USB-3 Issue With Laptop: Speed

Tony Rotten

Weaksauce
Joined
Apr 23, 2008
Messages
98
I just bought an HP laptop with AMD 4-core processor (price was a consideration) and 650 GB hard drive and I was so 'excited' that with two USB-3 ports (in addition to two USB-2 ones) I would finally be able to perform my backups much faster than now.

Well, I used my trusted utility HDTune to check out a 2.5" Seagate Momentus 500 GB, 7200 RPM in a screw less Icy Dock USB-3 enclosure and and it turns out that I am getting what amounts to a USB-2 speed, 32 MB/sec. With the two USB-2 ports it's half of that!

A similar drive that I have connected to my tower PC via an expansion card with FireWire-800, a 1TB Scorpio Blue (also 2.5" but 5400 RPM) measures over 56 MB/sec.

USB-3 is supposed to be faster than FireWire-800 so am I the victim of false advertising or what? I need to know so that I can return the laptop promptly.

I may try another 'real' USB-3 external drive, but I wanted to know if this is a systemic, across the board issue that others may have noticed?

Thanks.
 
What specific model HP did you purchase? Was it a Staples/Bestbuy model?
 
Unfortunately, some of the HP mass market stuff (Best Buy, Target, Staples etc) has some serious deficiencies. Such as putting all their USB2, USB3, WIFI and ethernet ports (plus sd card reader and sometimes even more) combined on what is essentially a x1 pcie link. What specific model is it? Have you updated all the drivers to the latest versions? Is the drive you have a momentus .1, .2 .3 etc? Have you updated the icy dock firmware?
 
Thanks mwroobel & drescherjm:

Yes I have uptadet everything in the laptop. I have been a professional programmer for 37 years (before the Internet) and I know how to measure simple hard disk drive speeds,

I may have been had by HP for the first time....
 
Again, what is the model # of this particular laptop and I can do some more digging.
 
Yeah, that is one of the models they loaded up to lanes on so they didn't need another phy chip. A few things you can do to increase performance. In Device Manager > Disk Drives > Policies for the drive in question, make sure that optimize for performance is checked, and not optimize for quick removal. Next, at the bottom of the info pages on the icy dick site include "There is a newer firmware available. The new firmware improves the overall product performance. Please e-mail us at tech@icydock.com for firmware update request." That may also be the source of some of your problems.
 
Well, I would put the drive in the machine hooked up to a SATA port, get a crystaldiskmark of that, and then compare it to the USB3
 
Thanks for all your help, mwroobel .

I appreciate it. I am almost convinced that HP is skimming in its USB ports.

What I didn't mentioned before is that I have a low-cost HP/AMD mid tower that behaves exactly like that with its USB-2 ports. Very low speed with all of them.

I think this should come out now especially with the claims by HP, and the expectations of consumers, about the real USB-3 support that they are giving, or more precisely that they are NOT giving.
 
Unfortunately, and this has happened from many vendors over the years..... Just because something is advertised as a connection doesn't mean that the device has either the horsepower nor the throughput to utilize said connection to its fullest. That is why reviews have benchmarks, so you can match apples to apples device to device.
 
Well, I would put the drive in the machine hooked up to a SATA port, get a crystaldiskmark of that, and then compare it to the USB3

Yep.

Here's an quick overview of some of my limited USB 3.0 testing. I have a toshiba portege z835-p56x with a USB 3.0 and an eSatap port. I've tested three different USB 3.0 enclosures with the USB 3.0 port on the toshiba and they all top out at just over 100MB/s (HDTune read test), and that was with a WD Black 750GB 2.5", an Intel 320 120GB SSD, or a Crucial C300 64GB SSD. I've also tested those same drives against the eSatap port and their max transfer rate is better and is close to what is advertised but I can't recall the specifics off the top of my head. IIRC, the WD black HD is a little better than the USSB 3.0 (but not by much). The Intel 320 SSD a fair amount better and the C300 is better but obviously limited by the Sata II bandwidth.

I've test just the Intel 320 120GB SSD against against my Asrock z77Pro4-m back panel USB 3.0 ports via a hub (so not even directly connected), and it gets much better results. I want to say the HDTune read test puts it at around 180 MB/s which is even better than this drive does with a Sata II port. I am unable to verify if these backpanel ports are the Intel ports or not and I've been unable to find the specifics for this motherboard on which ports are the Intel ports. I've not hooked up the motherboard USB 3.0 headers to test yet.

So in my limited experience, USB 3.0 ports are far from equal.
 
Unfortunately, and this has happened from many vendors over the years..... Just because something is advertised as a connection doesn't mean that the device has either the horsepower nor the throughput to utilize said connection to its fullest. That is why reviews have benchmarks, so you can match apples to apples device to device.

Fully agreed. In my opinion this happens far too often.
 
Last edited:
UPDATE. I need to be fair to HP:

After some thought, I went and bought a "bona fide" USB-3 WDC external drive (0.5TB) and voila! The number went all the way up to 74 MB/s! Which means that the ports are real USB-3 and also that the Icy Dock enclosure is, well, "bad". :mad:
 
Back
Top