WD 2TB Green Early Failure.

Snowdog

[H]F Junkie
Joined
Apr 22, 2006
Messages
11,257
I didn't check for smart errors. But I did notice slow reactions accessing this drive recently.

Today. It hung and I after a reboot windows tried to fix it and I lost everything....

It looks like an unpartitioned drive now. My SMART tools can't seem to find any of my drives now.

Is there any hope of recovering anything. I am about to use a Linux Recover disk and see if it can see anything on the disk.

I check on Newegg now and see a lot of failure cases.
 
You can't perform software recovery if your disk is not recognised anymore in the BIOS and/or your operating system. Try Ubuntu livecd to rule out something with your Windows OS. Also, you may want to test the HDD in another system and on another controller.

If you can get your drive to work, read the SMART data and look for:

Current Pending Sector (should be 0) -> indicates BAD sectors that are not fixed and are very dangerous!
UDMA CRC Error Count (should be 0) -> indicates cabling errors

A nice Windows tool is HDTune, the Health tab shows the SMART information for the drives that can be detected. Look for the last column labeled "Data".

Good luck!
 
You can't perform software recovery if your disk is not recognised anymore in the BIOS and/or your operating system. Try Ubuntu livecd to rule out something with your Windows OS. Also, you may want to test the HDD in another system and on another controller.

If you can get your drive to work, read the SMART data and look for:

Current Pending Sector (should be 0) -> indicates BAD sectors that are not fixed and are very dangerous!
UDMA CRC Error Count (should be 0) -> indicates cabling errors

A nice Windows tool is HDTune, the Health tab shows the SMART information for the drives that can be detected. Look for the last column labeled "Data".

Good luck!

Yeah. I already had HDtune installed and checked all my drives once in while. I have had this drive for months and everything was well.

Since it failed today. HDtune is failing to load anything, for any of my drives, it just hangs.

I have little hope at this point.

Any idea what are considered the most reliable 2TB drives ATM??
 
long shot but maybe the mobo controller died?

You mean partially died? I am using the computer. Two of my 3 HDs are working...

I suspect disconnecting the flaky one will probably allow HDtune to work again. I think it is hosed trying to communicate with the flaky drive.
 
oh, well your posts seemed like you couldnt access any drives....


maybe the sata port did die and is causing issues, try disconnecting the bad drive and see if your tools work, try switching ports around also
 
I can't access SMART info for any of my drives. Disconnected the dead drive doesn't help. Still can't get SMART info for others.

Startup Bios messages showed smart enabled. I can access the drives, (I am using the computer now). I can use Windows built in HD manage tools and scan the still connected drives for errors, but HDTune is failing to detect drives.
 
There are so many 2TB failures lately. Looks like a 1TB is the only choice for now.
 
As said, try different cable, different controller, different computer system. If the drive still is not recognised by the BIOS, then you can consider it to be failed.

The more reliable drives is kind of irrelevant; a good backup strategy perhaps mixed with redundancy (RAID) should deal with HDD failure rates.
 
You can't perform software recovery if your disk is not recognised anymore in the BIOS and/or your operating system. Try Ubuntu livecd to rule out something with your Windows OS. Also, you may want to test the HDD in another system and on another controller.

If you can get your drive to work, read the SMART data and look for:

Current Pending Sector (should be 0) -> indicates BAD sectors that are not fixed and are very dangerous!
UDMA CRC Error Count (should be 0) -> indicates cabling errors

A nice Windows tool is HDTune, the Health tab shows the SMART information for the drives that can be detected. Look for the last column labeled "Data".

Good luck!

Ugh! SMART info fails if you aren't running the program in ADMIN mode.

I now have smart data for all drives.

My bad drive has a number of error counts not present on my good drives:

Here are non zero values that my good drives don't have:

Raw Read Error Rate: 3 (0 on other drives)
Current Pending Sector 1404 (0 on other drives)

None of my drives show any UDMA CRC errors.
 
So it looks like the partition got blown away when windows tried to recover at bootup. I have access to the disk. I did a quick error scan with HDTUNE but it found nothing but that indicates at least the disk is there and accessible, doing the thorough scan now (already found red sector and I am only 2 minutes in).

Are there any good tools to search the disk itself for the files. This was a media drive, so the files tend to be large and a lot of them should be recoverable with decent tools...

edit: Getdataback seems to see a lot of the missing files. I am going with that unless I get a better rec.
 
Last edited:
The more reliable drives is kind of irrelevant; a good backup strategy perhaps mixed with redundancy (RAID) should deal with HDD failure rates.

Not to me it isn't. We shouldn't have to accept terrible reliability just because you can RAID drives (I don't have a RAID controller anyway).

Using Newegg as stats (not the best, but what else is there). 2TB are significantly more unreliable accross the board than 1TB were. Only looking at drives with more than 100 reviews to get a better sample.

WD and Seagate have the worse reliablity among 2TB drives.
Samsung has the best.

My next drive will Samsung.

I am not going to reward the most unreliable players by buying more of their product. That only encourages them to keep producing junk. Clearly they all got in over their heads building 2TB drives. But it makes sense to still go for the more reliable models.

FWIW I have never had a drive fail before 4 years of use on me before this one that didn't make it 6months.
 
Try Recurva? http://www.piriform.com/recuva Not sure if its better, but I used 2 programs last time I had to do something like this to be sure.

Regarding the drive reliability, this is a reason I prefer buying smaller drives. I believe 1 TB drives right now for instance have the best $/size ratio, they are relatively more mature and easier to manufacture then 2 TBs, and so should be more reliable over a large sample size. Also if you fail a 1 TB drive, you'd be losing less data.
 
Using Newegg as stats (not the best, but what else is there). 2TB are significantly more unreliable accross the board than 1TB were. Only looking at drives with more than 100 reviews to get a better sample.

WD and Seagate have the worse reliablity among 2TB drives.
Samsung has the best.

My next drive will Samsung.

Newegg review "statistics" wont tell you anything. Western Digital and Seagate are more popular in the US than Hitachi and Samsung. A lot of people only post reviews if they have a problem, thus you would expect to see more negative reviews for WD and Seagate drives.

In terms of reliability I would imagine they're all quite similar. Only large scale HDD failure records like Google has from their data centers would give you real reliability statistics, and Google doesn't release that info.
 
Newegg review "statistics" wont tell you anything. Western Digital and Seagate are more popular in the US than Hitachi and Samsung. A lot of people only post reviews if they have a problem, thus you would expect to see more negative reviews for WD and Seagate drives.

Actually the counts of reviews are similar and I am looking at the percentage of failures, not the total failure count.

1TB drives are more popular, and have many more reviews and lower failure percentage, so greater popularity does not equal higher failure complaints. Higher actual rates of failure does that.

I acknowledge newegg reviews are imperfect, but they are essentially all we have and you can definitely spot the trends. 100% bet your life on it? No. But if I have to choose from a sea of drek, I am going go with trends from imperfect stats instead of blind chance.
 
I've been using WD drives since I switched from Seagate back in 04 or so. I have had almost no issues until these green drives I'm using now..

I built a Raid5 array with (5) WD10EADS drives, with TLER enabled.. 1 drive failed after about 45 days, last night another drive completely failed.

Switching HD brands is tough for me, once I get used to one, but I've got a couple of the 2tb Samsungs on order, and if they work out I'm really considering building a big Raid6 array with them.
 
So it looks like the partition got blown away when windows tried to recover at bootup.

There are tools that will restore the partition data. I used one many years ago, so I do not have the current names. A Google search should find tools.
 
There are tools that will restore the partition data. I used one many years ago, so I do not have the current names. A Google search should find tools.

I used Getdataback to recover most of my data.

After that I formatted, chkdsk.

There were still Current Pending Sector 1404 even after format/chkdsk.

I have RMAd the drive...
 
Back
Top