upgrade the vidcard or the cpu?

sunchaser

n00b
Joined
May 27, 2009
Messages
42
Hi guys,

I currently own a AMD Athlon 64 X2 5000+ Black Edition, 4GB OCZ Platinum DDR2-800 + ECS Geforce 9600GT 512MB.
I'm about to order a new 22" LCD and want to play as much games as possible on native 1680x1050.
I know my current rig will have trouble with some newer games so i'm willing to upgrade, but only 1 component and i'm in the dark as to what upgrade would give me the best performance boost : the vidcard or cpu?
The reason i'm asking is because i was thinking of upgrading my vidcard to something like the 9800GT/GTS 250 but i'm afraid my CPU will keep it from running at full potential. So maybe it's better to upgrade the CPU to bring the most out of my 9600GT?
Could you also state what brand/model you would recommend? (for vidcards i like to stick to Nvidia)

Any advice greatly appreciated,
Sunchaser.

Some more specs :

* PSU Enermax Noisetaker 485Watt
* Default CPU speed 2,6Ghz
* Asus AM2 mainboard (don't have the specific model number with me)
* Budget : 100-150€
* Memory @ default speeds : CAS Latency (CL) 4 | RAS-to-CAS-Delay (tRCD) 5 |
RAS-Precharge-Time (tRP) 4 | Row-Active-Time (tRAS) 15
* Antec Case P160W
* Default AMD CPU/HSF

Thanks again.
 
The minimum that we normally recommend for that resolution is the HD4850, which outperforms the 9800GT and performs on par with the GTX 250 but is often found for a bit less. If you can afford one, a used HD4870 or GTX 260 would be a better option.

Which motherboard are you currently using? Though I don't believe that you'll have to upgrade the processor at this moment, the motherboard that you're using could help us determine your updating options. As a tangent, you may want to consider upgrading the power supply, especially if you've been using it for more than two years.
 
Last edited:
tiraides meant resolution.

If you can, OC that CPU to around 3Ghz. It shouldn't affect gaming that much though, especially at your res, unless its a CPU intensive game.

If I googled correctly, you'll need a new PSU if that thing only has 18A on its +12V rail. You can get a Corsair 400W for $50 right now at the egg (also has a $10MIR), and it offers 30A on its +12V rail (where your system draws most of its power from).
 
I would say both... 5000+ is very dated these days and 9600 GT handles 19" LCD with no problem but 22" you would have to leave out any AA and FSAA.
 
Mainboard is Asus M2A-VM.
PSU is Enermax Noisetaker EG-495AX-VE(W) (24P)
495 Watt and 18A on seperate 12V rails
i also checked my CPU, seems i did OC it from day1 to 3.0Ghz, only forgot about it :confused:

i've had the PSU for several years indeed, do these things loose power over the years?
geez, didn't know that...and do you think it won't be able to feed enough power to a new vidcard?

thanks again
 
PSUs become less efficient over the years and start to lose their capabilities, as do many things with age. ;) Oh, so its a different PSU than the one in the OP. That one is better, at least, since it has 32A on the +12V rails. How old is it, exactly? After 5 yrs, you'll probably want to replace it. It should power the new vidcard, but not sure for how long it will last afterwards.
 
Rule of thumb that works for me is that if your game performance is poor at lower resolutions, you need more CPU or Memory. if your performance is poor at larger resolutions (roughly anything over 1000 vertically,) you need more video card.
 
Back
Top