UPS and marine battery

Red Squirrel

[H]F Junkie
Joined
Nov 29, 2009
Messages
9,223
I have heard of this done before, basically replacing a UPS battery with a marine battery, as they are cheaper, and will actually run much longer.

I am just wondering if anyone has first hand experience, and if you happen to have done it with this ups:

http://fixya.net/Products/U/Ultra/118x100/ups_system_324884.jpg
(Ultra 1000VA UPS)

I own the 1000VA version of that UPS and my battery is completely dead. I'm thinking of buying a deep cycle marine battery and hooking it up. Also, since those batteries produce hydrogen, do I need to do anything special as far as venting, or is the amount rather small to be insignificant in a large enough room? Or if I get a sealed battery then it should not produce any right?


Thinking of one of these batteries:

http://www.canadiantire.ca/AST/brow...utilus%2BDeep%2BCycle%2BBattery.jsp?locale=en

http://www.canadiantire.ca/AST/brow...ELL~0793926 Replacement+Battery.jsp?locale=en
More expensive, but probably more robust.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Yes, works fine. I have (4) 12v Deep cycle batteries on my APC3000. You can get sealed deep cycle batteries at Wally World but in a room or basement the H2 is not a worry.

My ACP is the mid 90s vintage and I had to write a few variables in the APC firmware to get the runtime correct with the larger capacity batteries, but YMMV. I went from (4) 18Amp/hr to (4) 120Amp/hr.
 
Is it safe to assume that most modern UPSes will know when to stop charging? SO they'll charge enough, but not too much? Or are they preprogrammed for a specific battery, or does it vary?
 
No a lot of UPSs will not handle much higher than spec batteries.

No, a battery charger is a battery charger as long as you stay within the correct battery type.

Use a trickle charger for example, it will eventually charge a 1000CCA battery if you give it enough time.

I installed (4) two series pairs at a customer site on a little APC 1000 (24V), worked great.
 
Is it safe to assume that most modern UPSes will know when to stop charging? SO they'll charge enough, but not too much? Or are they preprogrammed for a specific battery, or does it vary?

It is fine, assuming you stay in the same type like I said above. Sealed and wet lead acid are close enough, it will not overcharge.
 
Cool this is good to know. So if the amp hour is higher I'm ok, as long as it's same type (ex: lead acid).

Think I will go ahead and buy a battery next time I go to Canadian Tire.
 
Cool this is good to know. So if the amp hour is higher I'm ok, as long as it's same type (ex: lead acid).

Think I will go ahead and buy a battery next time I go to Canadian Tire.

Are you sure your UPS is a single 12v battery? Usually units around the 1000 mark are two 12v in series?

Also, I'm not familiar with that unit, but it might not be possible to tweak the battery constant like on the APCs. As an example, this could lead to a runtime indication of say 30 minutes that actually last 5 hours! Doesn't hurt anything just could be misleading.
 
I''m assuming 12v but I will find out when I take it appart. If it's two 12v I can just use two 12v marine ones right? At that point I'm probably nearing the price of replacement though, but at least I will get more time out of it.

And I doubt I can modify this particular UPS, so now that I think of it, could it end up shutting itself down too early?
 
Modification is usually just a hole big enough for the two battery cables, appropriately sized.

When on battery mine will drop to about 70% pretty quick, staying there for hours, then slowing dropping. As long as you can set the shutdown threshold (say 10% to shutdown) you can find the sweet spot.
 
I have an APC at my parents' house that I left there when I moved out, it has a dead battery, so think I will use that unit to replace mine and go ahead with the marine batterie(s). This should be interesting. Upon further reading it looks like some people even get a day out of this. For now I will go with something cheap as far as batteries go, but later on I can always invest in "solar power grade" batteries which are sealed lead acid and probably will last much longer. I'm hoping that UPS indeed needs 24v as that will cut down on the wire size needed. I'm hoping to be able to get away with 10awg romex. 600w at 24v comes up to 25 amps which is the max load I should see, so 10awg will do for that. If it's 12v then I probably need to use 6awg or so.
 
Sounds like your off to a great start! A fairly simple project that is quite rewarding, be sure and post back if you have any questions.
 
Yep for sure. Another reason for using the APC is I think it will have better support under linux. Hopefully I can get more stats out of it too. I believe Linux has a package for that. apcd or something like that.
 
I'll probably go out and buy the batteries tomorrow and pickup the APC unit from my parents' place. The power has been going out a lot latetly for like 3 seconds, which is not enough for the server equipment to fully shut down, but enough to make it reboot. I also have 2 failing drives in my raid 5 and these forced power offs are probably not helping... can't wait for replacement drives to come in so I can at least stop worrying about my raid crashing.

Also, is there any risk of fire doing something like this? That's the only part I'm kinda scared of. Can the UPS itself also have overheat problems? just because it has more AH it should not really be stressed more right? It's still drawing the same amount of current, it's just doing it for longer.
 
Also, is there any risk of fire doing something like this? That's the only part I'm kinda scared of. Can the UPS itself also have overheat problems? just because it has more AH it should not really be stressed more right? It's still drawing the same amount of current, it's just doing it for longer.

There is always a risk if not done properly. Keep the battery fuse, ensure the external wiring will not ground out on the case, use large enough wire to handle the current, proper terminations etc. For the most part common sense items.

UPS will not overheat, it will charge at the same rate as before, just take longer to recharge due to the larger capacity batteries.

Also make sure that the battery terminals are covered, just in case you drop something metal across them!
 
Seems simple enough, and common sense. What about stuff like float voltage, hydrogen, having to add water to it etc? I'm mostly concerned about the hydrogen, is it a big enough amount to be a problem in a basement? Should I enclose them in some fireproof case of some sort, and vent outside?

I've also read that UPSes are designed to run for only 5-10 minutes so if I make it run longer it will overheat, is this true? I'd hope the APC units are better quality then that. I'm probably going to add a fan to be safe.
 
I've also read that UPSes are designed to run for only 5-10 minutes so if I make it run longer it will overheat, is this true? I'd hope the APC units are better quality then that. I'm probably going to add a fan to be safe.

UPS's can run longer than 5-10 minutes. It all depends on the battery's capacity. I have 2 APC units that run for at least 25 min before the battery dies. Always keep in mind that battery time is so that you can save your data and properly shutdown for PC if the power does not return.
 
Flooded wet cell and sealed have a very similar float voltage, no problems there. No H2 concerns unless you seal the batteries in an un-vented box, just leave them open in the basement and your fine. Even if you instantly separated all the water in that battery into O2/H2 you'd have to have it contained in a closet or something similar to concentrate it enough to be worried.

I have one arrangement that uses Trogen T105 flooded wet cells, I have to add distilled water about once every 4-6 months.

My APC3000 has a fan that starts when on battery, the others do not, but in all cases the loading is less than 30% of the rated wattage. Probably not an issue unless your pushing it pretty hard.
 
Hm that's a good point the battery can only hold a limited amount of hydrogen, physically. I've played with electrolosys before and you have to process a decent amount of water before you get even a pop.

Guess I'm just being paranoid. Lot of people I talk to about this think I'm crazy and going to burn my house down.
 
Back
Top