Upgrade - Different options: Most Beneficial

mokkapoop

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Jun 6, 2005
Messages
1,155
Ok guys. I have the chance to do a little upgrading on my computer. I have the following specs:

Dell Dimension E521 Mini Tower desktop
AMD Athlon 64X2 Dual Core 3800+
2048M DDR2 RAM (DDR2 PC2-5400 667MHZ
160G SATA hard drive
16X DVD+-RW double layer CD/DVD burner drive,
EVGA 7600GT 256MB
Dell E207FPW 20.1" WideScreen
WindowsXP Professional

Which option would be better in upgrading:

1. More Ram (now at 2gb pc2-5300 667mhz, or possibly go to 3gb pc2-6400 800mhz)

2. Faster CPU (now at the X2 3800+ at 2.0ghz /2x 512kb cache, or go with a X2 6000+ at 3.0ghz and 2x 1mb cache). Fry's has the 6000+ and ECS mobo for $229 today, was thinking about picking it up and selling my old chip and the 3800+ together to offset the price.

3. Don't upgrade at all.

Please help!
 
You left out the most important part of your question: what are you looking to do with your system?

If you're looking to speed up general windows apps (not gaming), then your processor would be the most natural area to bump up. If you're looking to bump up your gaming performance, then your videocard would be the best area to upgrade. I wouldn't consider the RAM upgrade in either scenario, as you won't see much of any benefit.

My final obvious statement: don't bother upgrading unless your system isn't performing where you'd like it to. Might as well set that money aside for something else :D
 
Gaming of course but I also do the following:

* Running a 24 man DOD Source Server on it (I have FIOS and this is working PERFECTLY)

* Gaming as stated before (mainly DOD Souce, so I think I am ok there)

* Ripping and burning DVD's

* Websites

* Photo editing

* Running multiple tasks at once.
 
It really comes down to which one are you looking to improve more: gaming performance or application performance?
 

Then you'd want to do both :D

That's what I was trying to prod you into deciding between. To be honest, a 7600GT isn't going to see a significant performance boost from a faster processor. In a perfect world I'd say grab one of the mid-range DX10 products (either from nVidia or ATi, depending how they perform) as well as a new processor.
 
Would the 6000+ benefit the server I run in anyway?

What would the CPU upgrade benefit at all?
 
imo you may have to start thinking about just starting over with a new build and carrying over some parts. i mean you would definitely benefit from a video card update, but you would probably need an aftermarket psu. then you would want to upgrade the processor, but if cost is a factor you would rather by a cheapie and overclock it. however, doing that would mean you would need a new mobo and maybe higher quality ram.
 
Would the 6000+ benefit the server I run in anyway?

What would the CPU upgrade benefit at all?

I'm not very familiar with Source based servers (I only ever hosted traditional CS servers, 1.6 and earlier), but more than likely that processor is plenty for a 24 man. Upgrading your processor would result in windows applications running faster (video encoding/decoding, audio, photo editing, winrar, etc.). You'd also probably get a nominal boost in your FPS, but nothing significant.

If you are considering overclocking your processor you could always buy a new motherboard and transplant your parts. That would also probably unlock the possibility of adding a new videocard to the bundle, getting you the whole shabang.
 
April 22nd
Core 2 Duo E4400 + mobo (perfect for the type of ram you have) and overclock it. If you don't want to overclock (why not) then 667Mhz ram is good for a Core 2 Duo E6xxx. But to overclock a E6xxx then PC6400 ram or better is prefered... That why I say E4400 in your case.

For the Video the 8800GTS 640MB is great but if too expensive a 8600GTS when they released are not bad either.
 
You guys are mising the point.... I will not be upgrading the video card, period. I won't be playing an DX10 games anytime soon, just Source DOD for now.

Would it better to go with a much faster CPU or more ram (original question)?
 
You guys are mising the point.... I will not be upgrading the video card, period. I won't be playing an DX10 games anytime soon, just Source DOD for now.

Would it better to go with a much faster CPU or more ram (original question)?

Sorry if I missed the point, I just thought that you mentioned improving your gaming performance was one of your objectives. DX10 has nothing to do with it; it's just that the DX10 cards available are far quicker than any of the DX9 cards available.

Anyway, between the two (CPU or RAM) a CPU upgrade would do far more for you than more RAM
 
I agree with quadnad. If you want to be able to take advantage of more ram, you'll need a better OS (64-bit).
 
Back
Top