I can't imagine why anyone would enable neat (sometimes obscure) graphical tricks like antialiasing and anisotropic filtering and leave their cards with the task of displaying whatever partially-overlapping frames they see fit.
The point of vertical sync is to tie the GPU to each monitor's differing capabilities. On my 60hz Cinema Display, I've noted extensive tearing at 60fps, beyond 60fps and below, yielding any game simply unplayable. I leave vertical sync on because it's intended to be left on.
I think the 'mouse lag' is simply the perception of difference by users who have consistently been told to play with vsync off, have done so for a long time and have only flicked vsync on just to see the end result. If someone has been playing one game with the same settings with vertical sync off for months, even years, changing any variable is certain to hurt one's performance online. If you get any obsessed CS:S player to change their mouse speed from whatever to whatever minus two, they aren't going to end up being a happy camper.
If you've been bred to race Ferraris, you're not going to enjoy having to drive a Lotus in one race.
The point of vertical sync is to tie the GPU to each monitor's differing capabilities. On my 60hz Cinema Display, I've noted extensive tearing at 60fps, beyond 60fps and below, yielding any game simply unplayable. I leave vertical sync on because it's intended to be left on.
I think the 'mouse lag' is simply the perception of difference by users who have consistently been told to play with vsync off, have done so for a long time and have only flicked vsync on just to see the end result. If someone has been playing one game with the same settings with vertical sync off for months, even years, changing any variable is certain to hurt one's performance online. If you get any obsessed CS:S player to change their mouse speed from whatever to whatever minus two, they aren't going to end up being a happy camper.
If you've been bred to race Ferraris, you're not going to enjoy having to drive a Lotus in one race.