vanilla 6800 or x800xl

sp187mf9

n00b
Joined
Jul 1, 2005
Messages
7
I saw the post with the x800xl going really cheap and I was wondering would it be worth it to pick one up. Right now I have a vanilla 6800 and it runs everything pretty well except for bf2. And bf2 is what i play most. I play on all low settings and at 1208 x 1024 and only get about 25fps. Would the x800xl allow me to run bf2 with med settings and at decent framerate at like 40fps.

My specs are:
athlon xp 3200
1gb of ram
 
i have a p4 2.8 oc'd to 3.4 and i average around 40fps at all low 1280 settings on a 64 player map.
 
I have owned both.. the x800xl is MUCH more powerful (in fact, at the time, I upgraded from a 6800vanilla to a x800xl and saw a big improvement in every game I played).

heres the cards on paper.. as you can see, the 6800 doesn't even come close.
http://www.gpureview.com/show_cards.php?card1=52&card2=178

the x800xl doesnt have pixel shader 3.0... but the difference between 3.0 and 2.0 is small AT BEST.
 
I say if you can get the x800xl for a fair price then go for it.
Question .... Have you tried unlocking the extra pipelines and shader on that vanilla 6800? If not you may be able to get a significant performance increase with just a few software tweeks. Doesn't work for all 6800 but it did for mine.

lloose said:
I have owned both.. the x800xl is MUCH more powerful (in fact, at the time, I upgraded from a 6800vanilla to a x800xl and saw a big improvement in every game I played).

heres the cards on paper.. as you can see, the 6800 doesn't even come close.
http://www.gpureview.com/show_cards.php?card1=52&card2=178

the x800xl doesnt have pixel shader 3.0... but the difference between 3.0 and 2.0 is small AT BEST.
Yeah, I bet you did see a big improvement. Look at the technical specs on that page you provided. Comparring a x800xl to a vanilla 6800 isn't really fair now is it?

Monkey_feces said:
x800xl = 6800gt
Closer to a 6800 Ultra is more like it. Take a look at these charts for some benchmark scores : http://www.tomshardware.com/2005/07/05/vga_charts_vii/page4.html#3d_mark_2005
 
Monkey_feces said:
It can go either way, it was about 200 marks above the gt and 200 marks below the ultra.
You are right. Really depends on the test & at what settings.

Using that page that lloose kindly provided, it looks like the x800xl and 6800ultra have nearly identical specs. http://www.gpureview.com/show_cards.php?card1=52&card2=179

Anyway ..... my main point was that the x800xl is on a whole other level than the 6800vanilla. Which is why I said the thread starter should go for it. Hell, I'd trade my OCed and unlocked 6800vanilla for a x800xl. :D
 
If you already have a 6800nu then buying an x800xl may not be worth it unless you can find a buyer for the 6800nu for a decent price to make it an upgrade-trade type deal.
 
If I were in the same situation, I wouldn't take an sm2 card because there is a great difference between bloom and hdr. I notice the light settings are realistic, vibrant, and colorful on HDR. On bloom. everything is a monochromatic bright color when you go outdoors.
 
Monkey_feces said:
If I were in the same situation, I wouldn't take an sm2 card because there is a great difference between bloom and hdr. I notice the light settings are realistic, vibrant, and colorful on HDR. On bloom. everything is a monochromatic bright color when you go outdoors.

Let's try this one- SM3 and SM2 are exactly the same except to do the same lighting effect in SM2 that you do in SM3 it takes a larger performance hit. 6800nu shouldnt be running much HDR anyhow, it's most likely too taxing on the performance.
 
lol, sm 3 is largely waste on a 6800nu. I made the afforementioned post in the contexts that he upgrades to an sm3 card, not stick with his nu. If you can stretch your budget to $170, you can buy a 7600gt (KO I think vs newegg's similar price for a stock version) with a $30 MIR. If you live in california, it's a bonus because monarch doesn't charge shipping. Even better, if you can increase your budget to $270, you can get the revised ram 7900gt with a $20 mir, aoe3, hl2 episode 1, and (not sure if it applies to all retailrs) if you register your product and evga.com, you couldl get hitman blood money. If you don't want the games and don't plan on stepping your card up when dx rolls around, you are better off with the x1800xt from newegg.
 
i have a vanilla 6800 and i play BF2 with high settings and 2AA and 4 AF at 1280x1024 without any problems thanks to 2GB of ram.

By the way my vanilla overclocks to 422/860.

I wouldn't buy the ati cos it doesn't have shader 3.0

if you want a cheap upgrade buy a 7600 GT ;)
 
matadorluis said:
i have a vanilla 6800 and i play BF2 with high settings and 2AA and 4 AF at 1280x1024 without any problems thanks to 2GB of ram.

By the way my vanilla overclocks to 422/860.

I wouldn't buy the ati cos it doesn't have shader 3.0

if you want a cheap upgrade buy a 7600 GT ;)
I know what you mean, I don't have too much trouble playing BF2 with the rig in my sig.

You have that 6800nu unlocked too? Doing so on mine gave me a significant performance boost.
Between unlocking & overclocking, I was able to double my 3dMark2k3 score .... 5,500 to 11,000 :D
 
Adionik said:
How's the upgrade of a 6800 vanilla to an X850XT?

PCI-E versions.
coldpower27 said:
Between those 2 videocards I would give the nod to the X800 XL.
Me too ... that would be a fairly significant upgrade. Compare the specs of those two cards. Not even in the same class really.
http://www.gpureview.com/show_cards.php?card1=55&card2=182

Unfortunately the PCI-E version of the 6800vanilla has no disabled pipelines to unlock so you can not try that route.
 
Well. I know gpureview has the specs that obviously show the x850xt owning the 6800, and the Hard guide sticky shows that the ati card is on par with an Ultra. But for someone wanting to play on 1280 x 1024 with medium AA and AF...I would want to make sure that i'm making a wise investment. (BF2, CS:S, Prey and that's about it)

Figure i'd ask here than branching off and making my own thread. =P
 
back when i had my unlocked 6800 i had a feeling that the 128 of ram was hurting my performance. I have no way of knowing if thats true or not, but at 400&800 16&5 it just seemed like too much power for what textures could be stored in 128mb. is there anyway to tell how much your using? If there would be any truth to this it seems the x800xl would be worth it for the 256 frame buffer.
 
If you use ATI Tray Tools, you can see how much by right clicking on the tray icon, going to Tools & Options, then clicking OnscreenDisplay. You can check Free Video Memory on the FlashOSD tab so you see the memory in a corner of your screen when you're running a 3d app.
 
Back
Top