Video editing computer

carlmart

Gawd
Joined
Sep 17, 2006
Messages
691
I wasn't sure where to raise my questions, as they deal with several areas in PC hardware.

Let's hope video editing oriented people come here have a look.

I am starting to check information on what stuff to use on a video editing PC. The program I will use will be Avid Xpress HD.

My initial ideas were to start for an Intel Core 2 Duo desktop, with an E6600 cpu. The motherboard most people seem to be using is the Asus P5W DH.

What do you think? What else?


Carlos
 
what's your budget..? anyways.. you'll probably want at least 2 gigs of ram and fast storage (maybe 2 raptors in raid 0..?)

My budget: as low as possible! :)

Seriously now, I really don't know, but I was expecting to spend at least $1,500 including everything but the monitors.

2 Gigs Ram, at least. Probably Buffalo Firestix 6400. Video board, even if I should go for a Nvidia Quadro, I think I might be better served with a Geforce 7600GT 256MB.

If by Raptors you mean WD, certainly not. I will never again use a WD except as paper-weight. Seagate or better only. Probably one or two 500GB in raid 0.

Did I go over budget?
 
WD Raptor = fastest non-scsi hard drive around. If you want speed, suck it up and get a raptor or two. Even if you want more capacity along with speed, the WD5000YS is still one of the fastest drives. Your only other alternative besides scsi is Seagate 'cuda ES, using perpendicular recording technology (or the slightly lower classed 7200.10). Check out Storagereview.com for their performance database.

No need for super overclockable ram with an E6600. Vanilla DDR2-800 sticks will do fine. Look for a 2GB kit under $180. Get a Tuniq Tower or Scythe Ninja/infinity (or zalman 9500/9700) if you want to OC past 3Ghz.

If you don't need crossfire, go for a P965 Express chipset based board instead, like the P5B-E or P5B Deluxe.
 
WD Raptor = fastest non-scsi hard drive around. If you want speed, suck it up and get a raptor or two. Even if you want more capacity along with speed, the WD5000YS is still one of the fastest drives. Your only other alternative besides scsi is Seagate 'cuda ES, using perpendicular recording technology (or the slightly lower classed 7200.10). Check out Storagereview.com for their performance database.

Barracuda ES is at the top of my list. I will check Storagereview.

No need for super overclockable ram with an E6600. Vanilla DDR2-800 sticks will do fine. Look for a 2GB kit under $180.

That's the price of the Buffalo Firestix, that was very recommended on another Hard Forum.

Get a Tuniq Tower or Scythe Ninja/infinity (or zalman 9500/9700) if you want to OC past 3Ghz.

Yes, will get a powerful and silent cpu heatsink. But I don't plan to OC. No need to in video editing.

If you don't need crossfire, go for a P965 Express chipset based board instead, like the P5B-E or P5B Deluxe.

The P5W looks like a much better choice, also having two IDE sockets and better arranged PCI slots. The MB is probably the only thing there's no better choice for me, I think.
 
My budget: as low as possible! :)

Seriously now, I really don't know, but I was expecting to spend at least $1,500 including everything but the monitors.


I hope you're a student then, because Xpress Pro HD is around $1500 to $1600 alone unless you're a student (and if you need a mojo with that it's gonna be a grand total of $2600). What kind of video editing are you planning to do. Are we talking freelancing for TV stations here, or are you just gonna be doing projects for yourself, or documentary work or what? The reason I ask is that Premiere Pro is an excellent editor for the average user. I've even seen it used in newsrooms for daily-turn stories. To be honest, unless you're looking to do major on-the-fly effects (rather than just cuts only and dissolves) or unless you need to feed an on-air server, Premiere is a much more cost-effective way to go at only around $600. Version 2.0 will do HD as well.

That said, you're on the right track hardware-wise, no matter which software you pick. 2 gigs of ram is a great move - as is the core duo processor. I'm sure you already know to cheap out on the video card unless you also plan to game on this machine. A good video card will do you absolutely no good with video editing. Dump the money you save into a faster chip.

I like M-audio soundcards for editing work (one of 'em even has XLR ins if you need to take analog stuff as well). They're pretty reasonably priced too - although as you get more insane with the specs they spike pretty high. They're a division of Avid, btw.

If by Raptors you mean WD, certainly not. I will never again use a WD except as paper-weight. Seagate or better only. Probably one or two 500GB in raid 0.

Yeah, I sadly agree there. I used to be a hardcore WD guy until my 200 gigger lost all its data 3 times and then finally fried itself. I'm about to get a Seagate myself. I think SATA will be fast enough for what you will probably be doing, but again it'll help if you tell us exactly what kind of video work you're going to do.
 
What kind of video editing are you planning to do. Are we talking freelancing for TV stations here, or are you just gonna be doing projects for yourself, or documentary work or what? The reason I ask is that Premiere Pro is an excellent editor for the average user. I've even seen it used in newsrooms for daily-turn stories. To be honest, unless you're looking to do major on-the-fly effects (rather than just cuts only and dissolves) or unless you need to feed an on-air server, Premiere is a much more cost-effective way to go at only around $600. Version 2.0 will do HD as well.

The program is not really something I wish to discuss. I am video/film director and producer, for now working on my own projects. And I do need several things that Avid provides. Particularly now that I am going into HDV.

That said, you're on the right track hardware-wise, no matter which software you pick. 2 gigs of ram is a great move - as is the core duo processor. I'm sure you already know to cheap out on the video card unless you also plan to game on this machine. A good video card will do you absolutely no good with video editing. Dump the money you save into a faster chip.

Or better and larger monitoring perhaps. More HDD space too, as HD is so greedy.

I like M-audio soundcards for editing work (one of 'em even has XLR ins if you need to take analog stuff as well). They're pretty reasonably priced too - although as you get more insane with the specs they spike pretty high. They're a division of Avid, btw.

That's interesting, because audio soundcards now have practically lost any sense in video or audio editing. In video you going in through 1394, and in audio through USB or directly through DVD or CD audio files.

The board I have, an Echo Mia, is great, but it's not even in my computer right now. It will be later for better monitoring probably.

Yeah, I sadly agree there. I used to be a hardcore WD guy until my 200 gigger lost all its data 3 times and then finally fried itself. I'm about to get a Seagate myself. I think SATA will be fast enough for what you will probably be doing, but again it'll help if you tell us exactly what kind of video work you're going to do.

Documentaries, features, highly developed stuff. Even if I will try many things, I will go out to a higher HD suite for effects and final touches. But I want to see first what I will be achieving, exactly, and pay just for the effect time I will be using. Maybe that explains things a bit better.

And you certainly should go the Seagate way yourself. I did after getting problems with Maxtor and then WD. Also problems with a WD 200GB myself, after a few months. Now I don't buy anything that offers less than 3-year warranty, enforceable in Brazil too.
 
That's interesting, because audio soundcards now have practically lost any sense in video or audio editing.

This is true, from an actual audio manipulation standpoint. But you still have to hear it when you're editing it, and the m-audio cards do a better job of reproducing that sound ;)
 
That's the price of the Buffalo Firestix, that was very recommended on another Hard Forum.

Yes, will get a powerful and silent cpu heatsink. But I don't plan to OC. No need to in video editing.

The Firestix are around $190... the Patriot eXtreme Performance LLK sticks have better timings, and are $190AR. However, since you don't plan on overclocking, theres no need for anything higher than DDR2-533. Stock speed on an E6600 is 9 * 266 = 2.4Ghz, and the ram will be running at 2 * 266 = DDR2-533. The Core2Duo platform doesnt benefit as much from a RAM_only_overclocked setup as does the AM2 platform. It performs best at a 1:1 ratio.
 
This is true, from an actual audio manipulation standpoint. But you still have to hear it when you're editing it, and the m-audio cards do a better job of reproducing that sound ;)

This where the Echo Mia enters, which is as good or better than many M-Audio. Don't know about that particular model you are talking about.

But I researched that field quite well when I bought the Mia. Also has balanced inputs and outputs. Will certainly use it.
 
The Firestix are around $190... the Patriot eXtreme Performance LLK sticks have better timings, and are $190AR. However, since you don't plan on overclocking, theres no need for anything higher than DDR2-533. Stock speed on an E6600 is 9 * 266 = 2.4Ghz, and the ram will be running at 2 * 266 = DDR2-533. The Core2Duo platform doesnt benefit as much from a RAM_only_overclocked setup as does the AM2 platform. It performs best at a 1:1 ratio.

It will be a tough decision between the Firestix and the eXtreme then. The price I could find on the Patriot was slightly higher, maybe a different model.

But I think I will go for a DDR2 800. Maybe I should try a slight OC to see what happens. It might be an issue if I make up my mind on using After Effects. That should affect the video board decision too, as the Quadro capabilities (still not sure what they are) seem to apply better with AE.
 
This where the Echo Mia enters, which is as good or better than many M-Audio. Don't know about that particular model you are talking about.

But I researched that field quite well when I bought the Mia. Also has balanced inputs and outputs. Will certainly use it.


Yeah, when I recommended the M-Audio you hadn't told us you had the Mia. That'll do fine as well.

I don't think, btw, that you'll need to OC it. It sounds like what you're getting will be more than powerful enough to do what you want without any OC.
 
Yeah, when I recommended the M-Audio you hadn't told us you had the Mia. That'll do fine as well.

Sorry for that. The digital interfacing, via 1394 or USB, has become so automatic that I forgot I even had the Mia. But I will need it for output quality audio.

I don't think, btw, that you'll need to OC it. It sounds like what you're getting will be more than powerful enough to do what you want without any OC.

My main concern is about the mobo, which seems to have heat issues on the chipset. As I live in Rio de Janeiro, that is a concern.
 
What about the video board?

I can't quite understand what a Quadro FX560 board, for instance, does better than say a Geforce 7600GT.

Even so Avid recommends the Quadro types, which are much more expensive.

Once I read it was the Open GL capability, but the specs show both having OpenGL 2.0.

Maybe it was a question of the past video boards, but is it still valid?

My present setup, with a GeForce 6200, handles Avid pretty well, and I never noticed anything lacking from that angle. My mobo is a Giga K8NS with an Athlon 3200 and 1GB RAM. Edits DV quite well.

Perhaps if you will use After Effects the demands will be greater, but I am still not sure if a 7600GT or similar wouldn't handle it.
 
To be frank, I think half of Avid's video recommendation is a marketing ploy. "well see you'd have to spend all this money to build a computer to these specs, why not just uh, buy a turnkey system from us? Yeah, that's it."


As for heat - I assume despite your location that you will have the computer in an airconditioned room (and if you're not planning on that, you should) so I wouldn't worry too much about that.
 
To be frank, I think half of Avid's video recommendation is a marketing ploy. "well see you'd have to spend all this money to build a computer to these specs, why not just uh, buy a turnkey system from us? Yeah, that's it."

Quite likely so, or at least the vendors will have a reason to sell Avid and expensive systems. ;)

As for heat - I assume despite your location that you will have the computer in an airconditioned room (and if you're not planning on that, you should) so I wouldn't worry too much about that.

Maybe yes and maybe not. There are some things I will have to do, which will deal with computer noise and temp. They should take care of putting the heat out of the case. Things like a proper case (Antex P180), with efficient ventilators, a proper cpu heatsink (Ninja), HDD fan cooling and a way to deal with the chipset heatsinking, which seems not to be too good on this mobo. There are other small parts inside that can use heatsinking and contribute to the case internal temp. This should probably reward me with reliability.

When the heat comes out I will have to think of doing something with my environment, like turning on the AC. :)
 
My comment above, about taking the hot air from inside the case, vs using air conditioning is based on fact.

During all last year I have been quite aware of hardware temperatures and how to lower them. The average in Rio, except in the summer, is not that hot. Around 25/27 degrees C. So I kept check on the inside temps every now and then in 2006. Turning the AC on did very little to improve things, only if you opened the case.

Right now the CPU is at 32 degrees, and the hottest Seagate is at 39. But the case is far from efficient, and the CPU's hs is the AMD's. Just for you to have an idea. Not really that hot.

CPU temps go up to 40 when I am rendering. So using AC things would be better indeed, particularly for me. Right now temps here are at 35 degrees. All C, of course.
 
Wouldn't want to use ECC RAM instead of Non-ECC?

I don't think you would - in the first place it's slower since it has to run the error correcting code. In the second place it's more expensive. I've been editing for years on machines with regular, non-ECC ram and have never had a problem.
 
I don't think you would - in the first place it's slower since it has to run the error correcting code. In the second place it's more expensive. I've been editing for years on machines with regular, non-ECC ram and have never had a problem.

Well, if the OP is doing a lot of movie editing and does not want errors, I would think he would rather have correct picture and sound than disjoined picture and sound. I hate when that happens when I rip and encode my movies.
 
Back
Top