Vista upgrade: 64-bit media?

Hornswoggler

2[H]4U
Joined
Jun 29, 2004
Messages
2,325
Hello all

I have ordered the Vista Home Premium Upgrade w/ Academic discount. One of my goals is to run the 64-bit version of Vista but I am wondering if the media I receive will be 32-bit only and that I would be SOL with anything but XP-64 as a starting point? The MS website seems to indicate that there is a special 64-bit upgrade license, which I assume is not included with the retail upgrade package.

Anybody know if my upgrade key would work w/ 64-bit media? I am all for a clean install, and could install vista64 twice (once w/o key, once with upgrade key) if needed, or try some of the post-install activation updates recently posted in here.

Summary:
- Does the retail upgrade media included 64-bits?
- Will my home premium upgrade key work with 64-bit media?
- Will MS send me 64-bit media if I only have an upgrade key?
 
(i) AFAIA only the retail Ultimate edition includes media for both 32 and 64-bit; other versions require you to send off to MS for.

(ii) I think it needs different keys too (though not 100%); these are issued in the process with MS.

(iii) Don't see why not, it would be a corresponding upgrade key, ie. WinXP to Vista Home Premium Upgrade (32-bit) => Vista Home Premium Upgrade (64-bit).
 
adam.mt, posting advice when you don't actually know the answer isn't helpful at all. You are quite wrong with your assumptions!


Hornswoggler, great purchase choice! That's the best purchase option for private, home use, if you reside in one of the many countries where you don't actually need to be formally enrolled in a course of study to be eligible to purchase it! In response to your questions:

  • The package includes only the 32-bit media, but you are provided with a leaflet giving you a website link from where you can order the 64-bit media. You'll only need to pay postage and handling costs for the alternative disk.
  • Your Product key will work with both disks. You can't, of course, use both on different machines at the same time.
  • Yes, all retail Vista packages entitle you to both 32-bit and 64-bit media - even the Upgrade packages!
 
Everything that Catweazle is correct. I did the exact same path, with an Academic Upgrade version of Home Premium. Ordered 1 64bit disk, and I have 2 copies of Home Prem 64 bit running now.
 
...Ordered 1 64bit disk, and I have 2 copies of Home Prem 64 bit running now.

Yep, that's the thing. The disk isn't specific to your Product code. All Vista DVDs are identical with reagrd to what's on them.

So you don't even need to order the 64-bit DVD if there is somebody close by who already has a 64-bit Vista DVD. Just copy theirs instead!

Remember - the product key is what you paid for. The disk itself and its packaging is really just a convenience - a means to actually get the installation on your rig. Your product key is what determines which version gets installed, and what makes it 'legal'.

My own 64-bit disk is a copy of a mate's 64-bit disk from his Vista Ultimate package. The arrangemenets in place here locally only provide for online credit card payment of the shipping and handling charges, and as I don't use credit cards it was sorta out of the question for me. So a mate made an ISO of his, bunged it on his web storage, and I grabbed the DVD image from there!

A further illustration. I have two legal, retail Vista packages/licenses in operation at present. When I purchased the first of them I made a backup copy of the disk, and used the copy to install with. When I purchased the second package/license I again used that backup copy, using the new product key with it. I now have two genuine Windows Vista packages, and only one of the disks has ever once been popped into a drive. I simply don't like seeing them subjected to the wear and tear of use :D
 
So you don't even need to order the 64-bit DVD if there is somebody close by who already has a 64-bit Vista DVD. Just copy theirs instead!

Honestly I am totally and completely dumbfounded that you'd offer that as advice. I know you're "down under" and while things might be different "down under" with respect to copyright laws (I really have no idea), and regardless of whether someone owns a legit 32 bit version of Vista or not, it is illegal to make a copy of a Vista DVD that belongs to someone else and you are not licensed to use, PERIOD.

I know it's just a convenience thing, that's entirely what "casual copying" means, and this situation you just offered as a suggestion is 100% proof of such a thing. It doesn't matter if you own the product, or you have a COA, or you have a store receipt, none of it does. What matters is you have to follow the rules and acquire the 64 bit Vista DVD legitimately or it's outright software piracy, period.

My lord... respect just flies right out the window, geez...
 
What a load!

If you already have the package with the 32-bit install media you already own the bloody license!

Fair dinkum, some people take 'copyright' to ridiculous extents.

It makes no legal difference whatsoever WHAT you use to install with! You can use an original disk. You can use a backup copy. You can copy the files to a separate partition on your hard drive and install from there if you want! You can deploy the bloody thing over a network!


Assigning your legal product key and activating the installation is what makes it 'legal'. It's got bugger all to do with the bloody physical disk itself.


sheesh!

It is illegal to use somebody else's product key to 'legitimate' your Windows install. Borrowing (or copying and using) somebody else's disk and using your own, legal, product key with it breaks no laws whatsoever!
 
No need for a lawyer. bbz_ghost has simply made the incorrect assumption that the 'license' is attached to the unique physical disk. It's not. The license is attached to your COA sticker and your unique product install code key.

The license becomes active when you first use that product key code to legitimate and activate a Windows installation. It's a contract, basically, not a physical 'thing'.
 
adam.mt, posting advice when you don't actually know the answer isn't helpful at all. You are quite wrong with your assumptions!

My humble apologies. In my defence I got 2 out of 3 right (only got the keys bit wrong). As I said only the retail Vista Ultimate contains both versions, others require you to send off.
 
That's the best purchase option for private, home use, if you reside in one of the many countries where you don't actually need to be formally enrolled in a course of study to be eligible to purchase it!

Well unless you are undertaking proper study then you'll be breaking the licence terms in using it. It doesn't matter whether academic proof is actually required or not to purchase, the terms of ownership Microsoft state still hold true.
 
... unless you are undertaking proper study ...
Terms of use vary from place to place. The US is about the only place where it seems to be really restrictive, but even there it's left unclear on the main MS website whether or not the restrictions actually apply to off the shelf retail academic products. At worst, you'd need to be formally enrolled at an accredited academic institution, but there's no stipulation what course of study you need to be enrolled in. Out-of-hours short courses would be fine, and the license is a perpetual one so it's not dependent upon your continued enrollment.

Here is the eligibility information as pertains to the US. Bear in mind that this is the 'Academic Edition Full Packaged Product' we are talking about, and that a careful reading of that page will indicate that the requirements are quite broad indeed!

In Australia, and many other places, the situation is considerably simplified. From the Microsoft Australia website, eligibility is outlined quite simply as:
To be eligible to purchase discounted retail version Microsoft software off the shelf at participating retail outlets, you must be one of the following:

  • Full or part-time student
  • Home-schooled student
  • Full or part-time faculty or staff of an accredited educational institution
  • Member of a household meeting any of the above criteria
No stipulation whatsoever is made there, you'll notice, regarding educational institution and type of study. "Proper study" is a poorly defined term, and your argument is diminished by the fact that you've used it. In the worst case scenario - the US - there's no exclusion specifically stated regarding those people doing, for example, night classes of short-course study. In the best case scenario - countries like Australia - the mere fact that you are 'teaching yourself' how to use the software makes you 'home-schooled'. Having a child attending school or pre-school, or even residing with a family which has children attending school will make you eligibile.


In reality, retail academic products are restricted only in that they are not a 'commercial' license. They're for private use only.
 
... unless you are undertaking proper study ...

Despite what you say, and your trying to avoid your mistake, that statement is CORRECT. Either yourself, or in some cases another household member, needs to undertake an official (government recognised) educational course. The MS site(s) state so.

the mere fact that you are 'teaching yourself' how to use the software makes you 'home-schooled'.

Well I'd like to see you argue that to Microsoft or a court because you're obviously (and plainly) wrong. Just speak to Microsoft or ask a lawyer to confirm.


I agree that's a wide eligibility criteria exists that emcompasses many people, however unlike you're trying to say it doesn't include everyone! If you don't strictly fulfill the licencing conditions then you aren't licenced at all. Full stop. No argument.

That's the best purchase option for private, home use, if you reside in one of the many countries where you don't actually need to be formally enrolled in a course of study to be eligible to purchase it!

My response:
"Well unless you are undertaking proper study then you'll be breaking the licence terms in using it. It doesn't matter whether academic proof is actually required or not to purchase, the terms of ownership Microsoft state still hold true."

Well I guess to be absolutely accurate I should have wrote "Well unless you <,or in some countries other members of your household,> are undertaking proper study then.....". Otherwise, what I wrote is accurate. What you've wrote and implied clearly isn't, academic pricing ISN'T open to all.

From your tone, and insistance in nit-picking my posts*, I doubt you'll admit your mistake.

(*: Why criticse my first post to this thread? I was correct with 2 answers and said I was unsure about the other that I got wrong. Surely that was helpful? Afterall the point was later clarified....... Meanwhile, you've stated a factual untruth, and yet insist in your correctness, despite it being obviously and plainly wrong. Now which is honestly more helpful?)

I've now set the record straight, and consider that sufficient, so END of argument.
 
LOL! An "I'm right and I'm gonna have the last word" rant :D

Dude, the comment quoted above, from the Microsoft Australia website, isn't an 'excerpt' from the conditions attached to Academic Retail products. It's the ENTIRETY of such comments ;)

:D
 
Just to kick a dead horse and for the "public record," I sent off an email to Microsoft Customer Service that stated the following:

I own a legitimate copy of Vista Home Premium.

My neighbor owns a legitimate copy of Vista Home Premium.

He purchased his copy 1 week after I bought mine because he saw Vista on my machine and wanted it for himself.

After he purchased Vista and got the retail box home, when he opened the box, his legally purchased Vista DVD was DAMAGED BY A LARGE SCUFF MARK so he can't even install it. Circuit City will not give him a refund or an exchange and he's stuck because his DVD IS DAMAGED.

I'm asking you if I can give him a copy of my Vista DVD - the same exact version of Vista - so he can install Vista on his machine since he's a LEGAL OWNER of VISTA HOME PREMIUM JUST LIKE I AM.

He's not interested in waiting 6 to 8 weeks for a replacement DVD from Microsoft to replace the DAMAGED DVD he has. Can I or can I not offer him a copy of the exact same DVD media that he already owns so he doesn't have to sit around on his hands and thumbs or possibly pay for a replacement DVD?

Thanks,
Paul

Supposedly they'd get back to me in 24 hours or less; fat chance of that because it took about 40, but they did get back to me and here's what they said, verbatim:

Microsoft Customer Service said:
Hello Paul,

Thank you for contacting Microsoft Online Customer Service.

I appreciate the time you have taken to write to us on behalf of your friend's dilemma.

Unless Microsoft explicitly gives you permission within the End-User License Agreement (EULA) or License Terms that accompany the Products and Services and/or in the guidelines below, you may not copy, modify, distribute, display, license, or sell any Products and Services or components contained in them. Therefore, you can not copy your CD and give it to your neighbor.

For further assistance wit this, or to obtain information on licensing, I suggest that you contact the Microsoft Licensing Team at (800) 426-9400. They are available Monday through Friday, 6:00 A.M. - 6:00 P.M. Pacific Time.

Paul, however, since your neighbor has a damaged CD, he can obtain a replacement disk from Microsoft by contacting the Microsoft Order Desk Team. They can assist you neighbor in obtaining Replacement disks and manuals for his retail copy of Microsoft software. Our representatives at this center can be contacted by calling (800) 360-7561. Their hours of operation are Monday through Friday, 5:00 A.M. to 7:00 P.M. Pacific Time.

I hope the above information is helpful. If you have further questions or concerns regarding Microsoft Products and Services, please do write back to us.

Thank you for using Microsoft Products and Services.

<support rep's name removed>
Microsoft Online Customer Service Representative

If you have any feedback about your Online Customer Service experience, please submit your feedback by visiting the web link provided below:
https://support.microsoft.com/common/survey.aspx?scid=sw;en;1389&showpage=1&WS=managermail

I of course bolded the relevant statement there in all the form-letter garbage; suffice to say Microsoft says you can't copy a disc to give to someone even if you and the other person hold legitimate licenses. And yes I do find it funny that even Microsoft keeps referring to the Vista "CD" since we all know it's distributed on DVD.

'Nuff typed.
 
bbz_ghost has simply made the incorrect assumption that the 'license' is attached to the unique physical disk. It's not.
Actually, I didn't get that "assumption" at all. I've read over the post 3 times now and still don't see where he even remotely "assumed" that. You are correct though, what you are really paying for is the key. You are dead wrong in the fact that it is OK to rip off and distribute Windows CD/DVDs. I was personally shocked to read it, I had to go back and read the ID that posted it again to make sure it was really you that said it!

'Nuff typed.

I think it is an open and closed case. You always go the extra mile ;)
Not content to just say "64 bit is faster" you have to go and run 4 different systems to get results to prove the fact.
Not content to quote the darned EULA, you go and email Microsoft to confirm it. The world needs more folks like you :cool:

At any rate- COPYright has the word COPY in it for a reason... the name in itself should serve a purpose.
 
Oh for goodness sake! I can't believe you took that effort to 'prove' a petty point using what you acknowledge yourself as "form letter garbage" which has been provided to you by a junior employee!



In the example described by you there your neighbour will end up with:

A genuine hologram Windows CD/DVD (the scuffed one in his package)
A genuine COA label (the one on his package)
A genuine EULA agreement (the one agreed to when he installed the software)
Genuine documentation (that contained in his purchased package.

The rest of the waffle is meaningless, unenforcable, and Microsoft would get severely chastised if they tried to bring legal action against an individual because of it. Your neighbour remains a genuine, legitimately licensed customer irrespective of whether or not his Windows installation was deployed using the original disk or deployed using a backup copy, and in fact the license agreement stipulates that it CAN be deployed using a backup copy.


COPYRIGHT, people, will NOT have been breached in this circumstance because the COPYRIGHT HOLDER has not been denied his fair and entitled remuneration for the use of the copyrighted content. Your neighbour will not have had something 'distributed' to him in respect of which which he hasn't already fulfilled his obligations to the copyright holder. Microsoft's efforts to convince you that such an act constitutes 'piracy'; doesn't actually make it so. No software piracy exists in this action.


Furthermore, your neighbour is entitled, within the restrictions specifically stipulated by Microsoft, to have and use a 'backup copy' of the software disk. The clause covering that is contained within the EULA, and its specific wording is:

10. BACKUP COPY. You may make one backup copy of the media. You may use it only to reinstall the software.

Note there that there isn't, and cannot be, any stipulation or restriction in relation to the method you employ to make that backup copy. Doesn't make any legal difference if it is a 'copy' you make yourself, using your genuine disk in your personal machine, or a 'copy' you employ another person to make on your behalf. It only needs to be 'a copy' of the contents of the media.

The "form letter garbage" is completely wrong in this situation, because what we are really talking about here is the means employed by your neighbour to 'make' that backup copy he is legally entitled to own and use.




That all said, of course, it must be noted that it was in response to ghost's waffle above, and the form letter canned response he received from a staffer.

ghost asked the wrong question, you see. This topic wasn't referring to a 'copy' of the disk the 'neighbour' already has. Instead it's related to the 64-bit media, which the 'neighbour doesn't yet have a genuine copy of. But do you people really think that any action would ever be taken in relation to such a circumstance? Even in that latter scenario it's not something for which additional fee costs need to be paid. The license fee has already been paid with the original purchase. The neighbour isn't receiving something to which he's not legally entitled.

This waffle started off with me making comment that I'd used other means to obtain the 64-bit install to which I'm entitled, remember! I already paid for it. Microsoft hasn't provided me with adequate arrangements to physically obtain that to which I'm entitled. Microsoft isn't ever going to pursue civil action against me, and even if they did they'd be slapped with a counter-suit which they couldn't win.


Argue the petty points of detail all you like, but for goodness sake try to accomodate common sense within it! Like I said earlier, some people try to take 'copyright' issues way too far!
 
LOL! An "I'm right and I'm gonna have the last word" rant :D

Pot calling the kettle black? (......and in this case pot's black and kettle's blue)

Dude, the comment quoted above, from the Microsoft Australia website, isn't an 'excerpt' from the conditions attached to Academic Retail products. It's the ENTIRETY of such comments ;):D

I didn't say it was; try re-reading what I wrote and where I've quoted you and said you're wrong. In short, academic licencing/pricing ISN'T open to all home users in ANY country (including Australia, if that isn't clear enough). If you wish to prove me wrong then provide PROOF. Learning how to use some software you've bought can't be considered 'home schooling' in the context you say. It's obvious.

I don't want an argument, but it would be helpful Catweazle if you admitted you were wrong when you are. It helps no one (including yourself) to insist you're right when you plainly aren't, or to continue unnecessarily criticising others (as you've done to me)...... I admit when I've made a mistake, you should consider that too...... Please try and learn this and how to get along with others; you're otherwise useful assistance would then be more appreciated.
 
.. In short, academic licencing/pricing ISN'T open to all home users in ANY country (including Australia, if that isn't clear enough). If you wish to prove me wrong then provide PROOF.


Oh FFS! Grow up and stop making claims about shit you either don't understand or have no experience of. Here in Australia, just as in a number of other countries, you can walk into a friggin' chain store and buy the bloody thing off the shelf, no questions asked!

Proof? You want me to go down there, take photographs, record interviews with the salespeople and post scans of fucken' receipts?

Please don't be so childish.

I don't care that I'm often blunt and even abrasive. I readily admit when I'm wrong and happily correct any errors I make, and I won't bloodywell back away from the truth just to please you! My interest in posting here is to provide accurate information for the benefit of readers. That's it!


Want more convincing? Microsoft Australia's Anne Flanagan didn't exactly jump back in all righteous when I suggested people could 'legitimise' their circumstances cheaply by grabbing an Academic Edition, did she? (Scroll down to Take #2 for that bit ;))

Why would that be? Easy. Microsoft, as its spokespeople will happily admit "off the record" really couldn't give a shit if people buy the cheaper option rather than pirating. They're happy enough to be getting something rather than nothing from that end-user! And there isn't a snowball's chance in hell that any end-user would ever be pursued over some pedantic triviality of wording in the licensing documents either. Ain't ever gonna happen.


You wanna tell the world that I couldn't possibly have purchased the Academic products I have sitting on the shelf? Go right ahead. I'll laugh. You wanna convince me that Microsoft would be shaking and irate at the stuff I write, letting people know how to cut the corners? Yeah right. I'll belly-laugh at that'n! My shelves are even MORE filled with the freebies I get sent to me when I contact Microsoft and request that they send me stuff so I can write MORE of the same!
 
I've been polite and stated the facts as they are. You've been repeatedly rude, shown inability to read properly, ignored what I've written, and instead tried to argue over issues I've never disputed. I never said you couldn't buy academic software without issue, and never said Microsoft would pursue you for it either. In reality, Microsoft is extremely unlikely to take any home user to court over unlicensed software (even warez) but that doesn't mean it's right or they condone it.

The proof I asked for is where do Microsoft's T&Cs for Academic software say it's open to all home users, regardless of educational status of the user and family (household). No where does it state this, hence you can't provide it, and are thus trying to change the issue. You have a clear inability to admit that and the fact you make mistakes.

Want more convincing? Microsoft Australia's Anne Flanagan didn't exactly jump back in all righteous when I suggested people could 'legitimise' their circumstances cheaply by grabbing an Academic Edition, did she? (Scroll down to Take #2 for that bit )

Er, yes I do. Looking at that article I see Microsoft's Anne Flanagan hasn't posted a reply to any of the forum comments. That likely means she's never read them; it most definitely doesn't mean she sanctions what's said in them (which must be what you are saying since the question posed to her doesn't mentioned buying academic). So how's that proof, as you claim?

....FORGET IT, it seems you'd argue that black's white, won't offer any legimate proof, and won't listen to anybody else, thus the point isn't worth arguing over. Get a life.
 
makeitstop.jpg
 
Anybody want to buy a hair splitter?

Got an almost NIB for sale





Oops wrong forum, my bad
 
- funny picture -


Yes, I really should (and do) apologise for the tone I've used in this topic. I'm a grumpy old bastard at the best of times. Reading through this again suggests to me that posting whilst the countryside was flooded and family stranded all over the place wasn't really a good idea. Sorry about the overly aggressive bits.


No apology, though, for comments about finding answers before posting advice. It really does only take a couple of minutes to check the veracity of advice posted. And the rest of the content really is hair-splitting. In the style of an earlier post:

It isn't 'casual piracy' if you are using your own legitimate and paid for product key. PERIOD!
 
Damn hit the enter button while replying and the post posted.

Anyway I do believe intent is the key word here, you purchased a license and you "should" be able to use that license with what ever media is available. Your intent is not to pirate, but to get what you paid for.

The rest of the legal mumbo jumbo is just that, MS, just trying to cut down on piracy. Morally there is nothing wrong with you using a media not officially provided by MS. Like I say splitting hairs
 
There is an "Edit" button on each post (except posts made in the News forum, those can't be edited) so you can simply click that and go edit the post you just made, or come back to it minutes, hours, days, even weeks or months later and edit it if necessary. Bottom right hand corner of each of your posts (can't edit someone else's, obviously), next to the "quote" button, so you know.

Just a tip... :)
 
Back
Top