water cooling hard disks...

Teknokid

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Feb 17, 2007
Messages
1,292
well its £7 more than a rack for my HDD to water cool them with (thermaltake aquabay m4). i have 2 250gb seagate drives as my main drives in raid 0 and im a heavy gamer. my sys is low noise (eventually mostly water cooled) so airflow is a little low.
is it worth it?
thanks
 
That bay uses 1/4" tubing for it's internal bits...

Not something I'd want to throw into my loop personally...

I run a Raptor ADFD drive with no airflow... and I've yet to see a temperature above 46.
 
its more to look nice :) whats wrong with tubing that small? im only 3/8" anyway...
 
its more to look nice :) whats wrong with tubing that small? im only 3/8" anyway...

If you're only 3/8 then it's not such a big deal I guess... You could run them in parallel if you really wanted to help your flowrate out.

They do look nice... They also don't look too leak prone...
 
dilema!!
this is my possible flow. pump, triple rad (6x120mm fans @ 1300rpm) cpu block, HDD 1, HDD 2, then in the future gfx block. am i best to add another rad after the HDD blocks (aquabay m2) i hate getting Tt lcs stuff but nowone can compare on value/range.
 
depending on what pump you have, going from 3/8 to 1/4 will put a HUGE bottleneck in the loop. flow rate increases exponentialy with size of tube, 1/4" is not just half the flow of 1/2", im too lazy to do math today but its somewhere like 1/5th the flow rate. it seems like only slightly smaller tube but its much less flow, not to mention the restriction HD blocks like to create. although i have 3 HD blocks myself, heres the soloution i used (taken from another thread i posted in)

i had this same problem, i had some 1/4" hard drive blocks from my old system i wanted to use on my current one. everything i have now is 1/2" though...

.........................../ ------------------------------------(1/2")-------------------------------------\...................
........>---(1/2")----'Y'........................... .............................. ..........................'Y'-----(1/2")--<
...........................\---------(1/2" to 1/4")----(hard drive blocks)--(1/4"to1/2")------/...................

hardware: 2x 1/2" Y splitters
2x 1/2" to 1/4" reducers
misc clamps & tubing

i wish my camera worked so i didnt have to make that stupid diagram but the idea is; most of the flow will continue through the 1/2" piece, but inevitably *some* of the water will find that the path of least resistance is through the 1/4" section. this flow will not be strong, but it will circulate water which is all i need for hard drives and this setup should be sufficient for Ram cooling. i wouldnt do this if you had a CPU block on the 1/4" section though. and if you want to increase flow rate you can always put a little pump in the line.
 
dilema!!
this is my possible flow. pump, triple rad (6x120mm fans @ 1300rpm) cpu block, HDD 1, HDD 2, then in the future gfx block. am i best to add another rad after the HDD blocks (aquabay m2) i hate getting Tt lcs stuff but nowone can compare on value/range.

Your RAD is fine! I'm more worried about the pump.

Trust me, that rad would handle 10 hard drives and a cpu/gpu without much of a problem.
 
haha. all this flow restrictions.. can i not go 3/8"... then t split from 3/8" to 2x 1/4"-through hard disks... T split back to 3/8". that way it splits the flow. i currently have a Tt 500 l/hr pump but im looking into a laing D5..
should i scrap the idea of HD blocks?
 
HD blocks make me extremely nervous. With everything else, you can (at least in theory) dry them out, clean 'em with alcohol, and be on your merry way, but if water gets into the inner workings of your 'drives (optical or magnetic), then they're permanently buggered.

Take that into consideration, is all.
 
haha. all this flow restrictions.. can i not go 3/8"... then t split from 3/8" to 2x 1/4"-through hard disks... T split back to 3/8". that way it splits the flow. i currently have a Tt 500 l/hr pump but im looking into a laing D5..
should i scrap the idea of HD blocks?

That's what I suggested... Run the HD blocks in parallel.

That should be ok if you split the line and rejoin them.
 
ok. all sounds rather dawnting. quite high risk too :S maybe ill stick with a 12cm fan :)
 
if your going to use a D5 you CANNOT reduce the 1/2" line into two 1/4" lines then rejoin them. you will burn the pump out real fast putting that much restriction on it. one 3/8" to two 1/4" might be do-able.
 
if your going to use a D5 you CANNOT reduce the 1/2" line into two 1/4" lines then rejoin them. you will burn the pump out real fast putting that much restriction on it. one 3/8" to two 1/4" might be do-able.

Um... 3/8" - Y - 2x1/4" is (negligibly) MORE restrictive than 1/2" - Y - 2x1/4". The dominant factor determining restriction is the presence fo the 2x1/4" section. It's not like the water has a "memory" of being in a wider tube before such that a smaller proportional bore reduction is less traumatic. :p

If you meant doing 1/2" - Y - 2x3/8" - (and one of the 3/8" lines - Y - 2x1/4"), that would help restriction significantly. (After rereading it, I really do think this is what you meant.). But If you're talking about pushing all the flow through 2x1/4" inch, it's going to be basically just as restrictive no matter what diameter the big bore upstream portion is.

(it might be easier to do this:1/2" - Y - 2x1/2" - (and one of the 1/2" lines - Y - 2x1/4"), as there would only be 2 sizes of tubing to buy instead of 3. however, I'd get a "pinch" fitting to restrict the 1/2" bypass just a little bit depending how much flow you get to the hard drives. If not, you might not get enough water flowing through the hard drive blocks - not that you need much anyways...
 
thats not what i meant, i mean the D5 is a native 1/2" pump with a very high flow rate, desigend to be used in 1/2" systems. if you have a 3/8" pump (usualy with lower flow rate) there will be less of a bottleneck, the 2x1/4" sections will have the same amount of restriction and flow, but the larger pump will be more limited then the smaller one.

(it might be easier to do this:1/2" - Y - 2x1/2" - (and one of the 1/2" lines - Y - 2x1/4"), as there would only be 2 sizes of tubing to buy instead of 3. however, I'd get a "pinch" fitting to restrict the 1/2" bypass just a little bit depending how much flow you get to the hard drives. If not, you might not get enough water flowing through the hard drive blocks - not that you need much anyways...

thats pretty much what my crappy diagram was trying to describe. and for hard drives it works well enough without the pinch fitting.
 
what i mean is regardless of the HD blocks would an entire 3/8" system be ok on a D5?
 
what i mean is regardless of the HD blocks would an entire 3/8" system be ok on a D5?

I would think so... The restriction from a full 3/8 tubing loop is about as much as a few elbows... Maybe 2.

Lots of people use elbows without too much harm ;)
 
unless i took the plunge and converted (changed barbs and tubing) on my sys to 1/2".. then maybe a second loop for HDD using my old pump etc.
 
Back
Top