[W]arm ? Fileserver setup $58 (geeks.com)

/dev/null

[H]F Junkie
Joined
Mar 31, 2001
Messages
15,181
Dual xeon board (socket 604)
Board has 4 pci-x slots @ 64-bit/100mhz

Xeon 2.4ghz single core * 2
1G ecc registered ddr
heatsinks & fans

Link
 
It's not a bad deal, im tempted to get it.

It's only got one ide connector and nothing more, that ain't to great.
 
The CPUs have a 115W TDP... each.

It will be power hungry as mentioned above. Similar servers using the same CPUs idle at 170-180W. That's around 120KW-hr/month if you leave it on, nevermind any additional AC required from having the heat dumped into your home or office.

If you really want a server like this, geeks and pacificgeek have whole servers sometimes for $100, including SCSI drives, rack mount case and PSU.
 
I thought these were 65W each ?

http://ark.intel.com/Product.aspx?i...6GD,SL6NQ,SL6VL,SL6YN,SL72D,SL73L,SL74T,SL8TJ

Is it not one of these?

Edit: Couldn't I throw in a norco case, some of those 3 pci-x 8 port sata controllers for $90 ea, and a single/dual port pci-x pro/1000mt nic and have a nice little filesever?

yeah it would run hot, but should take a while to fill up, no ?

Total cost before adding disks should be:
Motherboard/cpus/hs/fan/memory: $58
Norco case: $300 (http://www.mwave.com/mwave/SKUSearch_v3.asp?px=FO&scriteria=BA25314)
2 pci-x 8 port sata controllers: $225 (http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16815121009)
1 dual port pci-x intel nic from ebay: $30 (http://cgi.ebay.com/Intel-PRO-1000-...ultDomain_0&hash=item20afe88f2d#ht_2619wt_913)

$650'ish for a fileserver that can hold 24 drives with dual gigabit ethernet...no?
 
Last edited:
As an eBay Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
I thought these were 65W each ?

http://ark.intel.com/Product.aspx?i...6GD,SL6NQ,SL6VL,SL6YN,SL72D,SL73L,SL74T,SL8TJ

Is it not one of these?

Edit: Couldn't I throw in a norco case, some of those 3 pci-x 8 port sata controllers for $90 ea, and a single/dual port pci-x pro/1000mt nic and have a nice little filesever?

yeah it would run hot, but should take a while to fill up, no ?

Total cost before adding disks should be:
Motherboard/cpus/hs/fan/memory: $58
Norco case: $300 (http://www.mwave.com/mwave/SKUSearch_v3.asp?px=FO&scriteria=BA25314)
2 pci-x 8 port sata controllers: $225 (http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16815121009)
1 dual port pci-x intel nic from ebay: $30 (http://cgi.ebay.com/Intel-PRO-1000-...ultDomain_0&hash=item20afe88f2d#ht_2619wt_913)

$650'ish for a fileserver that can hold 24 drives with dual gigabit ethernet...no?

It will still be balls slow with dual single-core CPUs, PCI SATA controllers and only 1GB RAM. I don't think you can even install Server 2008 with only 1GB RAM (and no 64 bit support), and you wouldn't be able to virtualize anything unless you upgraded with the expensive ECC registered DDR ram.
 
As an eBay Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
I think for $650 you could find a much better solution... no?

I was actually looking at this combo several days ago. But, I'm looking for a dual-Xeon motherboard with PCI-e.
 
I thought these were 65W each ?
Where does geeks state it's shipping the LV Xeon? I would bet you're not getting LV Xeons with this board. :p

I should have put 103W/110W instead of 115W, but the platform is still a power hog at idle.

And yeah, you can get a whole server with faster CPUs and drives for ~$160-170 right now (dual 3GHz Dell PE SC1425) at pacificgeek.

But why mess with putting something together around this? You can get a low end quad core server new for $400. http://configure.us.dell.com/dellstore/config.aspx?oc=bedwlr1&c=us&l=en&s=bsd&cs=04 a low end xeon quad core rack mount is ~$770 at dell now.

I guess if you need 24 drives you would want to look into other options.
 
Last edited:
It will still be balls slow with dual single-core CPUs, PCI SATA controllers and only 1GB RAM. I don't think you can even install Server 2008 with only 1GB RAM (and no 64 bit support), and you wouldn't be able to virtualize anything unless you upgraded with the expensive ECC registered DDR ram.

I have served files from boxes WAY slower than this. Also I have no interest in windows....no reason this wouldn't make a nice little iscsi box.

If you are spending $400+ on a windows 2k8 license, you can spend more than $58 on a cpu/motherboard/ram combo :) Using a windows license defeats all the cost savings!
 
I think for $650 you could find a much better solution... no?

I was actually looking at this combo several days ago. But, I'm looking for a dual-Xeon motherboard with PCI-e.

Can I stick 20 (hot swappable) drives in your $650 combo?

I'm not saying this would make a good SERVER, but a good FILE server......if that is what you need.

There are much better options for a barebones _server_ that don't cost much more.
 
Where does geeks state it's shipping the LV Xeon? I would bet you're not getting LV Xeons with this board. :p

I should have put 103W/110W instead of 115W, but the platform is still a power hog at idle.

And yeah, you can get a whole server with faster CPUs and drives for ~$160-170 right now (dual 3GHz Dell PE SC1425) at pacificgeek.

But why mess with putting something together around this? You can get a low end quad core server new for $400. http://configure.us.dell.com/dellstore/config.aspx?oc=bedwlr1&c=us&l=en&s=bsd&cs=04 a low end xeon quad core rack mount is ~$770 at dell now.

I guess if you need 24 drives you would want to look into other options.
Do you have a link to socket 604 xeons ~ 100w ea? I'd like to find out the power usage for these instead of guessing. Also: Can you stick 20 hot swap drives in the $770 delll you are talking about? If not, how would it be a better fileserver?

Edit: This is the only concrete info I can find on 604 2.4ghz xeons. Normal are 65W ea. LV are 40W

http://download.intel.com/design/intarch/prodbref/tc/25270904.pdf
 
Last edited:
processorfinder.intel.com is down right now as it's being migrated. I got the TDPs from there when a pacificgeek server deal came up recently on another board. The link with 65W chips you posted was for LV Xeon sSpec parts. You can verify that by looking up each sSpec listed in that link. I did. :p

Anyways, there are better deals available if you want a cheapie dual server, but many are still a bad idea for home users due to the high power consumption. IMO a solid Intel boxed motherboard and dual core CPU is more flexible for building a stable, OS/hardware validated home server if those things are important.
 
It may be cheaper up front, but the power usage will add up over time. Don't forget that these processors are 8 years old. You'll be very limited in expandability too.
 
Geeks often has refurb servers for cheap, I even purchased a few for work when they were the appropriate type. But of the 6 I purchased 2 had faulty memory.. I got it (memory) replaced, but still.
 
It will still be balls slow with dual single-core CPUs, PCI SATA controllers and only 1GB RAM. I don't think you can even install Server 2008 with only 1GB RAM (and no 64 bit support), and you wouldn't be able to virtualize anything unless you upgraded with the expensive ECC registered DDR ram.

You realize those balls slow PCI-X slots are 'only' good for 800MB/s right?
 
cold deal, although the heat generated will keep your house warm. So maybe it is a "warm" deal.
 
Would have been hot if those hardware were still new. Why wasnt this deal here 10 years ago.
 
A few feet away at work here we have our main server running a SE7520BD2 board with 3.0ghz cpu. It's been up 24/7 for about 5 years now with zero issues ever.
 
I hate to be captain obvious here, but if you are talking about 20+ drives (assuming all 2TB because at $100/ea that is the best value now), you are going to spend $2k on drives and probably $12-50/ port for connecting the drives (HBA's, RAID cards). This vs getting a new, nice Intel/ Supermicro board w/ KVM over IP, warranty and etc. is probably not worth saving a few hundred bucks. My perspective is biased by my homebuild experience though.

Now, if you want a <$60 aging box to have fun with, this isn't a bad deal.
 
I'm saying you CAN build it out for that. If you have a BETTER base for a 20 disk file server on the cheap please post it.

I hate to be captain obvious here, but if you are talking about 20+ drives (assuming all 2TB because at $100/ea that is the best value now), you are going to spend $2k on drives and probably $12-50/ port for connecting the drives (HBA's, RAID cards). This vs getting a new, nice Intel/ Supermicro board w/ KVM over IP, warranty and etc. is probably not worth saving a few hundred bucks. My perspective is biased by my homebuild experience though.

Now, if you want a <$60 aging box to have fun with, this isn't a bad deal.

pjkenned hit the nail on the head. For a simple webserver, single/dual disk file server this is a great deal. If you want to roll out an enterprise grade system you'll be spending more.
 
I used to have a dual Xeon 604 system running on an Iwill DH800. They're not very fast in comparison to newer stuff, but if anyone wants them, I think I still have 2 Xeon 3.06's that I'd let go of for real cheap. I'd just have to find them first....
 
Back
Top