Vista 64 vs. XP Pro 32

chockomonkey

[H]F Junkie
2FA
Joined
Oct 11, 2003
Messages
8,474
Let me preface this by saying that the biggest attraction to XP Pro is that i already own it, thus it being free.

I'm considering Vista 64 for my new build. Going to have a Q6600, something around a 8800gtx, and about 2gigs of ram. (i was told this should be enough ram for gaming)

The most i've heard about Vista is that you need it to recognize more than 4gigs of ram. Since this isn't the case in my build, i'm looking for reasons that i should upgrade.

I'm on a budget for this build, and so the thought of saving some money on an OS is attractive. However, are there any advantages that would be worth my money upgrading to Vista from XP and/or from a 32bit OS to a 64?

Thanks for the input!
 
Well, if you're going for an 8800GTX, it'd be a shame to be stuck with DirectX 9 in Windows XP. Vista will give you DirectX 10.

And the 64-bit version of Vista is slightly more robust/secure than the 32-bit version. When more 64-bit software comes out, it will probably give you a small advantage in terms of performance (or better graphics, like with the 64-bit version of Far Cry).

I'd turn the question around. What reasons do you have NOT to go for Vista and 64-bit?
You can still do a dualboot with XP (and you can buy a cheaper upgrade version of Vista). This way you have a fallback for software that won't work in a 64-bit OS or Vista. I would recommend that, although you probably won't have to resort back to XP often (I don't).
 
i suppose the only reason i was considering NOT going with an upgrade is because i wanted to save money.

I've heard of compatibility problems with 64 bit... is it that much of a pain to try to find drivers/software that supports 64 bit?
 
i suppose the only reason i was considering NOT going with an upgrade is because i wanted to save money.

I've heard of compatibility problems with 64 bit... is it that much of a pain to try to find drivers/software that supports 64 bit?

Not bad at all. I have (like many others) found 64 bit drivers for everything which work well. Vista 64 is a stable OS which is a must for a user with 4GB of ram. I see that you are going with 2GB, in that situation you should use something like Vista 32. If you buy a retail version of Vista I believe you can get the 64 version for free (you just pay shipping) which you could use down the road when you get more RAM. :)
 
Well, i threw 2gb in there because that is kinda what i had decided upon when i chose to stick with XP... but since then (and party becuase of ram prices atm) i may end up going with 4gb... I just have to figure out if that will make OCing any more difficult...
 
Also... as the reason for not upgrading was because of money (i don't have to buy xp), i know i won't go with Vista 32, as the version of XP i have is 32 bit. If there are good reasons for moving to 64bit i'd probably fork up the cash and buy vista. But at the moment, i don't see vista in itself anything that much better than xp... unless i'm mistaken :p
 
DX10 is imo one of the biggest gimmicks over the past year. Makes no difference at all in graphics currently, and runs worse. Things may change in the coming months/years though. I didn't buy my card because it had dx10 anyway, just because it ran dx9 better than the others. :)
 
DX10 is imo one of the biggest gimmicks over the past year. Makes no difference at all in graphics currently, and runs worse.

That's because no engine so far has actually been designed for DX10 yet.
Even so, Bioshock already proved that DX10 can get slightly better performance and quality than DX9.
Crysis is going to be the first REAL DX10 game, which will make quite a bit of difference visually (most importantly the whole tonemapping/bloom/related HDR effects are higher quality in DX10, giving more vibrant and realistic colours), and will probably also give better performance than DX9. It will actually use some of the new shader features to accelerate things like smoke, fire and destructive environments. All games on the market so far are just DX9-games which have been hacked around to run on the DX10 API and some slightly fancier shaders. Basically DX10 is being *used* as a gimmick in those games.
That's not exactly giving a proper view on what DX10 can do, neither in terms of visual quality nor performance. But as I say, even so, Bioshock already uses DX10 to offer better quality visuals (most notably better HDR effects and sharper shadows) while maintaining the high performance of DX9.

Mark my words, 6 months from now everyone will want to run Vista/DX10 for the better graphics and performance.
That's my view, as a Direct3D developer.
 
Back
Top