TechLarry
RIP [H] Brother - June 1, 2022
- Joined
- Aug 9, 2005
- Messages
- 30,481
First, I'm suprised there isn't a Printers Forum
Hint Hint!
Now, I'm thinking about getting an inexpensive Color Laser. My main reason for this was to cut down on color printing costs overall, so I can just use my Inkjets for photo's and stuff.
That's what I thought, at least. I'm not so sure this is true.
First, most of them ship with lame 1/3 filled toners. Man that pisses me off. It's just plain decitful.
Then there's the rest of it. The OPC's, the transfer belts, the waste toner bottles, oh my!
I thought I was on to something with the Okidata C5200NE. On sale for $445 at CompUSA. Great specs. Good quality prints. Solidly made.
BUT!
The (normally 3000 page) cartridges are only half-full.
Replacements are $80 each for each color.
The damned transfer belt is almost $200 and has to be replaced at 50,000 pages.
Oh, it gets worse. Get this!
Each cartridge color has an OPC drum. There are 4 of them. They are only rated for 15,000 pages. All of them. They are $100 EACH, and they ALL have to be replaced at the same time!
So at 15000 pages, you are looking at $400 worth of OPC Drums. Sheesh!
Ok, so mark that one off the list. Damn...
Now, the HP LaserJet 2600n.
Now, I'm only going by information I've read on the web, but _if this is correct_ HP has the cartridge life locked to the page count. 2000 pages. Period. Doesn't matter if the cartridge is 3/4 full. At the end of 2000 pages you MUST replace the cartridge.
Oh, and it doesn't matter if you are printing b/w or color. EVERY cartridge gets a page hit with EVERY page printed. Whether it has color or not, whether it has B/W or not.
Cartridges are $80 each. Thats $320 EVERY 2000 PAGES, regardles of your true toner usage.
My god!
Next up is the Lexmark 522N. Reasonable price. $499. VERY fast printer. Well rated, but a tad low on the quality side for photo's. No biggie, that's what the Canon's are for.
I haven't been able to find any reliable cost data on this printer though. Lexmark does NOT have a good reputation at all for reasonable consumable costs.
Ok, so I'm also considering this one:
http://www1.us.dell.com/content/products/productdetails.aspx/print_5100cn?c=us&cs=19&l=en&s=dhs
$699 ($300 discount right now) and free shipping. Way better toner capacity, and it ships with FULL cartridges.
Reviews say it's a decent printer, but not everyone has been happy with Dell support, and it seems most feel the plastics are quite cheap and tacky. I believe Dell uses Lexmark engines, so consumable costs are in question.
Fast, Black and white up to 35ppm print speed (actual print speed will vary with use)
Fast, Color up to 25 ppm print speed (actual print speed will vary with use)
Maximum Resolution is 600 x 600 dpi with 2400 image (1200 x 1200 at 1/2 speed)included
Maximum input capacity 2,150 sheets (Maximum of two additional drawers)
Optional 500 sheet A4/Legal and 1000 sheet A4/Legal drawer
Monthly duty cycle up to 90K pages
Upgrade to 2-4 year At-Home Service3 options are available
Toner cost per page (not including drum) : 0.6 cents (Black), 6.9 cents (Color)
Toner cost per page (including drum) : 1 cent (Black) , 7.4 cents (Color)
Standard Duplex
Ships with 9K Black, 8K Cyan, 8K Magenta, 8K Yellow Toner Cartridges
Standard Ethernet 10/100 BaseT networking, USB and parallel port
Compatible Operating Systems with the 5100cn Windows® 95/98SE/Me/2000/XP, Windows Server 2003, Windows NT 4.0
Unix (HP-UX and Solaris 9)
Linux® (Red Hat® 8/9 and SuSE 8.2/9 English versions)
Mac OS9/OSX over TCP/IP
Novell® NetWare® 3.X, 4.X, 5.X, 6, 6.5
Standard for LPD, Port 9100, FTP protocol
For other protocol, including IPP, Netware, Ethertalk, a Multi-Protocol card is required, Multi-Protocol Card $99
Dell Color Track driver enables designation of color and/or black and white printing with individuals or workgroups.
Dell Printer Web Tool can be used to install, configure, and manage network printers and consumables
Standard 1 year At Home Service3 and 24x7 toll free tech support. 2-4 years extended services options with Fuser Maintenance Coverage included in standard and extended limited warranties
Drum is good for 35,000 pages and is a reasonable $140.
A set of 4 toners (3 8000 page color and 1 9000 page black) is $579. You can get them individually for $169 color, and (a quite reasonable I think) $49 for 9000 page black.
Though it's TON bigger than what I need, at these prices is the Dell not the best value out there?
-Larry
Now, I'm thinking about getting an inexpensive Color Laser. My main reason for this was to cut down on color printing costs overall, so I can just use my Inkjets for photo's and stuff.
That's what I thought, at least. I'm not so sure this is true.
First, most of them ship with lame 1/3 filled toners. Man that pisses me off. It's just plain decitful.
Then there's the rest of it. The OPC's, the transfer belts, the waste toner bottles, oh my!
I thought I was on to something with the Okidata C5200NE. On sale for $445 at CompUSA. Great specs. Good quality prints. Solidly made.
BUT!
The (normally 3000 page) cartridges are only half-full.
Replacements are $80 each for each color.
The damned transfer belt is almost $200 and has to be replaced at 50,000 pages.
Oh, it gets worse. Get this!
Each cartridge color has an OPC drum. There are 4 of them. They are only rated for 15,000 pages. All of them. They are $100 EACH, and they ALL have to be replaced at the same time!
So at 15000 pages, you are looking at $400 worth of OPC Drums. Sheesh!
Ok, so mark that one off the list. Damn...
Now, the HP LaserJet 2600n.
Now, I'm only going by information I've read on the web, but _if this is correct_ HP has the cartridge life locked to the page count. 2000 pages. Period. Doesn't matter if the cartridge is 3/4 full. At the end of 2000 pages you MUST replace the cartridge.
Oh, and it doesn't matter if you are printing b/w or color. EVERY cartridge gets a page hit with EVERY page printed. Whether it has color or not, whether it has B/W or not.
Cartridges are $80 each. Thats $320 EVERY 2000 PAGES, regardles of your true toner usage.
My god!
Next up is the Lexmark 522N. Reasonable price. $499. VERY fast printer. Well rated, but a tad low on the quality side for photo's. No biggie, that's what the Canon's are for.
I haven't been able to find any reliable cost data on this printer though. Lexmark does NOT have a good reputation at all for reasonable consumable costs.
Ok, so I'm also considering this one:
http://www1.us.dell.com/content/products/productdetails.aspx/print_5100cn?c=us&cs=19&l=en&s=dhs
$699 ($300 discount right now) and free shipping. Way better toner capacity, and it ships with FULL cartridges.
Reviews say it's a decent printer, but not everyone has been happy with Dell support, and it seems most feel the plastics are quite cheap and tacky. I believe Dell uses Lexmark engines, so consumable costs are in question.
Fast, Black and white up to 35ppm print speed (actual print speed will vary with use)
Fast, Color up to 25 ppm print speed (actual print speed will vary with use)
Maximum Resolution is 600 x 600 dpi with 2400 image (1200 x 1200 at 1/2 speed)included
Maximum input capacity 2,150 sheets (Maximum of two additional drawers)
Optional 500 sheet A4/Legal and 1000 sheet A4/Legal drawer
Monthly duty cycle up to 90K pages
Upgrade to 2-4 year At-Home Service3 options are available
Toner cost per page (not including drum) : 0.6 cents (Black), 6.9 cents (Color)
Toner cost per page (including drum) : 1 cent (Black) , 7.4 cents (Color)
Standard Duplex
Ships with 9K Black, 8K Cyan, 8K Magenta, 8K Yellow Toner Cartridges
Standard Ethernet 10/100 BaseT networking, USB and parallel port
Compatible Operating Systems with the 5100cn Windows® 95/98SE/Me/2000/XP, Windows Server 2003, Windows NT 4.0
Unix (HP-UX and Solaris 9)
Linux® (Red Hat® 8/9 and SuSE 8.2/9 English versions)
Mac OS9/OSX over TCP/IP
Novell® NetWare® 3.X, 4.X, 5.X, 6, 6.5
Standard for LPD, Port 9100, FTP protocol
For other protocol, including IPP, Netware, Ethertalk, a Multi-Protocol card is required, Multi-Protocol Card $99
Dell Color Track driver enables designation of color and/or black and white printing with individuals or workgroups.
Dell Printer Web Tool can be used to install, configure, and manage network printers and consumables
Standard 1 year At Home Service3 and 24x7 toll free tech support. 2-4 years extended services options with Fuser Maintenance Coverage included in standard and extended limited warranties
Drum is good for 35,000 pages and is a reasonable $140.
A set of 4 toners (3 8000 page color and 1 9000 page black) is $579. You can get them individually for $169 color, and (a quite reasonable I think) $49 for 9000 page black.
Though it's TON bigger than what I need, at these prices is the Dell not the best value out there?
-Larry
