Upgrade Advice needed after phenom disappointment

rgratto2

2[H]4U
Joined
Jul 22, 2005
Messages
2,319
I built a new rig this past summer. Its in the sig, but to make things easy ill link the important parts. I got a Biostar Tforce 550, an AM2 3800+, and slapped on an Arctic Cooler. I also grabbed an 8800 GTS 640mb.

My original intentions were to buy this relatively cheap cpu, overclock it up a bit, and drop in a phenom when they came out. Well, assuming i have my info correct, theres all that bullshit with the AM2+ mobos, and it doesnt seem as though I can just drop in a phenom. I am not quite pleased with the performance I am getting, my cpu is bottlenecking my video card.

That being said, I have been evaluating my upgrading options. It looks as though you can pick up a 5000+ black edition (as shown in this thread) for $94.99 shipped. Would I be better suited to get one of those and sell off my 3800, for a relatively cheap upgrade, or should I try to sell those 3 components and look to replace them with an intel setup? If I did the latter, do you think my parts would have good resale value on the FS forum, given that theyve been used for ~6 months and lightly overclocked? I know relatively little about intel parts, other than theyve been kicking some major ass.
 
A few questions before we begin:

- What's the speed of the G.Skill RAM that you purchased?
- Which monitor(s) do you have/are you planning on purchasing?
- How old is your NeoHE power supply?
- What did you build your rig for: gaming? Photoshop? Multitasking? What?
- How much of your own money (total, not including what you may get from selling your parts) would you be willing to use for upgrading your rig?

And now for the answer to all of your questions: It depends.

The easiest "solution" would be, as you mentioned, to swap out the 3800+ with the 5000+ BE and be done with it. If you're not planning on doing any heavy gaming (even though better cards are out there, including the refreshed 8800GTS with the G92 chips, your 8800GTS is still a good mid-range card) or system-intensive work, it may be all you need.

Yes, Intel is the better choice right now, and their low-end processors (the E2xxx and E4xxx series dual core CPUs) can overclock well, improving their performance over most AMD parts. But, depending on what you're (planning on) doing, you may not need to make the switch. Check the Intel Processors forum and the Intel Mobo's subforum for more information to help you in your decision.

If you plan on selling anything, especially here, don't expect to get more than 75% of your parts' original value back. Even that may be too generous, as many people will try to bargain with you to go lower. (I'll go into more detail later, if I need to... but let's just say I have plenty of experience on the subject.)

But before I go any further, I'd like some answer to my questions, so I have an idea of where you intend to go with this upgrade.
 
Ahh yes, I was too vague about my usage, sorry. Thank you for your detailed post, I'll try to answer your inquiries as best I can:

- What's the speed of the G.Skill RAM that you purchased?
It is DDR2 800, seen here.
- Which monitor(s) do you have/are you planning on purchasing?
I have the Samsung 226BW that I just purchased last.. May?
- How old is your NeoHE power supply?
Antec sent it to me because I had to RMA my previous PSU, I can't exactly remember how long I've been using it, but I believe that I got it last spring and did not use it until I made my new rig in June 2007.
- What did you build your rig for: gaming? Photoshop? Multitasking? What?
I game pretty frequently. The game of choice lately is TF2, and I would certainly like to be able to handle future blockbuster titles. Otherwise, I am a Computer Science major. I expect a lot from my computer and do a fair amount of multitasking.
- How much of your own money (total, not including what you may get from selling your parts) would you be willing to use for upgrading your rig?
I will be graduating soon and be making a salary, so I have enough money to splurge on an upgrade. Money is not necessarily an issue, although I would not feel as satisfied if I lost a significant chunk on upgrade from what I spent on these parts not long ago. If you want more specific numbers, I would go up to the $200-300 range on a processor and the $100-150 range on a motherboard.
 
What are your fps like in TF2 currently?
How did you come to the conclusion your CPU was your bottleneck?
Can you OC your CPU any higher than 2.4Ghz?
 
What are your fps like in TF2 currently?
How did you come to the conclusion your CPU was your bottleneck?
Can you OC your CPU any higher than 2.4Ghz?

I used Fraps today for about an hour of playtime. At maxed settings, I'd say that the frame rate averaged about 45, but there were a lot of dips. I saw it go as low as 22. I do not think this is my average performance though, arent the current nvidia drivers performing poorly?

I've determined that my CPU is the bottleneck based on 3dmark scores, and even vista's rating. I have not been able to find any stable OC past 2.4, although I am admittedly a bit noob at OCing.
 
For options, you could find a good Intel board, like the Gigabyte GA-P35-DS3L or the Abit IP35-E, for at least $90 (or more, based on what features you want). You could also obtain a low-end processor like the E2140 (that can overclock as high as 3.2GHz on air cooling) for under $80. Obtain a good CPU cooler, such as the Scythe Ninja ($36), and you have a nice setup for around $200 (plus shipping). (And don't worry: There are plenty of guides available, both here and elsewhere, on how to OC Intel processors.)

(Then again, all you may need to solve your problems is possibly a switch to a new AMD processor, like the aforementioned 5000+ BE.)

If, after you've made the proposed upgrade, you're still getting low numbers from gaming, then you may want to look at a new card for your computer. For under/around $300, you could purchase a 512MB 8800GT (which, right now, is the best in the bang-for-buck category) or a Radeon HD 3870 (which plays at the level of your 8800GTS for somewhat less).
 
For options, you could find a good Intel board, like the Gigabyte GA-P35-DS3L or the Abit IP35-E, for at least $90 (or more, based on what features you want). You could also obtain a low-end processor like the E2140 (that can overclock as high as 3.2GHz on air cooling) for under $80. Obtain a good CPU cooler, such as the Scythe Ninja ($36), and you have a nice setup for around $200 (plus shipping). (And don't worry: There are plenty of guides available, both here and elsewhere, on how to OC Intel processors.)

(Then again, all you may need to solve your problems is possibly a switch to a new AMD processor, like the aforementioned 5000+ BE.)

If, after you've made the proposed upgrade, you're still getting low numbers from gaming, then you may want to look at a new card for your computer. For under/around $300, you could purchase a 512MB 8800GT (which, right now, is the best in the bang-for-buck category) or a Radeon HD 3870 (which plays at the level of your 8800GTS for somewhat less).

Thanks for the post. I am pretty sure that my friend upgraded to an E2140 this fall, and has had great results. Any idea how a nicely OC'ed 5000+ BE would compare to an OC'ed 2140? Any good benchmarks to look at to compare?

I don't think I would likely change my video card. I decided to go high-end this time and got it for $295 in June, so I've been kind of pissed with all this refresh business that nvidia has been pulling.


The 5000+ is so tempting at $95 shipped. Newegg even has all of my info saved :eek:
 
Right now, deal-wise, the 5000+ BE can't be beaten. You get a processor, designed for overclocking, with an unlocked multiplier; you already have a system in place that you could use it with; and you would get substantial improvement over your current processor right away.

But I can't tell you to choose the 5000+ BE or to go with the Intel E2140/P35 combo... you have to determine what would best solve your performance issues -- satisfactorily, for you -- and go from there.
 
I've determined that my CPU is the bottleneck based on 3dmark scores, and even vista's rating. I have not been able to find any stable OC past 2.4, although I am admittedly a bit noob at OCing.

Vista's CPU rating is useless.

Try gaming with task manager open and see if your CPU spikes to 100% while playing. If so, then try lowering the resolution you're playing at, with 0xAA. Try several lower resolutions, and see if your framerate gets better as the resolutions get lower. If so, and your CPU is not at 100%, then its not your CPU bottlenecking your gaming performance.
 
I don't remember the specific numbers, but I ran 3dMark awhile ago and the tests on the processor indicated that it was holding back the rest of my system. I'll have to run them again soon.
 
Real world test (what I suggested you do) > synthetic benchmark (3DMark)... so do what I suggested instead.
 
Back
Top