Upgrading and need advice for smart buys.

Endymion

n00b
Joined
Dec 16, 2002
Messages
26
I am thinking that it might be time to upgrade my computer.

I don't have a huge amount of money, so I want to make sure I can stretch it as far as possible. Since this is an upgrade, I only need to focus on processor, motherboard, ram, video card and the power supply. I don't plan on overclocking, I just want something that is stable and simple. I do play some games.

Processor: I am not sure whether I should go with a dual core, or go with something that costs a lot less. I usually buy something less expensive and then tell myself that I can upgrade just the processor later on, but that never really happens. Basically, this seems to me where I could possibly save a lot of money, unless looking ahead it makes more sense to get something that is more powerful. If I am not overclocking, will the stock heatsink/fan be ok? On my AthlonXP 2000+ the fan failed within the first month.

Motherboard: I am leaning towards the Asus A8N-SLI. I've really liked my Asus A7N8X Deluxe. However, would the basic Asus board be enough? I also don't plan on using two video cards at once. I figure I can add in a second one later as an upgrade. Is that a good plan?

RAM: I am thinking of going with 2 sticks of the Corsair XMS PC3200 512 MB that is on Newegg for $100.

Video Card: I just bought an Evga agp video card thinking that it would hold me over for awhile to give me more time before I upgraded, but now I am not so sure. Evga has a Step Up program that I think I can use to trade in the agp card for a pci-e card. So which one would I want to go with for price/performance given that I only have to pay the difference between the cards? (It also depends on availability of the cards available for the Step Up program.) Oh, and I would prefer a 256mb card.

Power Supply: I'm looking at the Enermax Liberty 500w. Actually, I need to get a new power supply right now as the current one is on it's way out, would this power supply work with my current setup until I can get around to upgrading?

I'm looking for any suggestions to try to keep the costs down, but still having a nice machine that will last, so if I am way off on any of this stuff, let me know. Thanks.
 
The Enermax Liberty 500w should work justfine with your XP2200. The main motherboard power plug from the enermax has a 24pin plug that has a 4pin removable segment. You can disconnect this 4pin part to make the 20pin plug that you Athlon XP probably uses.

This pic on newegg makes it pretty easy to see.

It would be a good Idea to state exacly how much you're looking to spend, otherwise you'll probably get a dozen bone-heads suggesting you spend way more than you need to.
 
I really would rather not spend more than $500, but I am not sure if that's realistic or not since I added up what I was thinking about and got to between $600 and $700.

The only thing I am really sure of is that I need to get a new power supply right away and I figured if I do end up actually upgrading soon, I would want the one I get now to work with the new stuff.
 
Here's my initial thoughts:

If your not overclocking I'd skip the XMS ram. At stock speeds there is almost no difference in performance. I've had a only good experiences using Corsair's Value-Select ram. Every computer I've put it in has been rock solid.
CORSAIR ValueSelect 1GB (2 x 512MB)

The ASUS motherboard is one of the best
ASUS A8N-SLI ATX

I'm not exactly a fan of the buy one video card now and get a matching one later. There still seems to be some sporatic compatability issues if you don't get identical cards. Also, by the time you're ready to add a second card, you may be able to get a new card that supports the newest technologies and would be as powerful as a SLI set-up for the same price (that's speculation on my part). One option you do have would be to save a couple bucks buy getting the ASUS A8N-E Motherboard and then spend the money you save on a better video card. Your choice. The price difference isn't huge, but when your on a budget anything helps.

The Enermax Liberty power supply looks good to me, but it's a little spendy for your budget.
I've really liked the enermax power supplies that I've used / installed. Although it doesn't have the cool cable system of the liberty, this one will probably work just fine, and you can then put a little more cash into you video card / processor (where you'll really see the difference.)
ENERMAX EG425P-VE 420W Power Supply

I'll post later about the video card and processor...
 
On to the Video Card and Processor...

Given your budget, a dual core CPU isn't really an option. I'd reccomend the AMD Athlon 64 3200+ Venice Processor. It will do a good job with anything you throw at it. Not the fastest, but a VERY good upgrade from your Athlon XP 2000. I currently game with an Athlon 64 2800+ it works quite nicely for me.

A good video card if you want bang-for-you-buck would be the eVGA Geforce 6800XT PCIe x16 256MB. Newegg has a $20 MIR that that brings the price down to $139+$5s/h. That price may be better than what you'd get with a trade in program. This video card will play any game out there with some pretty good settings.
 
Thanks for the advice. :)

I imagine that you're probably right about the SLI. It would probably be overkill for me anyways.

As for the dual core, I was thinking that would be more power than I need now, but be better as the computer aged. it might be more expensive, but might be worth it. It also might be in my budget if I can trade in my current agp card... the trade in program bases the value on how much I paid for my card and the card you mentioned, I believe is actually valued less in the program than what I paid. But there might be a problem of availability when doing it that way.

So say I can get the pci-e vid card for just shipping, would getting a dual core make sense?

I also already ordered the power supply. I don't need to have that included in my budget with the way my finances will be and I needed to get that right away anyways.
 
For gaming, the 3200+ and the X2 3800+ will perform about the same. This is because almost none of the games out there really take advantage of the second core, so it sits there doing very little while the first core is maxed out playing your game.

Here's where the X2 processor would help you the most:
*Heavy Multi-tasking
*Video Editing / Rendering
*Picture Rendering - i.e. Ray-Trace
*Professional Audio Recording / Editing

The only other thing I'd reccommend would be that you consider getting 2 GB of ram. This is a bit of an luxury, but some games like: Battlefield 2, Quake, and FEAR run smoother on 2GB. It would also help with any of the items listed for ideal X2 tasks. I currently only have 1GB in my gaming box, and I'm happy with it, but there are advantages to going to 2GB.
 
With your budget, you should get one of the Biostar Tforce 6100 combos with a Sempron, 2 gb of ram and trade up your video card to something better. The sempron will still perform leaps and bounds ahead of your xp 2000+ cause of the integrated memory controller. Then when you have enough money for a real upgrade, you can get a better mb/cpu combo. Considering the tforce 6100 has onboard video, you can save it as a backup/linux box when you upgrade or maybe give it to someone in your family who needs something newer. I mean, really... the combo is only ~$150.
 
nigerian_businessman said:
With your budget, you should get one of the Biostar Tforce 6100 combos with a Sempron, 2 gb of ram and trade up your video card to something better. The sempron will still perform leaps and bounds ahead of your xp 2000+ cause of the integrated memory controller. Then when you have enough money for a real upgrade, you can get a better mb/cpu combo. Considering the tforce 6100 has onboard video, you can save it as a backup/linux box when you upgrade or maybe give it to someone in your family who needs something newer. I mean, really... the combo is only ~$150.

It's a little unclear in my mind why an Athlon 64 X2 3800+ and ASUS mother board is not a "...real upgrade..."

It doesn't make sense to up-grade to something that you're already planning on replacing before you even buy it.
 
The computer I have now has lasted about 3 years and the one before it lasted about 3 years as well. Given my financial situation, that's about as often as I can spend this kind of money on upgrading (And this is taking into consideration the new power supply I had to buy and the fact that I just bought a new video card within the last couple of months), at least for the foreseeable future. So whatever I get now, has to last because I know I won't be able to just upgrade whenever I want.

Again, that's why I am thinking that I may not need a dual core processor right now, but later on as the computer ages and new hardware and new software come out, I would be less behind the curve, meaning it would last longer.

I have no problem buying a new video card or possibly more ram later on because I figure there's more of a performance boost doing it that way for the amount of money I would be spending. You can correct me if I am way off on that. ;)

I should also mention, my current computer runs most of the things I do pretty decently still and I actually had wanted to wait another year before upgrading. However, it seems my second computer crapped out at the same time as the power supply, so go ahead with the upgrade now and move the parts from current computer into the second computer. This works out well because the second computer really didn't run everything I needed it to anyways.

Ok, that was more long winded than I had planned on, I just thought that I should explain my thinking to make sure you understand my thought process behind all of this.

Thanks for the help pj. You've given me some things to really think about before I go ahead with this. :)
 
Here's some more thoughts:

Just so you know, socket 939 is about be be replaced by socket AM2. Socket AM2 is expected to come out in 2-3 months, and is not backkwords compatable with S939. The biggest difference between the two will be that AM2 will use DDR2 while S939 uses DDR.

It is my opinion that moving to DDR2 will only have a very small performace increase for low to mid range processors. High end processors may have a little greater increase in performance, but only in applications that are very memory intensive. Even though DDR has been around for a while, it still delivers a very good amount bandwidth in dual channel mode.

AMD says that it will continue to produce S939 processors as long as there is a reasonable demand from consumers. Although this is only a guess, I would expect that S939 processors to be available for at least 2 more years.

This background is all to address one question: Is it a good idea to upgrade to S939 when AM2 is so close? My answere to that is yes, but only if you really need an upgrade. S939 is a very mature platform that still offers tons of performance. DDR is also very mature and will be arround for a long time. If you buy a S939 Athlon 64 3200+ now, you will have at least 2 years, but probably more to upgrade.

I think that waiting on upgrading to dual core processors is not a bad idea because only a few programs are currently designed to take advantage of multiple processors (although having dual cores definitly helps when running multiple programs at once). In 2-3 years most software will probably be designed to take advantage of multiple cores. It would not surprise me if in a couple of years we see software that requires multiple core processors to run, as a minimum specification. As I see it, this applies to you because if you get a single core processor now, when you are ready for your next upgrade, getting a dual core processor later will make more sense for you then it would be to spend the money for one now. Eventually almost everything will go to at least dual cores.

In summery, although socket AM2 is approaching, S939 still offers a solid processor and excellent performance. S939 processors will be available for some time, allowing for upgrading sometime in the future. The world is moving to dual cores, but single core processors still offer an excellent performance per dollar ratio and make a lot of sense for the computer buyer on a budget.

I recommend Athlon 64 over Sempron, but I'll get into exactly why in another post.
 
Endymion said:
...and then tell myself that I can upgrade just the processor later on, but that never really happens.

Don't forget about this, and the fact that the parts I am buying now, will eventually go to my second computer. ;) Basically, the chances of me upgrading the processor without doing a major upgrade is pretty slim.

I'm also still working on what my budget will actually be. I should find out Monday or Tuesday what I am working with for sure and at the same time will make the decision to go ahead or to wait awhile... not that I would be waiting for AM2, more like just trying to put off upgrading for as long as possible. (I probably will since like I said, my current second computer doesn't really run what I've been wanting it to and it's currently dead anyways.)
 
pj-schmidt said:
It's a little unclear in my mind why an Athlon 64 X2 3800+ and ASUS mother board is not a "...real upgrade..."

It doesn't make sense to up-grade to something that you're already planning on replacing before you even buy it.

It is a real upgrade, but at the cost of a better video card.
 
Back
Top