Upgrading from an i5 to i7?

Arclouse~

n00b
Joined
Jun 30, 2013
Messages
12
Hihi!

I've been thinking about upgrading my i5 3570k to an i7.
Would I be better off sticking with socket 1155 and going to a 3770k or should I upgrade to an 1150 and get a 4770k? Would the difference be worth the price?
 
What do you use your computer for?

If this is for gaming, you probably won't notice the difference from an i5.
 
Oh well I do game but I'll be doing a lot more heavy video editing in the near future.
 
In the interest of saving money I guess you should try rendering first to see if your i5 produces acceptable render times.

If not - I guess that is when you decide on moving to an i7. In this case, a used 3770/K would be good. You probably won't see much additional benefit of moving to a 4770K aside from the extra motherboard features.

If you do heavy heavy heavy rendering, maybe you'll consider an X79 system?
 
For editing, a faster harddrive would help while editing. The faster processor will help when encoding.

Nothing is more annoying when scanning through a video then stutters and hesitations while the drive(s) catches up. This is more apparent with 1080p and greater.

For encoding, you can pretty much walk away and come back later.

So you'll just have to ask yourself if the time saved is worth while to you. But more cores or megahertz is always better.

Remember that Hyper Threading does little help with thread 2 when the Core is already at near 100% utilization from the thread 1.

The purpose of Hyper Threading is to allow thread 2 to use the remaining idle time of a core when thread 1 is not fully utilizing the core. So when thread 1 is using 100%, thread 2 can certainly go into the queue, but it will still have to wait for thread 1 to finish. Hyper Threading is great for "light multi-tasking".
 
I went from a 2500k to a 3770k.

I find everything runs better/smoother with HT off on the 3770k so I feel it is not worth it.

When I say better/smoother I mean in general windows operations/browser/games/calc math application for college.

Your mileage varies and my experience may not be the same as yours.
 
If your going to be doing heavy video editing in the future, then why not wait until that future to upgrade when even better parts are available on the market? I use an i5 for heavy video editing and it's great for that by the way.
 
If your going to be doing heavy video editing in the future, then why not wait until that future to upgrade when even better parts are available on the market? I use an i5 for heavy video editing and it's great for that by the way.

You could use this argument year after year though ;)
 
I did exactly that I built a new machine Feb 1st with it 3570k overclocked it immediately to 4.4 and ran that for a month & half till I got the bug to get the i7 3770k I wanted to begin with. I sold the i5 to a friend and bought the i7. It's running 24/7 @ 4.2 but it will run 4.5 very solid. I'm really happy I made the change. I think it was worth it do tons of video encoding & it saves me tons of time.
 
i went from a 2500k @4.5ghz to a Xeon E3-1230V2 (basically a 3770 without the built in gpu) and i saw some difference in basic video editing but i didnt see much of a difference in gaming. Maybe 2-3 fps.
 
Deffinitively doesn't worth it. If you need to speed up your media rendering, you may want to use applications that uses CUDA, AMD APP or Quicsync to accelerate the process, but like other posters said. Hyper Threading does marvelous stuff in lightly threaded application, in heavy multithreaded application, the threads struggles for resources, that is why in those scenarios, you can see the AMD FX modular approach getting away with it.
 
if you are going to use cpu rendering then yes its worth it for video editing although cuda was pretty fast for video rendering if you had a fermi card like the 500 series.
 
You could use this argument year after year though ;)

As you should. Buying for the present situation makes more sense then planning for a hypothetical future.

The most expensive CPU i've ever bought in my life was an Athlon 64 3000+. At the time when I bought it I didn't need any extra cpu speed whatsoever but I got it anyway in order to future proof my computer for future 64-bit software. You know what happened? By the time I needed a 64-bit ready CPU I had already upgraded my CPU two more times by then. If upgrading is entertaining for you then go for it for that reason but there is always something better and faster around the corner so you might as well wait till you need it to get it because if you don't then your hardware will already be obsolete by the time you need it. I do video editing and you don't need a particularly fast CPU at all. A fast SSD/hard drive and enough RAM is WAY more important than more cpu power.
 
I'd rather not wait until my system performance was noticeably lacking before upgrading you'd miss so many years of increased performance as you lived with degrading performance because you got something that just "got by" at the time...

I like to get the best performance for the buck at the time and upgrade when the mood hits :D
If he's going to do video editing in the near future then I wouldn't consider replacing my system in 3-10 weeks acceptable either. I'd plan for that future as it's near. (OPs words not mine)

Speaking of CPUs I paid about the same for my 3930k as I did my 200mhz MMX which had remained the most expensive CPU I'd ever purchased until the 3930k.
 
If performance if lacking then sure it's time for an upgrade, didn't have a reason to think that was the situation. I was just talking about not upgrading for the silly reason of needing it for video editing in the future as videoediting isn't particularly dependent on CPU speed. Plus we are talking about the move from Ivy to Haswell which is a very small bump forward and wouldn't be particularly noticeable outside benchmarks.
 
Back
Top