kind of problem? I'd heard of the TLDR bug in RAIDs but I thought that was only with hardware RAID? What would cause two WD drives to grind to a halt like that?

I should mention: neither drive (to my knowledge) gives S.M.A.R.T. errors: that says they're healthy! But the transfer speeds on both drives are in the ~2 MB/s range.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top