USB card reader problem, SO FRUSTRATING, plz someone help

eetoi

Weaksauce
Joined
Oct 5, 2005
Messages
74
Okay, I love using SD cards, mainly because of my pda and camera. After switching from a Via mobo with a Sempron 2300+ to an intel board with a (used) P4 2.8 HT Northwood quite a while ago, my card reader started distorting any kind of data uploaded from/downloaded to the cards I'm using. I've tried different cards, different card readers (they worked fine with another computer, an emachines), different OS's (two versions of windows, and Linux, the Knoppix distro), different RAM (switched from Rosewill to Kingston), different video cards, and now, a new mobo (with same southbridge chip but different nb chip). The last thing I can think of is the proc, and the computer does everything else fine, really, no glitches in gaming, video/audio encoding/playback, etc. I'm just boggled, I've been trying to figure this out for a year now, and haven't thought of posting here for advice. I recently bought a celeron oem off of newegg with which to build another extra pc with the old mobo, to see if it was indeed the cpu.

Any ideas?
 
Check that your machine is not overclocked in any way.

run prime95 looping on your machine for 24 hours if your proc has a problem that should show it up.

How does your card reader connect to your PC.
 
how other USB devices work..? I don't know if it's southbridge responsible for controlling USB.. but make sure you have all mobo drivers installed..
 
I feel soooooooooooooo stupid right now. Either that or something weird happened. I swear, I tested both card readers and they yielded the same distorted data. Perhaps the bad one corrupted the card and so the other one read fine, but it was reading corrupted data. Explanation below.

jnex26, I got the cpu secondhand from my cousin (I'm going to be more cautious when getting stuff from him), and he reported that he o'ced it from 2.8 to 3.6 without a hitch, and stock cooling. That must have been at least a year and a half ago, and since then I've been running it stable at stock speeds, and it's no wonder, it's not the problem.

TheMostWantedPolishTwin, I installed all mobo drivers from the site. USB mouse, keyboard, pda cradle, mp3 player, and pretty much anything works fine.

OK, here's how I found out (if you don't feel like reading a lot, it turned out it WAS the card reader :eek: ). From the replaced mobo, a cheap secondhand hdd and psu, a $35 celeron D from Newegg, an old CDRW and gfx card, I put together a second pc in a cardboard box (I was planning to do this anyway). After installing Windows, I plugged in the external card reader, and to my disbelief, it read my pictures fine. That's when I began to think it was the cpu, which still didn't make sense because it did everything else fine. I plugged the external card reader back into my original pc (which had the faulty internal one in it already), and to my further shock (and anger), it read fine. I could have sworn I saw it read distorted pics before, while reading fine on the other emachines.

Well, at least I learned a lesson.
 
Back
Top