VR-Zone: RV770 Preliminary Performance Revealed

Yeah but look at the price difference 1950xtx was like what 500+ dollars and 8800GTX was like 550+ when it came out.

This card is going to be between 200-300 dollars. Thats a huge difference.. I'll take 40-50% boost in performance if it means I save 200-300 dollars. It will also be great if its a single slot solution.

I have a feeling that the nvidia cards are going to be very hard to get.. Something with a billion transistors is going to be hard to manufacture.
 
Well, if the next generation isn't twice as fast as the previous, it's not really a new generation, is it? More like a (yet another) refresh.

For example: http://www.anandtech.com/showdoc.aspx?i=2926&p=5

The X1950 scores 22.7 FPS, the 8800GTX 48.3. *That* was a "new generation".

I feel the same way :mad:

I was really hoping for a substantial upgrade next month. I guess I could grab a 4870 and move my 8800GT over to my media center though....it's still pimping a 6800.
 
Yeah but look at the price difference 1950xtx was like what 500+ dollars and 8800GTX was like 550+ when it came out.

This card is going to be between 200-300 dollars. Thats a huge difference.. I'll take 40-50% boost in performance if it means I save 200-300 dollars. It will also be great if its a single slot solution.

I have a feeling that the nvidia cards are going to be very hard to get.. Something with a billion transistors is going to be hard to manufacture.

Well, the 320MB 8800GTS was released not long after the high-end 8800 cards, and provided 50% better performance than the previous generation for <$300.

The difference this time is that the high-end part is missing from both ATI's and Nvidia's line-up.. With high-end, I mean the $500 part meant to double the performance of the previous generation. In fact, Nvidia hasn't really released a high-end part since the 8800GTX 768MB. The 9800GX2 doesn't count because it's just two cards bolted together.
 
9800 GX2 counts since it performs like high end part and one can use it like one card.
 
Well that's a matter of personal opinion.

And IMO, the SLI/multi-GPU solution isn't transparent enough for me to count it as "one" card. Too many problems with Vista, multiple monitors etc.. If it showed up as one card like the Voodoo5, then maybe I would consider it "one" videocard. But in its current state, it's two videocard bolted together, IMO.
 
Well, the 320MB 8800GTS was released not long after the high-end 8800 cards, and provided 50% better performance than the previous generation for <$300.

The difference this time is that the high-end part is missing from both ATI's and Nvidia's line-up.. With high-end, I mean the $500 part meant to double the performance of the previous generation. In fact, Nvidia hasn't really released a high-end part since the 8800GTX 768MB. The 9800GX2 doesn't count because it's just two cards bolted together.

Not really. The GTX 280 is the high-end card from NVIDIA and, if rumored specs are any indication, it will be over twice as fast as a 8800 GTX.
 
Not really. The GTX 280 is the high-end card from NVIDIA and, if rumored specs are any indication, it will be over twice as fast as a 8800 GTX.

Doesn't change the fact that Nvidia hasn't released a high end part since the 8800GTX, sure WHEN the GTX 280 is released it may be the part people are waiting for but it's not out yet...
 
Well rumoured GTX 280 compared to 9800 GX2:
86% of shader performance
57% of texture mapping performance

Then of course GTX 280 has SLI issues fixed and some memory related problems too so GTX 280 could be (with luck) as fast as 9800 GX2

Rumoured GTX 260 compared to 9800 GTX:
111% of shader performance
65% of texture mapping performance

With memory bottleneck removed GTX 260 could be as fast as 9800 GTX with luck
 
In fact, Nvidia hasn't really released a high-end part since the 8800GTX 768MB. The 9800GX2 doesn't count because it's just two cards bolted together.

I count it in the pure fact that I can use the card in my non-SLI mobo to get SLI speeds.
 
Well rumoured GTX 280 compared to 9800 GX2:
86% of shader performance
57% of texture mapping performance

Then of course GTX 280 has SLI issues fixed and some memory related problems too so GTX 280 could be (with luck) as fast as 9800 GX2

Rumoured GTX 260 compared to 9800 GTX:
111% of shader performance
65% of texture mapping performance

With memory bottleneck removed GTX 260 could be as fast as 9800 GTX with luck

Are you kidding ?
The GTX 260 will be much more powerful than the 9800 GTX. And luck has absolutely nothing to do with it.
 
Hah I didn't realize Vijay leaked the number of SPs. That's funny.
 
Hmm if the rumors of the GT280 being 2x as fast as a GX2 then one should hope Ati has something as just as strong to counter it.
 
if GTX 280 is 2x faster than GX2 then it's difficult for AMD since they should have something that would be much over two times faster than HD3870 X2..
 
AMD is hoping this GDDR5 attempt will bail them out of trouble :). Hell of a clock speed advantage there. Although GDDR4 didn't do so hot for them.
 
GDDR4 weren't that great..no clock speed advantages. (if there was 20MHz difference in fastest GDDR3 and GDDR4 solution..)
 
I guess ATI has basicly given up trying to best Nvidia on the Ultra high end game. Instead they seem to be focusing on lower the overall card cost while boosting performance without a large impact on overall card cost, which is working out pretty well for them. They are selling cards to the mainstream faster and faster so gotta give them props there.

I do miss the days of the 9700 pro being king , it made Nvidia work alot harder to beat ATI and benefited us most of all in the end.
 
I guess ATI has basicly given up trying to best Nvidia on the Ultra high end game. Instead they seem to be focusing on lower the overall card cost while boosting performance without a large impact on overall card cost, which is working out pretty well for them. They are selling cards to the mainstream faster and faster so gotta give them props there.

I do miss the days of the 9700 pro being king , it made Nvidia work alot harder to beat ATI and benefited us most of all in the end.

What do you mean ?
ATI gave NVIDIA plenty of competition up until the GeForce 8 series. If they hadn't, NVIDIA would've not released probably the best graphics processor ever, G80.

As far as giving up on the high-end, I wouldn't be surprised simply due to their financial problems. It was always my opinion that they should focus on the mid-low end market, where most of the money is, to recover from their precarious financial status. When they reach profitability, then they could get back to the high-end, in both the CPU and GPU market.
 
What do you mean ?
ATI gave NVIDIA plenty of competition up until the GeForce 8 series. If they hadn't, NVIDIA would've not released probably the best graphics processor ever, G80.

As far as giving up on the high-end, I wouldn't be surprised simply due to their financial problems. It was always my opinion that they should focus on the mid-low end market, where most of the money is, to recover from their precarious financial status. When they reach profitability, then they could get back to the high-end, in both the CPU and GPU market.

Umm the 9700 pro had no real competition . Nvidia's response to it was the highly overhyped 5800 Ultra which not only did Nvidia have extremely low yeild rates on during its production (meaing it was extremely limited) but it ran so hot that it had the first monster fan design that we are all use to these days otherwise it was a total botch to say the least . Even the 5900 didn't really perform well compaired to the 9700 pro ( the main factor was the 256-bit memory bus vs Nvidia's 128-bit which neither the 5800 ultra nor the 5900 ultra had) so thats what I'm refering to.
 
Geforce FX5900 series had 256-bit mem bus.

Main issue of FX5900 was that it had only 4xPixel Shader when Radeon 9700 Pro had 8xPixel Shader.
FX5900 cards had higher core clocks, but they didn't make up to those lacking pixel shaders
 
I guess ATI has basicly given up trying to best Nvidia on the Ultra high end game. Instead they seem to be focusing on lower the overall card cost while boosting performance without a large impact on overall card cost, which is working out pretty well for them. They are selling cards to the mainstream faster and faster so gotta give them props there.

I do miss the days of the 9700 pro being king , it made Nvidia work alot harder to beat ATI and benefited us most of all in the end.

To tell the truth, we don't truly know if it's working out well for them at all. A majority of us form members here have a much larger than average tech knowledge. We, for the most part, know a lot about our hardware. The pros & cons, the benefits, etc. Apart from the brand loyalty, we have our reasons to buy the hardware that we do. So when we purchase a CPU, a GPU, a Power Supply, we KNOW what to get & what we want. There is a much larger part of the market that are not as knowledgeable.

When it comes to shelf sales & sales off of online retailers such as newegg, zipzoomfly, clubit, tiger direct, etc, ATI cards seem to sell a decent amount. Where they are hurting bigtime is the full system manufacturers. Dell, HP, Apple, Alienware, Gateway, etc. If you take a real good look at them, you see that a huge majority of there systems come with the Intel/Nvidia combination of hardware. Ads boast Core 2 Duos & Nvidia graphic solutions. This is where Nvidia dominates them at while still selling very well on store shelfs & online sites. That's where AMD needs to break in. They need a hell of an advertising campaign & a whole new marketing strategy to break back in. They keep losing millions to billions every quarter at there current pace. Within that amount, we're not sure if ATI gained or lost revenue since there counted as AMD now.
 
ATi will never get back in the game untill they start putting some TUs on their chips to match the raw power nVidia is putting in their's. 32 is nice, but with half the TUs, are they really going to compete with the G92. They will be fortunate to match the G94 in price to performance. They keep slapping Shader Units on, with out adding power to push the pixels.

I mean damn, they just went to 32 TUs after bieng at 16 for what....4+ years of chips (R480, R580, R600, RV670), while nVidia has been steadily ramping up TUs since the G70 so that they are now at 64TUs on the G92.
 
32 texture units is fine. Keep in mind that a lot of the processing done these days is with pixel shaders rather than texturing.
 
Umm the 9700 pro had no real competition . Nvidia's response to it was the highly overhyped 5800 Ultra which not only did Nvidia have extremely low yeild rates on during its production (meaing it was extremely limited) but it ran so hot that it had the first monster fan design that we are all use to these days otherwise it was a total botch to say the least . Even the 5900 didn't really perform well compaired to the 9700 pro ( the main factor was the 256-bit memory bus vs Nvidia's 128-bit which neither the 5800 ultra nor the 5900 ultra had) so thats what I'm refering to.

You missed my point. I wasn't talking about those days. I was talking about what you said about lack of competition and that with ATI on top, NVIDIA worked a lot harder.
But that's exactly what happened just after the 9700 Pro days. NVIDIA launched the 6 series and has the edge ever since. The edge was turned into absolute leadership, with the GeForce 8 series that was literally a "bomb" over ATI's camp. ATI was just completely overwhelmed by how powerful G80 is/was and had nothing to compete with it and still doesn't, 1.5 years later.

Also, this idea that ATI must be on top so that NVIDIA works harder, is ridiculous. Aren't we in a situation where ATI should be working harder to get back to the top ?
 
ATi will never get back in the game untill they start putting some TUs on their chips to match the raw power nVidia is putting in their's. 32 is nice, but with half the TUs, are they really going to compete with the G92. They will be fortunate to match the G94 in price to performance. They keep slapping Shader Units on, with out adding power to push the pixels.

I mean damn, they just went to 32 TUs after bieng at 16 for what....4+ years of chips (R480, R580, R600, RV670), while nVidia has been steadily ramping up TUs since the G70 so that they are now at 64TUs on the G92.

64 gave G92 some nice fill rates and all that, but real performance didn't beat G80 with 32 by any means, so its not nearly as big a deal
 
I want to add that Kyle is one of the many people in the internet supporting the AA-fixed issue with ATI, so that should have some backing to it!
 
64 gave G92 some nice fill rates and all that, but real performance didn't beat G80 with 32 by any means, so its not nearly as big a deal

G80 has some other major advantages, like more RUs and a wider memory lane, a much better back end than G92.

While games are using more shader intensive scenes, texture resolution and average screen resolution are ramping up as well, this requires more fill rate.

Just look at the numbers between ATi cards and nVidia cards over the past few years, Ati has had more SUs the whole time, yet they consistantly lag behind the nVidia counter parts with more TUs and RUs.
 
Geforce FX5900 series had 256-bit mem bus.

Main issue of FX5900 was that it had only 4xPixel Shader when Radeon 9700 Pro had 8xPixel Shader.
FX5900 cards had higher core clocks, but they didn't make up to those lacking pixel shaders

The main issue was that the FX series had floating point ALUs added as an afterthought, and therefore not powerful enough.
In PS1.x software they could compete well with the Radeon series, and actually have a small advantage usually...
But with PS2.0 the performance totally fell apart (sometimes with more than 50%), making an expensive and powerhungry 5900Ultra perform more like the budget 9500Pro series from ATi.

As for R700 and GT200... they're not in the same league, so comparing them makes no sense. AMD just has to pray that R700 can indeed bring them back up to 9800GTX levels of performance, because GT200 will most probably redefine the performance scale, making a 9800GTX mid-end rather than high-end (which it technically is anyway, because it's built on the same G92 chip that was originally developed for the 8800GT/GTS... there never was a proper replacement for the G80, so we actually moved back from a 384 bit memory bus to a 256 bit bus.. GT200 is the 'real' successor to the G80 and should have a 512-bit bus, and more than 128 stream processors, which is a step forward rather than back from G80)... In which case nothing really changes, because AMD's 3870 is a mid-end card aswell. So AMD's fastest GPU would still only match nVidia's mid-end, and nVidia will have the high-end all to itself.
 
All this talk about the 5800 and 9700 made me dig up some of the old reviews. Man those were the days.

I totally forgot that the 5800's cooler both sucked air in and blew it out of the back plate. It makes the 9700's cooler look odd by comparison.
 
Back
Top