Venice or San Diego?

Gh()st

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jul 31, 2003
Messages
473
Ok, so I'm finally doing the AMD64 plunge. Been a longtime Intel !!!!!!. I've always run Intel systems for myself, while my family/friends got the lower-end AMD solutions. ( typically due to cost constraints ).

I recently built a mid-to-low-end system for a friend using a Fry's 3000+ 64/ ECS NF3 combo. I noticed during the build process the damn thing booted/ran almost 2x as fast as my current rig. Mind you, I built my system 2 X-mas ago......

his:
AMD 64 3000+
ECS NF3-A ( 250 )
1GB Kingston value ram
120GB WD SATA

mine:
P4 3.0c
Abit IC-7 G
1GB Mushkin ( 2x256 level II, and 2x256 special 2-2-2 )
2x60GB Maxtor SATA Raid 0

I've been wanting to do some custom painting on my clearPC/Acrylic case, and knew I'd need some down-time to get that done. Being bitten by the speed demon/bug, I figure this is as good a time as any to upgrade.

So, all that being said I've been looking around and have come upon what I think will be a decent uprgade/setup. I only have 1 condition: I currently have a PNY 6800 AGP with all pipes opened 16x6. I really don't have the funds to buy a new mobo, CPU, memory, AND Vid card. As such, the vid card stays, and I'll need a mobo that's 939/AGP compliant. Future proof is also a desireability. ( is that a word? )

Afte some google'ing/research I came upon the the Asrock 939 Dual mobo.

Asrock 939 Dual SATA2

review on Anandtech

It's got the AGP compliancy, and future PCIe/CPU support. I'm not keeping any of my old hardware ( well, except for the 6800 ), so I've decided to also pick up some Crucial Ballistix memory.

link

Now here is the question.

I can't afford a X2. Don't see the need as I'm not a serious/hardcore gamer anyways. ( used to be, but don't have the time anymore. ) I was thinking about picking up a Venice core CPU ( 3200 or 3500 ), but noticed the San Diego's. Other than the L2 cahce size being bigger ( 1Mb as opposed to 512K ), is there enough of a difference between the CPU's to warrant buying a SD over a V? Also, I keep seeing V cores listed as both 800Mhz, and 1000Mhz FSB. Are there 2 differnet V Cores? ( I don't see that listed on AMD's CPU spec sheet )

:(
 
I recommend you get double the L2 cache with the San Diego.

Unless you're planning to OC. Then I have no freakin' clue. ;)


The 3500 is $201. You can get an X2 3800 for $299. So I'd save up a couple extra bucks and splurge on dual core if you can.
 
The only difference between san diego and venice is cache size (and price) - thats it.

I personally do not like the Asrock board (from experience) - go with a dedicated AGP nforce 3 or a dedicated PCI-e nforce 4 - you will get better performance out of those baords. But if you NEED to have both AGP and PCI-e then there is no better board that that Asock.

btw - dual core is not for gaming - at the moment, it actually hurts gaming performace w/o tweaking. It is great for encoding and multi tasking goodness

good luck
 
S1nF1xx said:
I recommend you get double the L2 cache with the San Diego.

Unless you're planning to OC. Then I have no freakin' clue. ;)


The 3500 is $201. You can get an X2 3800 for $299. So I'd save up a couple extra bucks and splurge on dual core if you can.

Or an Opty 165 ;) for the same price
 
fuelvolts said:
Or an Opty 165 ;) for the same price

I left that out on purpose. See the OC comment I had. :p

I know the Opteron has become popular but I don't OC...
 
fuelvolts said:
The only difference between san diego and venice is cache size (and price) - thats it.

I personally do not like the Asrock board (from experience)

Other than the known cold-boot issue, ( which was supposedly fixed with a bios update ) what issues have you had?

I actually don't mind going to a NF4 + AGP board. It's just going to cost extra $$ when I decide to upgrade to a newer vid card in the future for a PCIe mobo.
 
The increased L2 cache does not give you any extra performance for games. Since most games are single threaded, it will only give the performance of one of the cores (ex. a AMD 64 4800+ X2 will run the same as a AMD 64 4000+ in games).

Though you will be able to easily run things in the background such as music, downloads, etc. with ease. From what I've read the 3700+ san diego core is great for overclocking. With stock voltage it got to 2.8 or something.

...Dan
 
Did some searching, and I'm not seeing any NF4+AGP boards (at least that is something decent). Have to step back to a NF3 250/Ultra. Otherwise It's the ULI or other chipsets.
 
I'm also upgrading soon, i'm planning on going with ASRocks 939DUAL-SATA2 board.

From all the reviews I've seen it's AGP performance is on par with other AGP based boards. Since this ASRock is not doing the same as other companies and using a couple PCI card ports put together to make AGP (and lose special AGP features), it allows the board to work nicely to run the same as AGP based motherboards.

Also this board will provide you with a nice upgrade path, later on. With a socket M2 slot in it, you'll be able to upgrade to their new processor. And with the PCIe port you'll be able to upgrade to newer graphics cards. That's what sold me on the board, since i bought my new video card a little while ago, i wasnt ready to dish out more for another video card.

If you go for a purely AGP based motherboard, the problem with that is within a year everything will be obscelete. AGP is dying out at the moment, mainly thanks to Intel who went and discontinued putting it in its new boards. I don't believe there are any new AMD AGP motherboards coming out either, and a lot are being discontinued. Socket 939 is approaching its end as well.

In my opinion (mainly since I decided on it as well), the ASRock seems like the most logical choice (AGP and PCIe).

But it's up to you :) ,

...Dan
 
I would seriously think about this before you upgrade. Getting AGP will pretty much lock you out of the new cards, and theres new ones on the way. I bought my motherboard because it had AGP, and I'm glad I did. But that was a while back. If I had to make that decision now, I probably go with a PCIe board.

edit: I'm an idiot. Didn't see that the board has PCIe and AGP... :p
 
Back
Top