Video Game Ratings Decided By Computers?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Removing the human element from game ratings? Is this really a good idea? It just seems like it will give more ammunition to the groups already criticizing the ESRB. What are your thoughts on this?

Starting on Monday the ratings board plans to begin introducing computers to the job of deciding whether a game is appropriate for Everyone, for Teens or for Mature gamers (meaning older than 16). To do this the organization has written a program designed to replicate the ingrained cultural norms and predilections of the everyday American consumer, at least when it comes to what is appropriate for children and what isn’t.
 
"Ingrained cultural norms"? This is totally bogus. The ratings are ridiculous enough as it is, but having software decide what is appropriate for different age groups? This is the dumbest dumb ass thing I've ever heard. Take it from this software developer: this is just a scheme to avoid the responsibility of making judgment calls. "It's the computer's fault.."
 
It's not going to matter much what rating it get's, if Mikey wants the game he'll find a way- thanks bro!
 
taking bets (Must PM me with infor don't post here, it starts at $0.01 and ends at $0.02, winner will get entire pool (- my cut ;)) max payment to winner will be $0.10
after my cut the remainder of the money will go to Japan relief funds :))

i bet on 1 month before it fails, and humans have to step in to save the day. (wanted to go on 1 week, but the dumbasses who made this won't realize it that soon so better safe than sorry)
 
USA, from democracy to Idiocracy.

A computer, even Watson, will not get it CLOSE to right.
 
Movie appropriate for everyone: Lots of violence, some nudity, at least three sex scenes

Game rated Teen: Mild violence, absolutely no nudity (even partial), not even the slightest hint of a romantic scene

Why is this?
 
USA, from democracy to Idiocracy.

A computer, even Watson, will not get it CLOSE to right.

If you have ever watched this movie, you would realize that this might actually be an improvement over the idiots who are currently doing the ratings.
 
Another relevant piece by ArsTechnica. One thing the NYTimes didn't mention was that the system is planned for use for games that are only digitally released.

I think as long as the developers are relatively honest, the ratings will be where they should be. Just a matter of how thorough the ESRB human verifications are. In any case, I suppose we should all be expecting some big news story and inevitable outrage about how a developer sneaked a hardcore sex scene into their indy game that was rated Teen.
 
As templarknightx points out, if the developers are honest it will work. The "survey" method will allow some of this to be present while fairly accurately categorizing a game's content. And when the system fails it will clearly fall back on the Developers for misrepresenting their game "in the survey". Probably a far superior method to having humans play these games and make the determination, while being influenced by a huge variety of subjective factors.
 
I think it will work great! For a reference, look at all the people who are thrilled with the Bowl Championship Series.
 
Movie appropriate for everyone: Lots of violence, some nudity, at least three sex scenes

Game rated Teen: Mild violence, absolutely no nudity (even partial), not even the slightest hint of a romantic scene

Why is this?

The lowest I have seen a movie with nudity get rated is PG-13 with both being "special" in terms of Nellie and Titantic.

But its all bull crap. I think back to the penny arcade comic from 2 weeks ago with the Duke Nukem hiney slapping commotion. Whether its a game or a movie too much is made of some swear words or a boob or two, while violence (you know the actual bad thing) gets a free pass because its harder to avoid. If I had a kids I think I would rather have one a little "loose" or swore like sailor, then one prone to violence. Though none of those are really an issue because the most that happens when people play games is some kids get insular, the exact opposite of any of the above issue.

Ratings are shit, tell me whats in the game/movie and I can make the choice of what my kid watches/plays. By the time they can sneak out/buy a game that I haven't allowed them to watch/play then they are probably old enough to see/play everything including Pron.
 
Back
Top