Was this upgrade right for me?

Viper8547

Limp Gawd
Joined
Aug 28, 2006
Messages
208
Hello, I built this system about three years ago, specs are in the sig. About a month ago I started to see my system finally lag behind in some games, so I decided to replace my 7900 GTO with a new ati 4870 1gb and a new corsair 550w psu. Fast foward to today and I decided to upgrade my 3800+ to a phenom 9850 black edition. I knew that I only had a AM2 board and the AM2+ phenom would have to lower its HT link to work with my board. I just didn't know if this was going to be a big performance hit or not.

I got my 9850 last week and this weekend I've been comparing/contrasting it to my old 3800+, and I am not impressed. This was a $164 upgrade to which I have not seen much improvement in game fps. First of all, I was able to OC my 2.0GHz 3800+ to 2.45GHz with no change of voltage. This 9850 black edition is so picky and unstable with overclocking I was only to able to get a 320 MHz overclock on it.

Before I got the 9850 I was thinking of buying a new intel motherboard and either a Q6600 or E8400 for only ~$100 more to the bill. But as of right now I'm thinking of returning this cpu and going the intel route. Thanks for any input.
 
I was a die hard amd fan, got back into computers about last year big counter-strike player made the change to cs source got a 3600+ w/ 6600 about a year ago and it was absoloutly terrible so i bit the bullet and bought a 8800gts the amd was stlll TERRIBLE so i said hell with it, and bought an e6750 what a huge difference my fps went through the roof now i can play the newer games too.. I'm going to have to say I'll be going Intel for a very long time till AMD pulls their head out.. if you're just gaming I would recommend an e8400 my brother bought one of those with an 8800gtx about a year ago it is awesome..

I'm not very picky about the pretty stuff i always played cs in 640X480 and quake3 in 640

and the amd still couldnt handle cs source in 640X480

I even tried a 5200+ later on with some extra parts and was still lack luster...

this comp has taken everythin ive thrown at it.. I even find myself playing some L4D in 1600X1200 w/ all the bells and whistles turned on barely seeing a drop below 100fps
 
The quad core Phenom 9850 benefits you more with multitasking, as the additional cores could be used to run separate programs or background services. It gives you little benefit in gaming, as most games are GPU-dependent at resolutions beyond 1280x1024.

Another factor that may have affected you is that AMD's AM2/AM2+ X2 and Phenom series aren't even remotely as capable for overclocking as Intel's Core 2 (and Core i7) series.

I'd like to tell you that you should just keep everything as is, since you've just finished making the upgrades, but if you feel so strongly about returning it, I can't stop you. You could sell your older parts (that you aren't reusing), but just know that you won't get enough from them (alone) to buy parts for your new system.
 
I was a die hard amd fan, got back into computers about last year big counter-strike player made the change to cs source got a 3600+ w/ 6600 about a year ago and it was absoloutly terrible so i bit the bullet and bought a 8800gts the amd was stlll TERRIBLE so i said hell with it, and bought an e6750 what a huge difference my fps went through the roof now i can play the newer games too.. I'm going to have to say I'll be going Intel for a very long time till AMD pulls their head out.. if you're just gaming I would recommend an e8400 my brother bought one of those with an 8800gtx about a year ago it is awesome..

I'm not very picky about the pretty stuff i always played cs in 640X480 and quake3 in 640

and the amd still couldnt handle cs source in 640X480

I even tried a 5200+ later on with some extra parts and was still lack luster...

this comp has taken everythin ive thrown at it.. I even find myself playing some L4D in 1600X1200 w/ all the bells and whistles turned on barely seeing a drop below 100fps

What are you talking about? :eek:

edit: you're talking about an Athlon XP? That might make a bit more sense...
 
I'd return it if wherever you got it from doesn't have a 15% restocking fee, since you're willing to shell out more for a Core2.
 
I feel I have some info and a good reason to chime in here hopefully to help you.

I had a 5000+ @ 2.6ghz.8800gt,and a hd4850.I only played cod4.Sure my avg was good around 60fps high around 90 low in the 20's.The low was unacceptable to me,I could not deal with 20fps.20 fps I can just buy a console and do better but I like pc gaming.

So I sold the whole rig for $140 shipped.Bought a E8400 with a p35 board.I have a 9800gtx now for video card.My performance went thru the roof.Framerate was alot more stable.It wasn't all up and down like it was before.My low went from 20 to 45 at the lowest.The low is what made the big deal.

With 20 fps it was a slideshow.@ 45 fps it went smooth.I am very happy with going with the E8400.Vista is alot faster,I mean everything is faster.

Amd really needs to make a huge comeback for me to ever buy another one of their cpu's again.I highly doubt it will happen.I will give it to amd tho for budget building like web surfing/email only it is really hard to beat a amd build since it is alot cheaper,but you have to pay to play.

Get rid of the phenom and get a E8400 or i7
 
Back
Top