Video cards for Video Editing?

Dario D.

Gawd
Joined
Dec 8, 2004
Messages
582
Hi all. I was just wondering if I can expect a big performance increase when editing HD video with a video card designed for graphics (such as Matrox and nVidia Quadro cards). I did a search, but couldn't come up with anything concrete. I know these cards improve performance in apps like 3d Studio Max, but I don't know about video editing.

I'm using Adobe Premiere CS3, and the HD editing speed can be SLOOOOOOW, even on my rig (using an Athlon 6400+ X2, and a fast HD, almost as fast as a Raptor).

Any pointers? Thanks.
 
If your heavy into video editing you should look into a better cpu, quad core, though I am not sure if premiere uses all cores, and more system Ram.

I think this sums it up,
The component priorities should be CPU, Memory, Hard Drive. For video editing CPU and memory are the critical components, and it’s easy to add more hard drive space down the line.

Graphics are not that important. Avoid integrated graphics, but a low-end graphics card (such as a NVidia 6800GS or ATI X300) is more than adequate for video editing. Integrated graphics slow the system down, but most dedicated graphics cards are more than you’ll ever need for video editing.

http://www.camcorderinfo.com/content/Picking-a-PC-for-Video-Editing.htm
 
Personally, I have an 8800GT which has hardware acceleration for most video codecs used for video files, SD or HD, but it's still not amazingly fast in Premiere, so I guarantee you that a fast card won't help you. I've never tried a Quadro though, so I can't say anything about that.

Now I also have a quad-core and I'm sure this thing helps, but Premiere doesn't come close to fully utilizing its power so I can't tell you how much of a difference it makes. It does use all 4 cores, but at a very low percentage each. When it comes to rendering/exporting videos though, it all mostly depends on your codec, not the software you use. I find that DivX 6.8 is pretty much the only codec that uses 4 cores at about 80% each when rendering. Everything else gets them up to about 30-50% at best. Most keep them around 30%. I've tried H.263, H.264, XviD, MPEG2, etc.
 
If your heavy into video editing you should look into a better cpu, quad core, though I am not sure if premiere uses all cores, and more system Ram.

Definitely this. CPU, then Ram, then HDD, then video. That 8800GTS should be beyond overkill. Integrated is ok, but it tends to do weird things at times, and even the $30 bargain bin cards, so long as they have on-board RAM, are fine until you get into 3D or things that rely on it (like some things in After Effects).

It seems to me like the X2 AMD systems feel slower than the Core2Duo Intel ones, for reasons beyond my understanding (I don't read benchmarks for entertainment). You might consider moving to a quad-core Intel setup, and definitely at 4GB of ram and an OS that will use it.

Set up your drives (if you haven't) so everything is on a different disk: OS, scratch, app, source content, and render output.

You can also try using a more efficient intermediary codec, like Cineform Aspect HD.

Premiere is a hog, anyway. :rolleyes:
 
Your CPU is fine, I doubt adobe was expecting people to have an e8400 when they were programming CS3.

But you definitely want more RAM. Even if you don't have a 64 bit OS, 3.5 GB of RAM will give you noticeable improvements in Photoshop and video rendering.
 
Sounds as if he's looking for something specifically built for video editing. There are such cards and they process video faster than a CPU as they are built specifically for that . They play games like crap too. I have a good friend who is a professional videographer for weddings and the like. With his $1500+ (?) matrox card he can edit in real time. I don't know the specific model he has but as I said- it's a professional video editing card.

or perhaps I'm wrong and the OP is a gamer who wants to edit part time.
 
Yer so we need to know your specifics. I think Ram + CPU, maybe consider a Mac or a 'Hackintosh' wait, please dont ban me if im not meant to say that, Editing with final cut studio is well, lets jsut say makes premiere look avg at best.
 
Thanks for the replies, all.
With his $1500+ (?) matrox card he can edit in real time. I don't know the specific model he has but as I said- it's a professional video editing card.
Yes, this is what I was hoping to hear (minus the price, lol)... can anyone confirm this?

I know certain programs (like Sony Vegas) let you edit in real-time simply because they work differently than Premiere, but I prefer using Premiere just because I need tons of manual control (and custom content), as opposed to Vegas' sheer relentless speed and automation. (btw, comparing only with Vegas 4, which my brother uses. I have no idea how the newer versions add up)
 
Yes, this is what I was hoping to hear (minus the price, lol)... can anyone confirm this?

Matrox had their card+breakout box (Matrox RT and RT-Mac) solution that used the newfangled-at-the-time c-cube chip to do real-time MPEG2 and others. It was $1k. I had one but never used it, most of the time spent on a job was waiting for some compositing pass or another in After Effects, on multiple boxes. I could do realtime or close to it preview anyway most of the time on modern hardware. It didn't do HD or component input anyway, only worked on the box you had it in, and the 'realtime' effects were extra fluff. Bleh.

They have an updated RT-X2, which claims support for HD but in somewhat ambiguous terms (sounds like HD MPEG2 and HDV): http://www.matrox.com/video/products/rtx2/home.cfm
Priced around $1.3k. At least it has component input/output now.

They also have a much more appealing Axio product line (loads of codec support, 10 bit color, HD-SDI, real-time color correction, and a likely redundant multichannel audio setup), but then you're talking $4k+. http://www.matrox.com/video/products/axiohd/home.cfm

I guess if you edit all day it makes sense. Otherwise, I'd just use proxy clips and buy more external storage and a nicer monitor. :)
 
I can do basic HD editing with a Q6600 and 4 gigs of ram, in real-time... add color correction and other effects and it tends to slow down to just under 30fps, but not all the time... I just render it to a 1080p30 .m2t file and watch it in VLC to check out it playsback after being fully rendered.

Working in Vegas 8 btw..
 
Back
Top