Upgrade Dilemma

Joined
Jun 14, 2007
Messages
1,018
My current rig is in my signature. I built it late 2005, and had a grand plan of skipping DDR2 entirely and upgrade most of my computer in late 2008, exactly 3 years later. However, two things have happened that have made me question my resolve and upgrade one year earlier.

For one, I was a build n00b back then and didn't take seriously the reviews about the noise of the chipset fan on my MSI K8N Neo4/Platinum. I just couldn't take the noise, so I replaced the chipset fan with a Zalman heatsink, which is working just fine, but means that I can't use a dual-slot video card on it, much less SLI (albeit the latter of which I probably wouldn't have done anyway). If not for that, I probably already would have upgraded my video card to a nVidia GeForce 8800GTS. So I'm stuck with my 7800GT until nVidia can manage to make a single-slot 8800 or 8900, and who knows how long that will be, if ever. (And no, I'm not going back to the noisy chipset fan; that would be even worse.)

For two, memory prices have been falling insanely. It cost me $210 (after rebate) to get my 2GB of DDR-400 RAM back in 2005. Now I could get 4GB of DDR2-800 for $160. Which I'm seriously tempted to do within the next week or two, before prices have a chance to go back up again. (The rest of the upgrade can wait until later if needs be.)

So given my situation, should I bite on the memory and upgrade to a P35 with a cheap Core 2 Duo with an eye towards Penryn? Should I get a P965 or 650i and get a Q6600 in late July when the price drops? Or should I just hold out and keep on chuggin' with my current machine and upgrade in late 2008 to DDR3 and Nehalem (if that's out by then) as I had originally planned? What would be a better bang for the buck in the long-term? Does anyone have any idea what DDR3 memory prices will be like in a little over a year?
 
I think the first question you have to ask yourself is "Is something really pressing me to upgrade?" A 7800GT is still a pretty darn good video card, even if it's a year old.

The adoption of DDR3 is going to take a good long while. AMD just barely moved to DDR2, and you know they're going to stick with it for a long time. So I wouldn't put off your upgrade for the sake of that.

Now is a great time to build a system--hard drive prices are ridiculously low, RAM prices have fallen through the floor, and there are tons of great motherboards, CPUs, and graphics cards out there. I've heard that RAM prices are quite cyclical, peaking around the end/beginning of the year and bottoming out in the 2-3rd quarters.

It's never a good time to buy a CPU or GPU--there's always something better just around the corner. Right now it's Penryn and Barcelona on the CPU side, and it's certain that nVidia will come out with an 8900 of some sorts in a few months. So don't let upcoming CPUs or GPUs affect your timing (unless it's only a week away).
 
All you've described is what you want to do. If you want to upgrade, go ahead and do it. However, if you described the kind of things you use your computer for, you might get better advice on upgrading. In my opinion, most people don't upgrade until they want to do something with their computer that they can't currently do, or it doesn't do well.
 
Thanks for all the comments so far. :) Sorry, I should have specified. It's a gaming computer. Mostly RPG/MMO's, though I plan to get Starcraft 2 when it comes out. Oblivion is basically shelved until I can get a better video card to enjoy it properly (though there's no rush; it's not going anywhere), and Lord of the Rings Online is having occasional hitching problems in more populated areas, especially Bree, which is annoyance enough for me to consider the upgrade for (and show that future games might have trouble), but not so serious that I must upgrade this very minute for. I also forgot to mention that I game at 1680x1050.

I also like to browse the web, play DVD's, and play with Linux, but none of those things are affected by my system specs (except perhaps Linux nudging me to stick with nVidia graphics cards, but then they're who are making the better cards now anyway).

You're right about "there's always something better just around the corner", Mohonri, but I'm concerned about bang for buck, not just what's better. DDR3 and Nehalem will of course be better than DDR2 and Conroe/Penryn, but then if I can get 4GB of DDR2 for $160, but 4GB of DDR3 is $500 (theoretically speaking) in late 2008 when I had first planned to upgrade, then all other things being equal, wouldn't that make it more advantageous to buy now? Of course, that's the big if that's irking me. Because if it turns out that I can get even better bang for the buck in late 2008, I would feel better toughing it out now and upgrading when originally planned. In this case, it's not "something around the corner" affecting my timing and prompting me to wait, it's "something here now I didn't expect" (namely lack of good single-slot video card upgrades and insanely low DDR2 prices) prompting me to possibly upgrade earlier.

And if I do decide to upgrade now, then is it better to go the P965/Q6600 route, or the P35/Penryn route? Or even the P35/Q6600 or 650i/Q6600 route?
 
Considering that there are very few games out there that effectively use two cores currently, I think going quad-core would not be worth it. I'd say just go with the P965(or 680i)/Core2Duo, get your 2-3GB RAM (don't bother with 4GB--most of the fourth GB would be wasted), and with the money you saved on those, buy a better video card--8800GTX or GTS.
 
My current rig is in my signature. I built it late 2005, and had a grand plan of skipping DDR2 entirely and upgrade most of my computer in late 2008, exactly 3 years later. However, two things have happened that have made me question my resolve and upgrade one year earlier.

For one, I was a build n00b back then and didn't take seriously the reviews about the noise of the chipset fan on my MSI K8N Neo4/Platinum. I just couldn't take the noise, so I replaced the chipset fan with a Zalman heatsink, which is working just fine, but means that I can't use a dual-slot video card on it, much less SLI (albeit the latter of which I probably wouldn't have done anyway). If not for that, I probably already would have upgraded my video card to a nVidia GeForce 8800GTS. So I'm stuck with my 7800GT until nVidia can manage to make a single-slot 8800 or 8900, and who knows how long that will be, if ever. (And no, I'm not going back to the noisy chipset fan; that would be even worse.)

For two, memory prices have been falling insanely. It cost me $210 (after rebate) to get my 2GB of DDR-400 RAM back in 2005. Now I could get 4GB of DDR2-800 for $160. Which I'm seriously tempted to do within the next week or two, before prices have a chance to go back up again. (The rest of the upgrade can wait until later if needs be.)

So given my situation, should I bite on the memory and upgrade to a P35 with a cheap Core 2 Duo with an eye towards Penryn? Should I get a P965 or 650i and get a Q6600 in late July when the price drops? Or should I just hold out and keep on chuggin' with my current machine and upgrade in late 2008 to DDR3 and Nehalem (if that's out by then) as I had originally planned? What would be a better bang for the buck in the long-term? Does anyone have any idea what DDR3 memory prices will be like in a little over a year?

why not just swap out the motherboard for something new?

keep your system, and upgrade the VC. then next year, at this same time assess what you've got and then invest in a new system if you need to.
 
Back
Top