Upgrade vid or mobo or rig?

Joined
Apr 25, 2006
Messages
3
Well,games are lagging :(
I'd like to hold off upgrading the whole rig-is there an agp card that will give me a decent performance boost without costing me so much I'd be better doing a mobo upgrade?How good are the pci-e cards?can i economically upgrade the mobo,keep the oc on my mobile,and improve my vid? Im running an ati 9800 pro flashed to xt-128 meg ram on a abit nf7-s v2 with a 2500m barton@2300mHZ
 
Well, if you're looking for an inexpensive route to upgrade, check out the FS/FT forums for a 6800 GT, I've seen a couple going for about $125 shipped. That'll give you a good boost over a 9800Pro (still have one myself until I get this 6800NU RMA'd).

If you go PCI-e, you'll be making a larger purchase as you'll need a mobo, cpu, and of course, a new video card.

If you want PCI-e, I'd go with an A64 3500+, NF4 chipset mobo, and a 7600GT. Should be decent for not a huge sum of cash.

Just click the Newegg banner up top if you want new parts.
 
The 7800GS is AGP, but it costs nearly $300 dollars last time I checked.

6800GT is a much better buy for your specific system.

Just ignore the 15 year old psters who want you to buy the best rather than the reasonable.

I have a Socket A system with 2100+ Palomino and a 9800Pro. I'm saving up for a new computer so I'm not upgrading video card. College comes first though....
 
Agent_N said:
Just ignore the 15 year old psters who want you to buy the best rather than the reasonable.
OP never gave a budget. Just ignore the 16 year old posters that assume everyone is a 15 year old mind reader

is there an agp card that will give me a decent performance boost without costing me so much I'd be better doing a mobo upgrade?
This is a more roundabout way of saying don't suggest PCI-E, $ is still up in the air as a 7800gs does not require a mobo upgrade.
 
cyks said:
OP never gave a budget. Just ignore the 16 year old posters that assume everyone is a 15 year old mind reader

Cyks, I have seen way to many posts where someone would like a recommendation and everyone starts recommending the highest dollar card they can think of. I haven't seen near as many posters recommend reasonably priced upgrades. This is at the heart of my post Cyks.


This is a more roundabout way of saying don't suggest PCI-E, $ is still up in the air as a 7800gs does not require a mobo upgrade.

I noticed that he didn't want a PCI-E recommendation, 6800GT's can be found in AGP last I knew. Unless I heard incorrect information. I usually can't remember all the cards from both nvidia and ATI and which model comes in AGP and/or PCI-E flavor.
 
The 7800GS is AGP, but it costs nearly $300 dollars last time I checked.
6800GT is a much better buy for your specific system.
I was looking at either a 6800 or even an ati 1600-just not too sure if I'll be getting a very moderate increase in framerate,and if it's really worth it?Or will I be able to crank the details back up to near max?
This is a more roundabout way of saying don't suggest PCI-E, $ is still up in the air as a 7800gs does not require a mobo upgrade.
What I'm really wondering is if I were to go all out on the 7800,how much faster pci-e actually is?Or to put it another way,will a moderate pci-e card blow a high end agp card out of the water?I hate to rebuild my whole system just so I can turn on the smoke effects in COD2.Otherwise the system is still doing me nicely.
 
electrocutioner said:
What I'm really wondering is if I were to go all out on the 7800,how much faster pci-e actually is?Or to put it another way,will a moderate pci-e card blow a high end agp card out of the water?I hate to rebuild my whole system just so I can turn on the smoke effects in COD2.Otherwise the system is still doing me nicely.

PCI-E is a faster connection than AGP, but it's not that that makes PCI-E cards better. While PCI-E cards haven't even gotten to the threshold where they would exceed AGP bandwidth, the pure and simple fact is that the high-end video cards are all coming out for PCI-E now. For instance, an AGP X850XT is the same performance-wise as a PCI-E X850XT.

Oh yeah, and don't rebuild a system just for one game. :)
 
I don't know if this will help you at all, but I'll chime in with my own experience. I recently upgraded from a 9800 Pro to a 6800nu. Here are my system specs.

P4 2.6C (800mhz FSB, 512k cache)
Abit AI7
1gb Corsair value
BFG 6800nu

My card like many AGP 6800nu was able to unlock from 12 pipelines to 16, and 5 vertex shaders to 6. This makes it pretty comparable to a 6800GT minus the faster GDDR3 ram on the GT which gives it the edge.

In the end though, this card blew away the 9800 Pro especially in F.E.A.R.
So any card that is better than the 6800 will no doubt satisfy you. In my case I didn't want to get anything to fast for fear that my cpu would be bottlenecking the crazy power of these new vid cards.
 
PioneerCrazed said:
In my case I didn't want to get anything to fast for fear that my cpu would be bottlenecking the crazy power of these new vid cards.

Exactly. A 6800-series card is where it's at. the 7800GS is really too much for our aging systems to handle.

My 6800GS should be here tomorrow. :D
Package was on the truck Saturday morning but POS UPS won't deliver Ground on weekends.
 
i was pretty amazed to see that newegg doesnt carry a single 6800gs in agp. the 6800gs isnt even listed on pricewatch.
 
In the end though, this card blew away the 9800 Pro especially in F.E.A.R.
Ok you almost have me sold-But as far as this statement goes,my card is unlocked to 9800XT bios and speeds.Short of the RAM it is an XT card.Will I still see a worthy increase?
Oh yeah, and don't rebuild a system just for one game.
;)
Well,theres Fear,which ran pretty close to full out,except for some stuttering.
COD2,had to really scale back on details...
BF2 could be better-ditto on Q4.
No doubt I am seeing the beggining of a trend here :(

So a 6800 sounds like a good bet-What specs are important to consider-what to avoid?Any brands to stay away from?How bout a PNY GeForce 6800 GS / 256MB GDDR3 / AGP 8x / DVI / VGA / TV Out / Video Card?Its priced at 179 bucks-
http://www.tigerdirect.com/applications/SearchTools/item-details.asp?EdpNo=1782292&CatId=935
any gud?
 
PioneerCrazed said:
Decision's, decision's... :D

I just finished CoD2, and with my system I was able to play with 2xAA, at 1280x1024.

Here is a decent comparo between AGP cards, it's a little outdated though not having the newest games like FEAR and CoD2, etc...

http://www.tomshardware.com/2005/07/05/vga_charts_vii/

Do not ever trust an article from Tom's Hardware. They've been known to fake benchmarks horribly (ie., they claimed in one of their hardware roundups that a 6600GT performs better than an X850XT -- please...)

edit: You can also see it in the article you linked. Go to page 15 and look at the bottom benchmark result, which is Sims 2 with AA enabled. Needless to say, they show again that a 6600GT performs better than an X850XT PE. Also, it shows a difference of 60 FPS between AA enabled and AA disabled with a 9600PRO. They really do just make stuff up... :(

Seriously, Tom's Hardware should just be shut down. Period.
 
Back
Top