WD Caviar drives - which one?

stevecamp09

Limp Gawd
Joined
Mar 27, 2009
Messages
172
I was researching the possibility of picking up another 1TB Caviar Black to RAID1 with my other Black drive that I have but have found some thorny issues with RAID-ing those particular drives and the TLER issue they have (documented all over the place). So, now i'm looking at just adding a 3rd drive to my system for backups from there and was wondering which drive offers the best bang for the buck? I was looking at the Caviar Green 2TB drive for about $150 and figured it's a better deal than the 2TB Black drive for around $270 or so. Anyone own either or both and can comment on which is the best value and bearing in mind mainly just for backups?

Thanks
 
For a backup drive (and considering the price difference) I would definitely go with the Green. No reason to pay $120 more for the Black in this scenario. If it was an OS drive the Black would definitely be the better choice, but that's still a pretty large price difference. A much, much larger price discrepancy than the 1TB drives.

To answer your question: bang for buck, the 2TB Green is by far the better buy especially considering the drive will be used for backups.
 
Cool...thanks a lot guys, that was the way I was leaning so you helped me make up my mind. Cheers!
 
Back
Top