USB Devices slowing each other down

pwnt

Weaksauce
Joined
Jul 31, 2007
Messages
72
I have USB2.0 ports on my computer through an Adaptec Duo 3020 Firewire/USB2.0 combo card.

I just added an external hard drive and after being infuriated by how slow it is, I discovered the mere presence of other devices slow down every ports.

duoconnecten7.png


The "mass storage device" on far right is the external HDD. I can get ~17MB/s on HDTach with everything else disconnected from the host adapter.

The daisy chained hubs connected to port #1 is really a single 7-port hub, not two separate hubs. Now with this hub and the printer + bridge (memory card reader) attached, the hard drive slows down to 10MB/s, even when there's no activity on port #1.

What's going on here?
 
Its a shared bus, so this might be typical and expected. Wow, 17MB/s? thats still slow. My external drive reads at about 30MB/s. If you want good speed, get eSATA. ;)
 
You have no USB 2.0 ports on the mainboard? What OS are you running? Did you install any drivers for this I/O card?
 
I can understand a shared bus slowing down if multiple devices are operating, but why would a hub with a printer and an unused memory card reader slow down the other port to 10MB/s from 17MB/s ???

I'm running WinXP SP3
 
Its a shared bus, so if it detects other stuff on the bus, it may be reserving some bw for them? I haven't read the USB spec, so its just a guess (and I'm to lazy to read it anyhow, lol).
 
I have read the USB spec (currently writing an USB stack for an Open-Source project :) ), and what is happening here should not happen. Something is interfering, yes, but I'm not sure what. Definitely time to start poking around.

What's the CPU usage during the data transfers, BTW?
 
I have read the USB spec (currently writing an USB stack for an Open-Source project :) ), and what is happening here should not happen. Something is interfering, yes, but I'm not sure what. Definitely time to start poking around.

What's the CPU usage during the data transfers, BTW?

While I have never read the USB spec I was under the impression that USB used polling to determine if a device is ready to transmit data. Thus the controller is going to take its attention away from any one device (Whether transmitting data or not) and place that attention on another device (Whether that device is transmitting data or not.). Am I wrong in this? As that would explain the slow down with more devices attached.

~Aaron
 
Well, depending on the device there could be some traffic, yes. If there is no actual data transfer (isochronous, interrupt or bulk), then that only leaves control transfers, which generally are very small and bursty. Even if the device(s) were to send some data back and forth to the host software, I don't see how it could account for the transfer rate with an USB HDD dropping off like that.

My bet is on the USB expansion card or its driver(s) not functioning correctly.
 
Well, depending on the device there could be some traffic, yes. If there is no actual data transfer (isochronous, interrupt or bulk), then that only leaves control transfers, which generally are very small and bursty. Even if the device(s) were to send some data back and forth to the host software, I don't see how it could account for the transfer rate with an USB HDD dropping off like that.

My bet is on the USB expansion card or its driver(s) not functioning correctly.

Well, I took out the Adaptec DuoConnect and installed a Belkin USB2.0 card,which also uses the same NEC chipset and now the transfer rate is ~22MB/s

I have no clue why though.
 
Well, I took out the Adaptec DuoConnect and installed a Belkin USB2.0 card,which also uses the same NEC chipset and now the transfer rate is ~22MB/s

I have no clue why though.

Yeah, it's odd indeed. Perhaps the Adaptec card was defective?
 
Back
Top