Upgraded videocard – now hard drive corruption?

GotNoRice

[H]F Junkie
2FA
Joined
Jul 11, 2001
Messages
12,843
I put this in the general hardware section because to be honest I have no idea which component is causing my problem in this case.


My brother’s computer is an AthlonXP 1700+ with 512mb PC133, KT133A Via Chipset motherboard, 80Gb IBM Deskstar.

It had a Radeon 9600Pro in it, but I recently came across an x1550 AGP and decided give it to him in place of his 9600.

The computer was working normally. I ran the ATI Software uninstall utility, I turned it off, opened it up. The first thing I noticed was a crazy amount of dust in there, I guess because it’s on the carpet and no one else ever blows the dust out, so it has collected for years. I used compressed air and blew it all out, including the powersupply, the heatsink, etc. Then I put the new videocard in and started it up. It booted fine, but in VGA mode (no drivers). I installed catalyst 7.8 and rebooted. This is when my issues began.

When windows started up it seemed to start normally, at the proper resolution, but very few of the icons on the desktop were being displayed. None of the start menu items were being displayed either. Windows would overlap in ways that they normally don’t do, the titles of the windows would look like multiple lines of text overlapping. I suspected file corruption, scheduled a chkdsk c: /r, rebooted and went to lunch.

When I came back the computer was at the desktop but at 640x480, 4-bit color. If I tried to bring it up it would just say it changed the settings but actually kept it at 640x480/4bit. I checked the event log and there were a bunch of Disk errors.

At that point I suspected the drive is on its way out, but it seemed like a pretty big coincidence that the computer worked fine for years but just starts having problems at the exact time I dust it out and install a new videocard? I’m thinking there is a possibility that dust got in somewhere or maybe because the x1550 requires an external molex while the 9600 did not that it put the powersupply over the edge (it’s just an old pos 300watt). I shut it down and re-seated all the cables and power plugs and dusted again just to be sure.

When I turned it back on it wouldn’t recognize the disk at all, it would just hang where it normally quickly detects it in the loading bios screen. I re-seated the cables again and it booted but every time it successfully boots it does an automatic chkdsk, saying “your disk needs to be checked for consistency”, and even after that, never boots windows but hangs at a black screen.

I know the deskstar drives have a bad reputation, but I seem to remember researching it and reading that this drive was not one of the ones that had the common problem.

What do you guys think? Obvious signs of a failing drive or too much of a coincidence? Would an x1550 stress a powersupply more than a 9600pro?
 
Could have easily been something on it's way out, and that just pushed it over the edge. However, chkdsk constantly running is fairly typical of an HD failure. I see hard drives fail all the time for no apparent reason, regardless of brand/model. Do you have any diags you can run?

And have you tried putting the original video card back in the system?
 
The deskstar failures is very noticable. You would hear it clicking when working.

Since you upgraded video cards on an older PC, I'm thinking older power supply too. Maybe you don't have enough wattage to go around. Try another PSU and see if the drives act up again. Try for maybe 550w at least to stay flexible.
 
Back
Top