WD Caviar Green Drive Sale @ MC

PGHammer

2[H]4U
Joined
Oct 8, 2002
Messages
3,315
http://www.microcenter.com/search/search_results.aspx?sku_list=994319+994350

The 2TB drive is [W]arm; however, the 1TB drive deal is so cold it's [F]rozen.

Why? Unlike the 2TB drive (or even my own ex-MyBook 1TB drive), the 1TB drive on sale has a mere 16MB on-drive cache/buffer - worse, it's only a mere $20 less than the 2TB drive with twice the cache. On top of that, there is no reason why any system that can swallow the 1TB drive can't take the slightly-pricier, but better performing, 2TB drive - not in terms of either size OR capacity.

Pass over the 1TB drive.
 
But of course it's in-store only. It seems that anytime MicroCenter has a good sale on anything it's in-store only.
If only there was a store close to me. :(
The 2TB looks tempting.
 
Limit one sucks. Not worth the drive for that. Especially when Amazon comes out to the same price after CA tax (until Sept 15th :( )
 
The 2TB drive is warm. That's about the same price I paid for mine about 1.5 - 2 years ago. Great drives - you would think at 5900RPM, that it's slow but it plenty of speed for my needs!
 
The 2TB drive is warm. That's about the same price I paid for mine about 1.5 - 2 years ago. Great drives - you would think at 5900RPM, that it's slow but it plenty of speed for my needs!

I agree - the 2TB drive (with the larger cache) is tempting - as it should be; this is the start of HDD pricing approaching pre-flood sanity; I whacked the 1TB drive for simply being a bad deal, and especially compared to the 2TB drive.

In fact my current 1TB drive is - like both these drives and the 500GB drive it replaced, a Caviar Green drive. The issue with these drives isn't *just* the spindle speed.

1. To be honest, the 5900 rpm spindle speed is still faster than the 5400rpm spindle speed common to the original Caviar IDE or first-generation SATA-150 drives; the first (and fixable) issue is the drive spindown (part of the Eco-Green firmware); to override in Windows, simply go to Power options and modify your exiting power plan (especially if High Performance is used) to set drive spindown to Never.

2. The other issue is on-drive cache, and 16MB is barely adequate - it's also the default cache of the moldy-oldy IDE Caviar SE of a mere 80GB - no 500GB drive intended for PCs should have an on-drive cache that small. (The Caviar AV/GP - which *does* have an on-drive cache that small, is also the same drive that, in retail packaging - wound up being sold to Best Buy a few years back.) Even drives intended for the MyBooks have larger cache than that; as I pointed out, my 1TB drive, with 32MB of cache, is an ex-MyBook drive.
 
Back
Top