Wanted - Inexpensive Color Laser

TechLarry

RIP [H] Brother - June 1, 2022
Joined
Aug 9, 2005
Messages
30,481
First, I'm suprised there isn't a Printers Forum :) Hint Hint!

Now, I'm thinking about getting an inexpensive Color Laser. My main reason for this was to cut down on color printing costs overall, so I can just use my Inkjets for photo's and stuff.

That's what I thought, at least. I'm not so sure this is true.

First, most of them ship with lame 1/3 filled toners. Man that pisses me off. It's just plain decitful.

Then there's the rest of it. The OPC's, the transfer belts, the waste toner bottles, oh my!

I thought I was on to something with the Okidata C5200NE. On sale for $445 at CompUSA. Great specs. Good quality prints. Solidly made.

BUT!

The (normally 3000 page) cartridges are only half-full.

Replacements are $80 each for each color.

The damned transfer belt is almost $200 and has to be replaced at 50,000 pages.

Oh, it gets worse. Get this!

Each cartridge color has an OPC drum. There are 4 of them. They are only rated for 15,000 pages. All of them. They are $100 EACH, and they ALL have to be replaced at the same time!

So at 15000 pages, you are looking at $400 worth of OPC Drums. Sheesh!

Ok, so mark that one off the list. Damn...

Now, the HP LaserJet 2600n.

Now, I'm only going by information I've read on the web, but _if this is correct_ HP has the cartridge life locked to the page count. 2000 pages. Period. Doesn't matter if the cartridge is 3/4 full. At the end of 2000 pages you MUST replace the cartridge.

Oh, and it doesn't matter if you are printing b/w or color. EVERY cartridge gets a page hit with EVERY page printed. Whether it has color or not, whether it has B/W or not.

Cartridges are $80 each. Thats $320 EVERY 2000 PAGES, regardles of your true toner usage.

My god!

Next up is the Lexmark 522N. Reasonable price. $499. VERY fast printer. Well rated, but a tad low on the quality side for photo's. No biggie, that's what the Canon's are for.

I haven't been able to find any reliable cost data on this printer though. Lexmark does NOT have a good reputation at all for reasonable consumable costs.

Ok, so I'm also considering this one:

http://www1.us.dell.com/content/products/productdetails.aspx/print_5100cn?c=us&cs=19&l=en&s=dhs

$699 ($300 discount right now) and free shipping. Way better toner capacity, and it ships with FULL cartridges.

Reviews say it's a decent printer, but not everyone has been happy with Dell support, and it seems most feel the plastics are quite cheap and tacky. I believe Dell uses Lexmark engines, so consumable costs are in question.




Fast, Black and white up to 35ppm print speed (actual print speed will vary with use)
Fast, Color up to 25 ppm print speed (actual print speed will vary with use)
Maximum Resolution is 600 x 600 dpi with 2400 image (1200 x 1200 at 1/2 speed)included
Maximum input capacity 2,150 sheets (Maximum of two additional drawers)
Optional 500 sheet A4/Legal and 1000 sheet A4/Legal drawer
Monthly duty cycle up to 90K pages
Upgrade to 2-4 year At-Home Service3 options are available
Toner cost per page (not including drum) : 0.6 cents (Black), 6.9 cents (Color)
Toner cost per page (including drum) : 1 cent (Black) , 7.4 cents (Color)
Standard Duplex
Ships with 9K Black, 8K Cyan, 8K Magenta, 8K Yellow Toner Cartridges
Standard Ethernet 10/100 BaseT networking, USB and parallel port
Compatible Operating Systems with the 5100cn Windows® 95/98SE/Me/2000/XP, Windows Server 2003, Windows NT 4.0

Unix (HP-UX and Solaris 9)

Linux® (Red Hat® 8/9 and SuSE 8.2/9 English versions)

Mac OS9/OSX over TCP/IP

Novell® NetWare® 3.X, 4.X, 5.X, 6, 6.5

Standard for LPD, Port 9100, FTP protocol

For other protocol, including IPP, Netware, Ethertalk, a Multi-Protocol card is required, Multi-Protocol Card $99
Dell Color Track driver enables designation of color and/or black and white printing with individuals or workgroups.
Dell Printer Web Tool can be used to install, configure, and manage network printers and consumables
Standard 1 year At Home Service3 and 24x7 toll free tech support. 2-4 years extended services options with Fuser Maintenance Coverage included in standard and extended limited warranties

Drum is good for 35,000 pages and is a reasonable $140.

A set of 4 toners (3 8000 page color and 1 9000 page black) is $579. You can get them individually for $169 color, and (a quite reasonable I think) $49 for 9000 page black.

Though it's TON bigger than what I need, at these prices is the Dell not the best value out there?

-Larry
 
Color laser printers are more expensive to maintain than ink jet printers, period. This is true whether you spend $399.00 or $39,999.00 on a printer. While maintenance is more expensive, color laser printers are slightly cheaper to print with (per page). Thus, if you print a lot of color pagers per month, it will even out in end...

With that said, I have experience with one of these color printers mentioned, the OKI.

Pros:

1. A very inexpensive printer with network support (watch for mail-in rebates)
2. Very fast color printing (considering it’s a budget printer)
3. Direct TCP/IP support
4. Expandable (paper tray and duplexer)
5. Durable glossy-like finish

Cons:

1. What OKI loses on the printer sale, they make up on the consumables. Their consumables are over priced
2. Some consumables are set to “expire” before they need replacement (almost all companies do this anymore)
3. Consumables are harder to purchase locally and sometimes must be ordered online
4. Their printer drivers are mediocre

Here’s a little secret: The OKI toner cartridges are nothing more than a tank and sensor for the overflow. With a little patience and practice, you can easily refill them with aftermarket toner. Also, the drum assemblies are set to expire well before they are ready. By replacing a small fuse, you can reset the drum over and over (or until it really needs replacement).
 
This is what is tempting about the Dell. They do NOT have counters in the consumables to kill them before they need replacement.

Apparantly, there is also a firmware option called "Allow use of non-OEM Consumables". Ain't that something :)

Dell service is really scary these days though. It's my main drawback.

The 3100cn is on sale for $349, but the 5100cn, with full 8K/9K toners, is on sale for $699.

There really should be a law against this consumable killing shit. At a minimum there should be an option in the settings to over-ride them.

-Larry

OregonLAN said:
Color laser printers are more expensive to maintain than ink jet printers, period. This is true whether you spend $399.00 or $39,999.00 on a printer. While maintenance is more expensive, color laser printers are slightly cheaper to print with (per page). Thus, if you print a lot of color pagers per month, it will even out in end...

With that said, I have experience with one of these color printers mentioned, the OKI.

Pros:

1. A very inexpensive printer with network support (watch for mail-in rebates)
2. Very fast color printing (considering it’s a budget printer)
3. Direct TCP/IP support
4. Expandable (paper tray and duplexer)
5. Durable glossy-like finish

Cons:

1. What OKI loses on the printer sale, they make up on the consumables. Their consumables are over priced
2. Some consumables are set to “expire” before they need replacement (almost all companies do this anymore)
3. Consumables are harder to purchase locally and sometimes must be ordered online
4. Their printer drivers are mediocre

Here’s a little secret: The OKI toner cartridges are nothing more than a tank and sensor for the overflow. With a little patience and practice, you can easily refill them with aftermarket toner. Also, the drum assemblies are set to expire well before they are ready. By replacing a small fuse, you can reset the drum over and over (or until it really needs replacement).
 
Sorry about that. It was this printer:

The Konica Minolta MagiColor 2400W Color Laser Printer is the ideal personal color laser printer for small offices and home offices. Thinking about purchasing an inkjet printer? The MagiColor 2400W is the color laser alternative. Print letters, photos, and reports quickly and easily - and no special paper is required!
Black-and-white and color laser printing
20 ppm black & white / 5 ppm color
2400 dpi resolution
Hi-Speed USB 2.0 interface
Up to legal size paper
45 seconds average warm-up time
Up to 35,000 pages per month
Desktop Status Display reports how much toner remains and the status of your print job
Compatible with Windows XP, 2000, Me, and 98SE.
Cable NOT included


 
The only downside of this is that it took some time to warm up, from what I remember, but you could push the button on it before you start printing to get it warming up beforehand and there were settings to keep it on longer before going in to power saving mode.

 
Ok, guys, I made my decision. When it was all laid out on the table, there was only one realy choice.

I ordered the Dell 3100CN for some very key reasons:

1. It is on sale $150 off for $349. That's an amazing price for a network color laser with this feature set.

2. The shipping is free right now, which saves another $90 or so. This is a BIG printer.

3. It ships with FULL 4K B/W and Color Cartridges.

4. Replacement Cartridges are reasonable and _more_ than competive.

5. The only other consumable is the Drum, and it has decent life and is reasonably priced.

6. There is an option in the settings to actually allow third-party non-Dell Toners. Never heard of that before :)

7. Reviews are generally very positive, particularly the professional reviews.

8. Photo/Color prints are said to be near-inkjet in quality, with exceptional black quality.

9. I was able to add on a 256MB Memory upgrade for only $53. The price of memory upgrades for a lot of the other printers I looked at were simply beyond believe. $300 for a $128MB upgrade? Paleease!

10. Comsumables are NOT chipped to die at an early age. You can run 'em till they drop.

Lingering concerns:

1. Dell support. Hopefully I won't need it. I don't speak Inglish very well.

2. Size/Weight. This is a big printer and weighs 71 pounds. I'll need to clear a place for it, but that's why they created 100 foot Ethernet cables :)

Short of a disaster happening, I think this is the best overall buy out there taking everything into consideration.

I came real close to going for the 5100CN, which at $699 is an amazing buy, but two things turned me away from it. It's size (it's a behemoth), and reports are it's color printing quality is competitive, but nothing like the 3100CN.

Also I've read several complaints of the Imaging unit only lasting 1/2 of it's rated life, and that's a pretty expensive part on that printer ($270).

The fact that it comes with full 8K cartridges actually outweights the $250 price difference, but you just have to draw the line somewhere. This IS for my home office/computer lab after all. I ain't NASA :)

-Larry
 
Ok, the Dell 3100cn came in.

Took me about 30 min to set it up. It's not as wieldy as the weight would suggest as it doesn't really bulk up in weight until you have the trays, main unit, consumables etc.. all tied to gether in one piece. It's easy enough to work with as you put it together.

Print qualty is surely fine enough.

My only gripe so far? Whoever designed the drivers is an idiot. Unlike most printers, you can't put different sizes of paper in the feeders and just select it in the printer driver. You have to set it in both the printer driver AND the internal printer settings manually.

What dumbass thought up that idea.

Luckily 99% of my printing will be 8.5 X 11.

-Larry
 
Back
Top