WARR Wins Hyperloop Competition

FrgMstr

Just Plain Mean
Staff member
2FA
Joined
May 18, 1997
Messages
58,694
The fine folks over at WARR HYPERLOOP in Germany won the latest competition put on my Elon Musk. Below you can see WARR's 202mph run from the nose of the pod. The prototype pod is 6 feet in diameter, so a bit smaller than these would have to be in usable form. The WARR pod uses and electric motor and has air-powered brakes that brought the pod to a halt in 3 seconds due to the short nature of the test track being run on.

Check out the video.

Even though Elon Musk tweeted it first, here's the run of the WARR Hyperloop Team on the second SpaceX Hyperloop Pod Competition. We maxed out at 324 km/h (202 mph) and are incredibly excited to have won the title of fastest pod!
 
Woooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo! Again! Again!
 
john-stapp-during-a-high-g-force-test-on-a-sled-nasa.jpg
 
exactly... except your missing the part where you are birthed from a butthole tube.
 
And why do we care again? This thing is just a short test track, moving at same speed as high-speed trains and open-air maglevs already achieve on a daily basis. This is a baby step, barely worthy of note.

Call me back in ten years when they achieve 400+mph on their larger test track, and I'll be impressed.

And then call me back a few years after that when the entire concept gets chucked into the dust bin because the reality was too expensive to build and maintain.

Because the cost of the hyperloop isn't just building a short test track, THE SALES PITCH IS building some form of at-speed switching transport network for a bunch of smaller cars with many different destinations, all running at extremely low pressure. Because if all it does is move a large box full of people from one fixed point to the next at 600mph, then we've just got owned by the much-more-versatile airplane again.
 
Last edited:
CA HSR will be testing HST's in 2024 at 250mph, so that max 200mph service and 220mph express service can begin asap, in the interim period Amtrak from 2025 until HST's can be delivered, Amtrak will run at 110-125mph.

And I agree with other posters here who are not impressed, 200mph or even 202mph is not impressive, not when Musk said 700mph or so, the TGV(HST) in France does 200mph all the time.

HST = High Speed Train
 
And why do we care again? This thing is just a short test track, moving at same speed as high-speed trains and open-air maglevs already achieve on a daily basis. This is a baby step, barely worthy of note.

Call me back in ten years when they achieve 400+mph on their larger test track, and I'll be impressed.

And then call me back a few years after that when the entire concept gets chucked into the dust bin because the reality was too expensive to build and maintain.

Because the cost of the hyperloop isn't just building a short test track, THE SALES PITCH IS building some form of at-speed switching transport network for a bunch of smaller cars with many different destinations, all running at extremely low pressure. Because if all it does is move a large box full of people from one fixed point to the next at 600mph, then we've just got owned by the much-more-versatile airplane again.


You certainly care enough to reply about the topic.

Seriously, whether or not this fails or succeeds, this is life. Research and Development doesn't always succeed but when it does, it moves the world forward just a bit. History is full of people like you who raise their nose against the idea of progress because it doesn't instantly gratify your needs. But thank goodness people still try to push beyond despite, otherwise we'd be stuck in time.
 
OK, Japan has had trains that run 200+ MPH for decades.
"This is merely
superconductor electromagnetism.
Surely you've heard of it.
It levitates bullet trains
from Tokyo to Osaka.
It levitates my desk,
where I ride
the saddle of the world.
And it levitates...
me!"
 
202 mph, brakes halt it in 3 seconds... *does math* great so you'll stop in a 1/6th of a mile. Even so, that's a 3g stop, stopping any faster definitely is going to give people whiplash.
 
"This is merely
superconductor electromagnetism.
Surely you've heard of it.
It levitates bullet trains
from Tokyo to Osaka.
It levitates my desk,
where I ride
the saddle of the world.
And it levitates...
me!"


And the funny thing is, Japan is building a superconducting maglev bullet train.From Tokyo to Osaka :D

https://www.thenational.ae/business/japan-bites-bullet-with-maglev-trains-1.86709

Because you don't need something as complicated as near-vacuum and gimmicky multi-car switching to make maglev viable. You just need three large cities within a couple hundred miles to be to be stretched to the limits as far as inter-city transport goes. Then they'll build their own traditional tunnels.

300mph traditional superconducting maglev is getting damn close to Hyperloop without any of the other complex problems. And I just don't see vast tunnels of low air pressure with complex car switching being anywhere near as easy to build or keep operational as compared to a traditional tunnel.

Term-X, You want to know WHY I replied to this thread? It's because there's a bunch of people in California playing in the Maglev clouds are making sure people care, while in the rest of the world is getting things done AND ACTUALLY PUSHING THE LIMITS OF SCIENCE.
 
Last edited:
I really don't care about going from one city to another a few hundred miles away. I want to see a system that can get you from one ocean to the next faster and cheaper than a plane. Until then, what's the point?
 
Call me back in ten years when they achieve 400+mph on their larger test track, and I'll be impressed.

Call me when they figure out how to maintain a near perfect vacuum in a 200 mile tube while factoring for expansion and contraction, and a way not to destroy the whole thing and kill everyone with a .22 rifle.
 
And the funny thing is, Japan is building a superconducting maglev bullet train.From Tokyo to Osaka :D

https://www.thenational.ae/business/japan-bites-bullet-with-maglev-trains-1.86709

Because you don't need something as complicated as near-vacuum and gimmicky multi-car switching to make maglev viable. You just need three large cities within a couple hundred miles to be to be stretched to the limits as far as inter-city transport goes. Then they'll build their own traditional tunnels.

300mph traditional superconducting maglev is getting damn close to Hyperloop without any of the other complex problems. And I just don't see vast tunnels of low air pressure with complex car switching being anywhere near as easy to build or keep operational as compared to a traditional tunnel.

Term-X, You want to know WHY I replied to this thread? It's because there's a bunch of people in California playing in the Maglev clouds are making sure people care, while in the rest of the world is getting things done AND ACTUALLY PUSHING THE LIMITS OF SCIENCE.


I'd also feel safer in their maglev trains, since they've been testing them since 1997.
 
About the only use for these things is coast to coast transport. And only if they can get it done cheaper and faster per seat than a jet can.

And even with all this, there is a real common sense problem with getting into a low pressure tube and going 500+ mph. There's no such thing as a "small" problem at that speed on the ground.

You can't really compare it to air travel either, the whole reason aircraft work is because when cruising you aren't likely to encounter anything solid.

With the hyperloop, you are always inches from solid mass.

If there wasn't so much taxpayer money going through his company I'd say knock yourself out but this raises every red flag I can think of just like the push for electric cars when technology just isn't there. This isn't a place for public subsidy.

And like all mass transit... does it actually go anywhere we want to go?

IF, and it's a big IF, it could be more efficient than diesel locomotives we could make a serious case for having a couple of these lines running coast to coast to transport non-living goods at insane speeds without putting the weight in aircraft. But let's see numbers. Pound for pound, what's the cost difference between an overnight air package and an overnight hyperloop package?
 
A bunch of make-believe. This will have as much real-world application as Mr Rogers's Neighborhood Trolley.
 
honestly the boring companies endeavors are significantly more exiting than this on a practical term, the idea of car tunnels at 1/10th the current cost would change everything.
 
Well with the buzz they will get the permits and abatements they need to build a high speed connector from SF to LA for the rich to work in LA and live in SF.
it also works the other way around, allowing people to live in a significantly cheaper environment but work in san fran (not that i think a tax payer funded connector should happen, but i also don't believe in public transportation subsidized by taxes)
 
Well with the buzz they will get the permits and abatements they need to build a high speed connector from SF to LA for the rich to work in LA and live in SF.

Highlighted the important point 'cuz with small cars holding less than 10? people it sure isn't fit for mass transit nor will be cheap enough for the public.
 
it also works the other way around, allowing people to live in a significantly cheaper environment but work in san fran (not that i think a tax payer funded connector should happen, but i also don't believe in public transportation subsidized by taxes)
HSR can do that now, and does that worldwide, so why reinvent the wheel? So to speak.
 
HSR can do that now, and does that worldwide, so why reinvent the wheel? So to speak.
Well in the case of California, please look at the cluster fuck that is the HSR project and the projected costs.

But to seriously answer your question, a great deal of commuters this is not an option. Yes the entire SF Bay Area is more or less "wired" with mass transit, but then again the whole bay area is fucking expensive, it's when you get to places not hooked to BART or Caltrain or any number of other options where houses become affordable again. Note: I couldn't give less of a fuck about housing affordability, I'm just saying if that's your metric about commuting you shouldn't work/live in the SF Bay area.
 
HSR can do that now, and does that worldwide, so why reinvent the wheel? So to speak.

HSR can do it and probably better, but the hsr is just too expensive in terms of money and politics to get done in a place like California. That being said, neither can the hyperloop, this whole project is a pipe dream. I'm guessing (and i mean totally guessing) that either the plan is to elevate it or put it under ground in conjunction with the boring company. If it is the later it makes a ton of sense (outside of earthquakes) since its the only way it could ever be paid for (as in train tunnels are a billion dollars a mile and boring company is trying to do smaller car sized tunnels for 100 million a mile).
 
it also works the other way around, allowing people to live in a significantly cheaper environment but work in san fran (not that i think a tax payer funded connector should happen, but i also don't believe in public transportation subsidized by taxes)
like someone pointed out the size of people moved at one time makes impractical for moving a large workforce. What it will do is allow businesses in SF to move to LA while their top management can still live in SF. Think of the money saved/made from converting business properties to accommodations.
 
like someone pointed out the size of people moved at one time makes impractical for moving a large workforce. What it will do is allow businesses in SF to move to LA while their top management can still live in SF. Think of the money saved/made from converting business properties to accommodations.
It may be impractical but it also may be affordable (thats what is trying to be worked out), also just because cars are smaller doesn't mean they can't use more cars or more trains, Hell, if you only have 1 stop in each city you can expend horizontally at the destinations and have simultaneous stops like you would at an old fashioned rail hub with multiple platforms connected to the same line and separate the trains by seconds in their actual travel

Also lets say your vision happens, stop tax payer subsidy of it, they want to build it let them and charge whatever they want and who cares?
 
Back
Top