Water Cooling Help Please - My First Time

sitalchauhan

Limp Gawd
Joined
May 30, 2006
Messages
244
I am going to order components for my new intel core 2 duo build, where I want the system to be as quiet as possible while still maintaining good temperatures. The basic specs are E6400, X1800-XT, 2GB DDR2, Seasonic S12-600. The case I am planning to use is the thermaltake tsunami, but I am replacing all the fans.

Initially, I was planning to get the following fans/coolers:
Zalman CNPS9500-LED (27.5dB) (CPU Cooler)
Zalman VF900-LED (25.0dB) (Graphics Cooler)
2x Scythe S-FLEX 1200RPM Ultra Quiet 120mm Fans (20.1dB, 49CFM) (Intake + Exhaust)
AcoustiFan C-Series Ultra Quiet 92mm Fan (25.9dB, 41.7CFM) (Side-Window Fan)
​

However, I have just done some research and water cooling isnt as difficult as I thought it would be, and it is supposed to be very quiet.

I am looking into the Zalman Reserator 1 v2 now, which is more expensive than the above air cooling combination, but if it makes a difference, I am willing to pay the extra.

I will not be overclocking, but am looking for a quiet computer.

1) Will it be much quieter? Or is the above air cooling going to be almost silent anyway?

2) Will the reserator be able to cool the X1800-XT ok?

3) Will the reserator be likely to be able to cool with the next generation of graphics cards enough, or is it likely that I will have to get a new / upgrade the water cooling system?



Many thanks for any help,
Sital
 
Oh dear, just digged out a review that was exactly what I was looking for, and it looks like its best for me to stick with air cooling:

http://www.xbitlabs.com/articles/coolers/display/16watercooling_30.html

The reserator is almost silent (apart from quiet hum of the pump. However, it would struggle to cool the X1800-XT well enough since it gets so hot.

Also, I was very surprised between the CPU temperature differences between the CNPS9500 and the reserator:

reser1p_results.png


The reserator had a considerably higher temperature!

Ill stick with quiet air cooling for the moment until there is a better passive all-in-one water cooling kit available (maybe the reserator 2?? :p)
 
You don't necessarily need a passive watercooling system to have quiet watercooling. You simply need quiet fans with good cfm. Remember, with passive water cooling systems and ALL watercooling systems, ambient temperature has alot to do with how well your parts will cool.

I watercool first and foremost for the quietness because I am very sensitive to noise, secondly for any performance and OCing I might experiment with, and thirdly for solid system stability. I have 4 120mm fans in my case and they all run at full speed. 2 of those fans are used in my watercooling loop for my radiator. If it weren't for my ccfl's I would not be able to tell that my comp is on, its so quiet.

I use 14dba 67 cfm 120mm SilenX fans in my system. Many members here on [H] do not like SilenX because of there ridiculously high expense and dba claims but they work excellently for me. Yate-Loons are alot cheaper and can give you similiar perfromance.

Also building a w/c setup is more than just good parts, its good design and good case airflow. If you have those things then you will have a very quiet system with excellent temps.
 
Back
Top