Upgrade: AMD 64 or Pentium 4?

jgarcia408

n00b
Joined
Aug 8, 2004
Messages
30
Im going to be upgrading my PC and need some help. For the past 5-6 years I have used AMD as my processor. I think I may be ready to change that. Im starting my research of what my next PC will be. My friend recommended I come here to get some answers to some questions, so here I am, and here are the questions.

First question: What is the better way to go? AMD 64 or Pentium 4 Processors. I get one group saying go P4 (that group is of Intel loyalist), and another saying go AMD 64 (and that group is of AMD loyalist). Obviously those two groups are a little bias. Then I ask groups that dont seem to be particularly loyal to either and I get mixed recommendations. Im really interested in Intel because of Hyperthreading, but I dont know if its something I really need. So, what should be better?

Second question: What Mobo do you think is the best, based on your answer of the first question? I have been looking at the DIF Lanparty Boards and they look really good. I also like MSI boards though. I have heard ASUS is really reliable too. I dont OC, although I might try to on this board, so that should be taken into consideration. I have never OCd a processor before, so I would like a board that is user friendly for OCing. I use my PC for Gaming (main use), Video Editing, Photo Editing, and other basics like internet, email and word processing. So, referring to any boards, not only the brands listed, which do you think is the best?

Third, and final question: PCI Express, should I take that into consideration. This upgrade will probably be the last Mobo/CPU upgrade I make for a while. The only other upgrades would be Memory and Video Cards. So, I have been hearing about PCI Express, is this something that I should look for on a new Mobo, or is that something that I shouldnt be too concerned about?

The components like Video Card, Hard Drive, Optical Drives, Firewire card, and possibly memory will be transfered from the PC I have now, to the new one. If it helps, this is what my current PC has in it now.

Motherboard: BIOSTAR M7NCG 400
CPU: AMD Athlon XP 2400+
Video Card: ATI Radeon 9700 Pro 128MB
Memory: 512MB DDR PC2700 (2x256mb) (dont know the brand, but thinking about upgrading to Crucial 512MB PC3200)
Hard Drive: Maxtor 80GB 7200rpm
Optical Drive: I/O Magic 8x Dual Format DVD Burner
PCI Cards: Dynex 3 Port Firewire Card


Thanks in advance for any information given.
 
I would go with the 64. Although hyperthreading does really help the P4's, it doesn't help enough.

You can't find a PCI-E AMD board right now. Yes, it is a good technology that I would get given the chance, however, it is not really needed at this point. By the time that high end AGP cards are no longer made, you will need a new motherboard anyway.
 
Video editing is not as time sensitive as gaming :)P) I would go for A64. In fact, I just moved from P4 to A64. HT is nice and noticeble but pure gaming performance of A64 just can't be denied. Will change sig once all oc'ing is complete :)
 
Correct me if I'm wrong, but doesn't the A64's HyperTransport technology act like HyperThreading? Man, i'm so out of the loop.
 
Thanks a lot guys. I was hoping the answer would be A64 because AMD has been really good to me. Now, any recommendations on motherboards which use AMD 64 CPUs?
 
RexPokinghorn said:
Correct me if I'm wrong, but doesn't the A64's HyperTransport technology act like HyperThreading? Man, i'm so out of the loop.

Hypertransport is just what amd calls their fsb.
 
1st Question:

I would suggest an AMD 64 as they are outperforming their intel counterparts, unless of course the majority of stuff you do is video and photo editing then I would suggest maybe leaning towards an intel, but the performance difference is slim, and AMD definetly holds the advantage right now in the gaming arena.

2nd Question:

Around here Abit boards are king, they ususally provide solid stability of boards like an Asus, but come with tons of o/cing features. Most of the big name mobos will serve you well as they are all about the same in performance.

3rd Question:

PCI-E is here, but I doubt we will see much migration of even the enthusiast martket probablly till at least 05. As the way it stands right now there is no real world benefit of having it, since video cards do not utilize all the bandwidth on the AGP slot. I would save your money and go with an AGP board.

As for RAM:

Crucial is the best bang for buck RAM there is, but it does not have the headroom that the others do when it comes to o/cing, lack of heatspreaders and slower latencies. But the performance between the high dollar RAM and Crucial has been very small it seems, until you start scaling the MHz upwards.
 
UltimaParadox, what ram would you suggest? Im probably going to upgrade Motherboard and CPU and use my current ram until I can save up for different ram, hopefully up to 1gigs worth.

I was reading the review for the MSI K8N Neo motherboard on Hardocp and it sounds really good. Anyone have any thoughts? You mention ASUS being king around here. Is there a specific board that you can recommend?

Heres the address to the review of the MSI board im referring too. http://hardocp.com/article.html?art=NjA3
 
Lord of Shadows said:
Hypertransport is just what amd calls their fsb.

Sort of. Think of it more as a type of highway for data. It can connect two points, but is more than just a FSB technology :)
 
I would always go corsair, unless you can't for some reason (motherboard incompatible with corsair). Every once in a while another manufacture will make something faster than corsair (like ocz has done right now), but that is really pretty rare.

Crucial and kingston aren't bad either, but the performance isn't always there. Maybe I have just always got bad sticks, but I found no headroom in OCZ either.
 
Im going to try to get Corsair, if I can afford it. So, the motherboards, can anyone point me towards a highly recommended board?
 
the Abit Kv8 pro for VIA
the MSI thingamawhatchcallit 250gb for nForce3

as of what i have read, it really is just a matter of preference...
 
after deciding to go a64 u have to decide socket 754 or 939, just based on what u can afford, then ask for mobo based on that

the 939 boards are limited tho, just as warning
 
Speaking for myself, I just went with a Gigabyte K8NSNXP-939 paired up with an A64 3500. I'm very happy with it. It's very pricey (the most by far I've ever paid for a board), but the MSI 939 board still hasn't come out yet. As it stands, it's the only nForce3 socket 939 mobo out right now. Maybe wait a little bit, the MSI boards are supposed to be out by mid-August, I believe.
 
Athlon 64 loves OCZ EB and BH-5. Other memories doesn't run as well as it does on intel board.
 
I'm currently looking at getting an A64 754 pin on MSI's nForce 3 250GB (K8N Neo) board. 939 boards and procs aren't very available and are a little pricey. Also I've had Abit, but it seems like, if it's not their current top of the line OCing board, bios revisions only come once in a blue moon. (I bought a BE-7 right before they started releasing their IC7-Max2 or whatever) Asus is nice, and usually has a lot of features, but on the expensive side. So I think I'll try out MSI this time.
 
As others have pointed out, AMD64 is the best choice for gaming rigs right now. As for whether you should go with socket 939 or 754, this depends on whether you are going to keep this system for a long time, because socket 754 will become the 'budget'-socket (Sempron). 939 will have all the new Athlon64 and FX CPUs.
 
jgarcia408 said:
UltimaParadox, what ram would you suggest? Im probably going to upgrade Motherboard and CPU and use my current ram until I can save up for different ram, hopefully up to 1gigs worth.

I was reading the review for the MSI K8N Neo motherboard on Hardocp and it sounds really good. Anyone have any thoughts? You mention ASUS being king around here. Is there a specific board that you can recommend?

Heres the address to the review of the MSI board im referring too. http://hardocp.com/article.html?art=NjA3


Picking RAM is hard to do, you have to decide where you stand on terms on what you want to expect from your RAM. Day in and day out stock settings are usually guaranteed by any RAM and usually going with the lowest price/ well-known brand is a good way to save some money and get some good performance. Namely Kingston/Crucial/Corsair/Mushkin. While buying high performance RAM is nearly hit and miss, its all chance, but of course usually the trend is, the more you spend the less risk you take when trying to find high performing RAM. Such as your Corsair/Mushkin/OCZ performance type RAM.

AS for motherboards Abit is my personal favorite, as I am sure many people around here can agree with me, is that they have great stability and o/cing features. As for that MSI board the performance looks good, and they have a good reputation, don't be hesitant to buy. Its ultimately your decision though, and I wouldn't consider a socket 939 solution unless you really got some cash to spare right now
 
I dont really know the difference between a socket 939 and 754. Can anyone please tell me. This is going to be the last time I upgrade for the next year and a half to two years. I I wouldnt mind paying a little more if it means Im getting a better board and more options. Theres some store locally that is offering the MSI board I mentioned and a AMD 64 3000 CPU for $250. That sounds really good to me. I was then going to get some Corsair XMS PC3200 Ram, a 512MB Stick for $118 at newegg.com. I only want to get this if it should take care of me for a while. What do you guys think? Are these good prices? Should I wait and get a Socket 939? Like I said, I dont really know what the difference is. Im new to this generation of motherboards and cpu's, so I dont know what is what.
 
939 is also a safer bet as far as upgrade paths go, since future AMD CPUs will be released on that platform.
 
Too bad 939 doesnt have any clawhammers other than the FX line. To the noobies Claws have 1mb cache easily worth 200MHz over its newcastle 512kb brothers (incidentally this is how AMD adjusts the PR as well - a 3200+ newcastle is clocked 200MHz higher), and at equal clockrates claws will give the 939 cpus a run for its money. That said Ill probably go 939 when the lower models come out in Q4. Bottom line is going 754 does get you one feature that cant be found in 939 with regular cpus, 939 gives you only one thing, creating a trade-off situation where right now 754 is very performance competitive.

Trying to scoop up a 3200+ Claw is a worthwhile endeavour over a 3000+ if the budget can be stretched. Remember though, there will be the same model in the newcastle flavor so be a bit careful since otherwise just going with the 3000+ is probably better than paying more.
 
So the "Clawhammer" is better then just a regular AMD 64 3000+? Another question, do the 939 and 754 use the same processors, or do they both use different processors? Like processors with different amount of pins and what not?
 
Hopefully the rumored XP64 3600+'s come out to fix the little 939 clawhammer dilemma.
 
Depending on your budget you can be surprised on what you can afford.
I built the system in my sig including PSU, tower, and keyboard/mouse for under 2 grand with quite a bit of money to spare for other things (speakers, upgrades to old pcs)

If it's $1000, you can afford a nice P4-C/M and overclock the bitch out of it.
 
From what I understand..all of the FX processors run on Socket 940 mobo's. Or maybe its just the FX-53?

A good recomendation is the Asus K8v Se Deluxe Socket 754 mobo with the AMD 64 3700+

Kingston Hyper X is not bad RAM either


Bottom line: If you have the dough....go with the 939 or 940 and the upper level 64's

Beer Budget: Go with the 754 with the 3400+ or 3700+ for a "tad" more
 
I dont have as much $ as I thought I was going to have, so Im going to stick with the Socket 754. I will check out that Asus board, thats for the recommendation.

Let me ask this. I want to do a memory upgrade, and I want to know what would be better for gameplay. Having 1gb or PC2700 ram, or 512mb or PC3200 ram? Can anyone answer that for me. I think thats my last question for now. Thanks.
 
Go with the 3200.....I have a Gig of Kingston Hyper X (the pricey RAM) DDR400 PC3200 and it is lightning fast.....I also paid close to $300 for them though......The Kingston value RAM is not a bad choice.......although I hear Crucial is VERY good stuff too.....Mushkin is a brand to look at also.......But I will tell you now that Kingston PC3200 is tested and rated for the K8v SE Deluxe board. If youre gonna go with the Socket 754....either get the 3400+ or the 3700+.......If you get the 3200+ try and get the core(I think its the Clawhammer) with 1MB of L2 cache
 
Thanks everyone for all the answers. I appreciate all the help. I cant wait to build my new system. Now to choose a case. :D
 
Back
Top