Upgrading my storage setup need help with 1TB drives.

TheBlueChanell

Supreme [H]ardness
2FA
Joined
Apr 15, 2005
Messages
4,658
I am upgrading my old 150gb Raptor/500gb Barracuda setup and I was thinking about doing the following.

150gb Velociraptor or 74gb Velociraptor Raid and a 1TB Storage drive.

I sold my raptor and my storage drive locally to a buddy in town.

I was wondering what is a good 1TB drive, I had my heart set on the Caviar Black because I've never had an issue with WD and I have been extremely happy with my first raptor. However, I read that the Caviar Blacks are extremely loud and not as fast as some of the other 1TB drives.

I would appreciate some insight, I was looking at the Spinpoint F1 but for $30 I can get a Caviar Black. I'm at a loss, so any help would be great. :D
 
There's not a huge performance difference when it comes to the 1TB drives. They all do pretty well in sustained transfers due to their density. The one outlier is the WD GreenPower drive, which is tuned for lower performance, less noise and less power consumption.
The big question is what are you doing with the drive? If it's just bulk storage of media, then don't worry about performance that much, and go with a GP drive, particularly if you're concerned with noise.
 
I went with the WD GP drives in my new Thecus N5200 NAS box I just put online. Storage is not performance driven like your OS drive might be. I couldn't pass on the power savings, since I will have 5 of them running in my NAS eventually.

If you are going to be doing I/O intensive applications, then go with the more conventional drives. The other moderately big drive I have is a 7200.11. I went with it at the time because I use it for the OS drive in my main rig.

Don
 
If you're looking to use the drive mainly for storage, then you probably don't need the speed of the Caviar Black. Look into the Caviar Green which changes speeds from 5400rpm to 7200rpm. Also keep in mind that the Black uses more power and runs louder/hotter than the other drives.

If you don't mind the heat issue, you can get a 1TB Hitachi with 32mb cache for around $95 (after rebate). However, the Hitachi drive is a bit older than the rest and has more platters so it does run hotter.

Basically, it depends on how cool and fast you want the drive to be.
 
If you're looking to use the drive mainly for storage, then you probably don't need the speed of the Caviar Black. Look into the Caviar Green which changes speeds from 5400rpm to 7200rpm. Also keep in mind that the Black uses more power and runs louder/hotter than the other drives.
If you mean the "Green Power" series of drives, they're not variable RPM, they're either 5400RPM drives or somewhere between 5400RPM and 7200RPM fixed rotational speed. It's mostly marketing to sell 5400 RPM drives, but it works out pretty well in the end with reduced power consumption, heat, and noise. For storage, the GPs are very good drives to consider.

If you don't mind the heat issue, you can get a 1TB Hitachi with 32mb cache for around $95 (after rebate). However, the Hitachi drive is a bit older than the rest and has more platters so it does run hotter.
I've seen Samsung EcoGreen 1TB drives (5400 RPM marketing FTW! :)) for around $100-110 ocassionally, I wouldn't really want to deal with the Hitachi 1TB drives, at least the older ones, since it has five platters. The EcoGreens probably have four platters, maybe even three (with the density of the Spinpoint F1 drives of 334GB per platter).


Overall, if you're going to use the TB drive as a boot drive (I strongly recommending partitioning it), I would go with the upper echelon of drives (Spinpoint F1, Caviar Black, 7200.11), but if it's for storage, go with whatever satisfies your needs the best and has the best price and warranty.
 
Back
Top