Unofficial DirectX 12 FAQ

Stoly

Supreme [H]ardness
Joined
Jul 26, 2005
Messages
6,706
What is Direct X 12?
Its a next gen API from MS that will bring a closer to metal access for game developers for better performance and improved battery life on mobile devices.

Is it based on AMD'sMantle?
No

How long has it been in development?
About 4 years.

Who's behind it?
Microsoft in collaboration with Intel, AMD, Nvidia and Qualcomm

When will it be released.
Late 2015, expect a preview by years end.

Supported OS?
TBA

What platforms are supported?
Desktops, mobile, xbox1

Which video cards are supported?
Nvidia: Fermi, Kepler and Maxwell
AMD: GCN
Intel: TBA

When is Forza Motorsports 5 coming to PC?
At this time there are no plans to bring Forza to the PC, its just a demo to showcase DX12 and demostrate code portability.

Which game developers will support DX12?
At this time there are no announcements, expect them soon.

Will all games benefit from DX12?
Only DX12 games will benefit from the features. Older games could get a DX12 Patch.
 
Want some more kool-aid Stoly ? you seemed to be parched!
 
Last edited:
What is Direct X 12?
.

Is it based on AMD'sMantle?
yes, to some degree as AMD was involved in its devleopment. It contains a sub-set of mantle features.

How long has it been in development?
discussed 4 years ago, active development About 1 years.

corrected for truth.
 
The heck was the point of this thread? There is already a DX12 discussion thread.
 
I love circumstantial evidence and connecting imaginary dots that don't exist. Remember, everything that is similar in wording is the same. That MUST mean that DX12 is Mantle. It is interesting , though, that nvidia also worked hand in hand with MS for DX12. I guess they were just force fed along into implementing Mantle into DX12. Oddly enough DX12 was in development for four years. Mantle? Two years, according to AMD. Hmm. Something with the circumstantial evidence isn't adding up here. Now of course I don't know for sure. Maybe it happened, maybe it didn't, but circumstantial evidence as fact doesn't really create a compelling argument. And the argument is silly to begin with.

It is truly an argument that is a waste of time. Who cares. Seriously? Even if that were true, and I don't think it is because MS didn't say it is in any way related to Mantle. Just because two cars drive similarly, doesn't mean that the innards are the same. What does it even do to even discuss about it? Is this some type of psychological chest-beating over "hey Mantle had this first!". Whatever man.

If AMD had a hand in this, hey great. Props to them for that. If they didn't? Well they still have mantle which seems to be a great value add for whoever has a GCN card. That's great as well for competition. I don't see the need to sperg over what is essentially, semantics. Again I do give props to AMD for heading in this direction. Now the entire PC gaming ecosystem will head in that direction, although DX12 has been in the works for 4 years. (this was also in the GDC presentation, oddly enough). DX12 won't be ready until later so AMD has plenty of time to take advantage of their Mantle investment - they will have a full year or so to do whatever they want with that. I think that's awesome. It will force nvidia to compete through brute force, which i'm sure they will with big Maxwell. Everyone benefits. Increased competition, better products, and AMD users getting Mantle as a value add. Everyone SHOULD be happy here. But the main point here is, this is truly a worthless and waste of time argument that has no bearing on any end result. It is also completely circumstantial evidence. Let's just all be happy for a more competitive GPU landscape and something that is here or coming for everyone.
 
Last edited:
I love circumstantial evidence and connecting imaginary dots that don't exist. Remember, everything that is similar in wording is the same. That MUST mean that DX12 is Mantle. It is interesting , though, that nvidia also worked hand in hand with MS for DX12. I guess they were just force fed along into implementing Mantle into DX12. Oddly enough DX12 was in development for four years. Mantle? Two years, according to AMD. Hmm. Something with the circumstantial evidence isn't adding up here. Now of course I don't know for sure. Maybe it happened, maybe it didn't, but circumstantial evidence as fact doesn't really create a compelling argument. And the argument is silly to begin with.

It is truly an argument that is a waste of time. Who cares. Seriously? Even if that were true, and I don't think it is because MS didn't say it is in any way related to Mantle. Just because two cars drive similarly, doesn't mean that the innards are the same. What does it even do to even discuss about it? Is this some type of psychological chest-beating over "hey Mantle had this first!". Whatever man.

If AMD had a hand in this, hey great. Props to them for that. If they didn't? Well they still have mantle which seems to be a great value add for whoever has a GCN card. That's great as well for competition. I don't see the need to sperg over what is essentially, semantics. Again I do give props to AMD for heading in this direction. Now the entire PC gaming ecosystem will head in that direction, although DX12 has been in the works for 4 years. (this was also in the GDC presentation, oddly enough). DX12 won't be ready until later so AMD has plenty of time to take advantage of their Mantle investment - they will have a full year or so to do whatever they want with that. I think that's awesome. It will force nvidia to compete through brute force, which i'm sure they will with big Maxwell. Everyone benefits. Increased competition, better products, and AMD users getting Mantle as a value add. Everyone SHOULD be happy here. But the main point here is, this is truly a worthless and waste of time argument that has no bearing on any end result. It is also completely circumstantial evidence. Let's just all be happy for a more competitive GPU landscape and something that is here or coming for everyone.

Type out a 413 word rant to say you don't care and it doesn't matter anyway?
 
Mantle was designed to function closer to how the GPUs internally operate. With DX12 chasing a similar goal, I'm not sure what is surprising about them arriving at similar concepts.
 
Mantle was designed to function closer to how the GPUs internally operate. With DX12 chasing a similar goal, I'm not sure what is surprising about them arriving at similar concepts.

Because you need to explain how MS can do this without knowlegde of the core hardware. Since that part is handled by video card drivers , hence high level as in DX11 API.

They pulled this information on low level hardware for each vendor out of the all knowing butt of Bill Gates ?
 
Mantle was designed to function closer to how the GPUs internally operate. With DX12 chasing a similar goal, I'm not sure what is surprising about them arriving at similar concepts.
As the saying goes, there are only so many ways to skin a cat.
 
[random AMD fan tweet]:

"Why does it feel like i'm reading the Mantle programming guide"

Indeed reading something that doesn't exist since the API is not yet public. I like reading imaginary things myself.

Response: smiley face.

There you go, indisputable evidence. A guide that doesn't exist to the public and the smiley face response. I was right on the psychological chest beating over "we were first", clearly anyone that takes self pride in that sort of thing has some issues to work out. If it happened, cool, if it didn't happen, cool, in the meantime I suppose we'll just get deluged with more nonsensical circumstantial evidence. If Mantle had a hand in DX12, good on AMD. It's just odd that the former has been in dev for 2 years longer, but hey whatever. If it happened cool.
 
Last edited:
The only circumstancial evidence you have, that microsoft has been working dx12 for 4 year, which says nothing bout api optimization.

While amd, has many programers stating for the last 6 years they were turned down on what mantle does. (see 6 trumps 4)

If microsoft had started listening to them 4 years ago... you think they d be the first to know.
Even 2 years ago, when amd said they'd do mantle, those programmers would've said no dx12 is coming.

You know your hate for amd Xoleras is really unhealthy, it'll give you an ulcer with the 2 years of mantle threads that'll popup. Dx12 is still far away.... :) <=== smilie


P.S. All the GDC slides had a mantle vibe and does it in the same way and even microsoft said amd worked with em to make it. so maybe ppl should stop trying to say amd no part in it because of their disdain for a corporation. (The pcperspective feed was hillarious, ppl saying amd sucks , xboxone rules. :D lol)
 
[random AMD fan tweet]:

"Why does it feel like i'm reading the Mantle programming guide"

Indeed reading something that doesn't exist since the API is not yet public. I like reading imaginary things myself.

Response: smiley face.

There you go, indisputable evidence. A guide that doesn't exist to the public and the smiley face response. I was right on the psychological chest beating over "we were first", clearly anyone that takes self pride in that sort of thing has some issues to work out. If it happened, cool, if it didn't happen, cool, in the meantime I suppose we'll just get deluged with more nonsensical circumstantial evidence. If Mantle had a hand in DX12, good on AMD. It's just odd that the former has been in dev for 2 years longer, but hey whatever. If it happened cool.

it was a winky face, not a smiley, as in Johan was implying its basically mantle.

Subtlety is clearly lost on you.

Im more inclined to believe an industry insider and the lead programmer of arguably one of the largest developers in the world (Johan is the lead programmer at Dice for those that don't already know) than some random fanboi.
 
Because you need to explain how MS can do this without knowlegde of the core hardware. Since that part is handled by video card drivers , hence high level as in DX11 API.

They pulled this information on low level hardware for each vendor out of the all knowing butt of Bill Gates ?

Because they talk to the IHV's? What is strange about this again?
 
Mantle is in most mainstream engines now. In two years Mantle will be standard protocol. Mantle will be much more optimized and mature than dx12. I dont think dx will be able perform on the level of Mantle. Ever use a universal remote, they're never as good as the original.:)
 
[random AMD fan tweet]:

"Why does it feel like i'm reading the Mantle programming guide"

Indeed reading something that doesn't exist since the API is not yet public. I like reading imaginary things myself.

Response: smiley face.

There you go, indisputable evidence. A guide that doesn't exist to the public and the smiley face response. I was right on the psychological chest beating over "we were first", clearly anyone that takes self pride in that sort of thing has some issues to work out. If it happened, cool, if it didn't happen, cool, in the meantime I suppose we'll just get deluged with more nonsensical circumstantial evidence. If Mantle had a hand in DX12, good on AMD. It's just odd that the former has been in dev for 2 years longer, but hey whatever. If it happened cool.

He's not a random AMD fanboy. He's a game programmer @ Creative Assembly. I wonder since he's seen the Mantle programming guide that Creative Assembly might be another dev that's going to support Mantle?
 
Because they talk to the IHV's? What is strange about this again?

Yeah I don't think they share any information on hardware level with MS :)
And why would they , they make their own drivers MS only provides the framework.

If you see how AMD sometimes struggles with drivers that would be somehow work when they have chats with MS ?
 
it was a winky face, not a smiley, as in Johan was implying its basically mantle.

Subtlety is clearly lost on you.

Im more inclined to believe an industry insider and the lead programmer of arguably one of the largest developers in the world (Johan is the lead programmer at Dice for those that don't already know) than some random fanboi.

Technical Director on Frostbite

I'm not an AMD fan :) and for reason of discussion like The Mac says it is real not because we or JA(DICE) is an AMD fanboy.

Again Xoleras you keep posting things you have little to absolutely no knowledge about then when faced with people which are knowledgeable as Johan Andersson you come up with an excuse for it not to be of any importance.

If anyone on this webboard ever has the intention of listening to Xoleras or Johan Andersson on the matter of Mantle/DX12 who do you think they would choose to believe ?
 
He's not a random AMD fanboy. He's a game programmer @ Creative Assembly. I wonder since he's seen the Mantle programming guide that Creative Assembly might be another dev that's going to support Mantle?

the Total War franchise would certinly benefit from mantle.

perhaps well see it in Total War: Arena when its released.

not like they really need more units on the screen anyway.

lol
 
Mantle is in most mainstream engines now. In two years Mantle will be standard protocol. Mantle will be much more optimized and mature than dx12. I dont think dx will be able perform on the level of Mantle. Ever use a universal remote, they're never as good as the original.:)

You make it sound like Mantle is everywhere when he reality is that it has hardly any real support. Mantle had it's 15 minutes of fame and will go the way of Glide next year. Even if DX12 doesn't gave AS MUCH performance increase as Mantle, the fact that it will be supported by a MUCH wider array of GPU's make it far more attractive to developers than Mantle. That "original remote" of yours is rather useless when trying to operate a device it wasn't intended for.

If you're a developer, are you going to get excited about an API that only works on GCN cards and is supported by AMD or an API that works on GCN cards, 3 generations of NVidia cards and is supported by AMD, nViida, Microsoft and Qualcomm?
 
You make it sound like Mantle is everywhere when he reality is that it has hardly any real support. Mantle had it's 15 minutes of fame and will go the way of Glide next year. Even if DX12 doesn't gave AS MUCH performance increase as Mantle, the fact that it will be supported by a MUCH wider array of GPU's make it far more attractive to developers than Mantle. That "original remote" of yours is rather useless when trying to operate a device it wasn't intended for.

If you're a developer, are you going to get excited about an API that only works on GCN cards and is supported by AMD or an API that works on GCN cards, 3 generations of NVidia cards and is supported by AMD, nViida, Microsoft and Qualcomm?

Only time will tell, but this is the same argument that's been used against Mantle all along. Still it keeps gaining support.

Mantle is in it's infancy. People are talking like we've seen everything Mantle has to offer. AMD has a huge lead with Mantle right now and ~2yrs. to leverage it. I think a sophomore marketing student could run with that and make it work to AMD and Mantle's advantage.
 
Only time will tell, but this is the same argument that's been used against Mantle all along. Still it keeps gaining support.

Mantle is in it's infancy. People are talking like we've seen everything Mantle has to offer. AMD has a huge lead with Mantle right now and ~2yrs. to leverage it. I think a sophomore marketing student could run with that and make it work to AMD and Mantle's advantage.

"all along"? it's been out for a month

"still gaining support" it has a handful of games only like 2 that are out

You have a special gift of sensationalizing all things Mantle

DX12 comes out in late 2015. How much $$$ do you want to wager than in 2016 there will be more DX12 games than Mantle games?

Oh and another important factor... Microsoft doesn't have to pay developers to use their API.
 
Last edited:
Technical Director on Frostbite

I'm not an AMD fan :) and for reason of discussion like The Mac says it is real not because we or JA(DICE) is an AMD fanboy.

Again Xoleras you keep posting things you have little to absolutely no knowledge about then when faced with people which are knowledgeable as Johan Andersson you come up with an excuse for it not to be of any importance.

If anyone on this webboard ever has the intention of listening to Xoleras or Johan Andersson on the matter of Mantle/DX12 who do you think they would choose to believe ?

To accept the idea that MS based DX12 off of Mantle we're going to need to see a whole lot more evidence than a winky face from a guy whose salary of the past couple years has been completely bankrolled by AMD.

I could be wrong here but I suspect there isn't a scrap of Mantle in DX12. Just as there isn't a scrap of Mantle in OGL, which has had the same features a full year before Mantle was even announced to the public amidst much fanfare.

I tell ya... AMD has, by far, the most remarkable marketing department in the tech world sans Apple. The things people post here and in other places are just fascinating and strangely familiar to the "it's magical" mindset we used to see in Apple fans.
 
"all along"? it's been out for a month

"still gaining support" it has a handful of games only like 2 that are out

You have a special gift of sensationalizing all things Mantle

DX12 comes out in late 2015. How much $$$ do you want to wager than in 2016 there will be more DX12 games than Mantle games?

Oh and another important factor... Microsoft doesn't have to pay developers to use their API.

It's the same argument since it's announcement. Not just for the last month.

Crytek has now announced support. Petr Tomicek, programmer for Creative Assembly (Total War), tweeted to Johan Andersson "@repi Why does it feel like I am reading Mantle Programming Guide again? :)" talking about the DirectX Developer Blog. To my knowledge only dev partners have the Mantle Programmers Guide. So, yes they are still gaining support.

If we were to take at face value your statement that Mantle is only one month old then 2 games released already is actually astounding. We know it's taken longer than one month though, so who's sensationalizing here?
 
It's the same argument since it's announcement. Not just for the last month.

Crytek has now announced support. Petr Tomicek, programmer for Creative Assembly (Total War), tweeted to Johan Andersson "@repi Why does it feel like I am reading Mantle Programming Guide again? :)" talking about the DirectX Developer Blog. To my knowledge only dev partners have the Mantle Programmers Guide. So, yes they are still gaining support.

If we were to take at face value your statement that Mantle is only one month old then 2 games released already is actually astounding. We know it's taken longer than one month though, so who's sensationalizing here?

Obviously you are. "feel like reading a Mantle programing guide" is completely irrelevant to the discussion on which will have better support.

Do you want to take my bet or not? If you really believe an API AMD has to pay developers to use is going to have more support than an inherently better supported Direct X, you'd put your money where your mouth is.

I'm pretty sure you know better though.
 
Mantle has to be extremely exceptional in order to be a rival to DirectX. Other than that, just another Glide. DirectX has way more popularity than Mantle and most studio will prioritize DirectX over Mantle. But Mantle earned its credit for giving Microsoft a push and direction because M$ was so lazy and probably lost :)
 
Obviously you are. "feel like reading a Mantle programing guide" is completely irrelevant to the discussion on which will have better support.

Do you want to take my bet or not? If you really believe an API AMD has to pay developers to use is going to have more support than an inherently better supported Direct X, you'd put your money where your mouth is.

I'm pretty sure you know better though.

There is no DX12 and there isn't going to be for a long time. AMD isn't competing with MS. They are just selling their hardware. DX12 having better support in 2016 isn't an issue because AMD will support it as well. AMD is competing with Intel and nVidia. For the next couple of years they are going to have nothing but DX11. DX will be Windows only. AMD does have the option of adding support outside of Windows. That's never going to happen with DX.

Also, try and get quotes right. It was, "@repi Why does it feel like I am reading Mantle Programming Guide again? " Not, feel like reading the Mantle programming guide. Which would have an entirely different meaning. I don't care if you feel like reading it or not. I'm just backing what I said that support continues to grow.

Finally, are you capable of having a civil discussion without trying to turn it into a pissing contest? I'm not an adolescent. I don't need to prove who's smarter, better, or tougher on a tech forum.
 
Obviously you are. "feel like reading a Mantle programing guide" is completely irrelevant to the discussion on which will have better support.

Do you want to take my bet or not? If you really believe an API AMD has to pay developers to use is going to have more support than an inherently better supported Direct X, you'd put your money where your mouth is.

I'm pretty sure you know better though.

Who have they paid to use Mantle?
I bet you are talking about the marketing expenditures with DICE?
 
Mantle has to be extremely exceptional in order to be a rival to DirectX. Other than that, just another Glide. DirectX has way more popularity than Mantle and most studio will prioritize DirectX over Mantle. But Mantle earned its credit for giving Microsoft a push and direction because M$ was so lazy and probably lost :)

Lack of competition will do that.
 
There is no DX12 and there isn't going to be for a long time. AMD isn't competing with MS. They are just selling their hardware. DX12 having better support in 2016 isn't an issue because AMD will support it as well. AMD is competing with Intel and nVidia. For the next couple of years they are going to have nothing but DX11. DX will be Windows only. AMD does have the option of adding support outside of Windows. That's never going to happen with DX.

Also, try and get quotes right. It was, "@repi Why does it feel like I am reading Mantle Programming Guide again? " Not, feel like reading the Mantle programming guide. Which would have an entirely different meaning. I don't care if you feel like reading it or not. I'm just backing what I said that support continues to grow.

Finally, are you capable of having a civil discussion without trying to turn it into a pissing contest? I'm not an adolescent. I don't need to prove who's smarter, better, or tougher on a tech forum.

Your age isn't a factor, neither is how tough or smart you are. Getting that quote right also isn't a factor... You got the quote right, what changed?

Perhaps you should go back a few posts. I responded to someone claiming mantle was going to be the standard in 2 years. You're the one who responded by quoting me about how strong mantle was going to be in 2 years. I challenged that and you came back complaining of completely irrelevant misquotes and who's tougher, whish is also completely irrelevant.

Lets simplify this civil discussion. Lets assume DX12 comes out late next year. Do you think there will be more DX12 games or more Mantle games released in 2016?
 
Your age isn't a factor, neither is how tough or smart you are. Getting that quote right also isn't a factor... You got the quote right, what changed?

Perhaps you should go back a few posts. I responded to someone claiming mantle was going to be the standard in 2 years. You're the one who responded by quoting me about how strong mantle was going to be in 2 years. I challenged that and you came back complaining of completely irrelevant misquotes and who's tougher, whish is also completely irrelevant.

Lets simplify this civil discussion. Lets assume DX12 comes out late next year. Do you think there will be more DX12 games or more Mantle games released in 2016?

I have no idea how many DX12 vs. Mantle games will be released in 2016. I do think Mantle is going to be strong in 2 years though. I'm not trying to say Mantle will supplant DX, nor am I arguing that DX isn't going to continue strong on Windows. I just don't think Mantle is dead because MS has announced a future DX version that will compete with it.

If AMD leverages Mantle and continues to grow it's features and performance it too can be a dominant API. What are the other hardware vendors going to do while waiting around for DX12? Are they going to let AMD run away with performance? AMD has already said they would like others to run Mantle on their hardware. There has been talk of AMD releasing the SDK this year. We'll see what happens then as far as how wide the adoption gets. In the meantime AMD is said to be adding Dev partners as fast as they can support them.

GPU's are going to continue getting more powerful at a much faster rate than CPU's. CPU bottlenecks are going to get worse. We are going to get high quality monitors with 120Hz/144Hz refresh rates. Other AAA developers are not going to sit back and watch games on Mantle advance and not use it themselves. You also have to consider that the consoles run GCN hardware. Devs are going to have all the incentive they need to learn how to code close to the metal on GCN hardware. I doubt they are just going to leave performance on the table with their PC versions after the work has mostly been done. AMD has to do the leg work, but they can make Mantle a very widespread API by the time the 1st DX12 game releases.
 
I have no idea how many DX12 vs. Mantle games will be released in 2016.

Nor do you need to know for the question I'm asking, which is very simple... I'll even make it into a yes or no question.

Do you think there will be more Mantle games released in 2016 than DX12?

I bolded the first part to illustrate that I'm merely asking for your opinion. My answer to this question is NO, I don't think there will be more Mantle games released in 2016. You can give your opinion without knowing first hand the exact number of games for each.
 
Nor do you need to know for the question I'm asking, which is very simple... I'll even make it into a yes or no question.

Do you think there will be more Mantle games released in 2016 than DX12?

I bolded the first part to illustrate that I'm merely asking for your opinion. My answer to this question is NO, I don't think there will be more Mantle games released in 2016. You can give your opinion without knowing first hand the exact number of games for each.

I understood you the first time. I don't know. I've given my opinion, but you seem to want a different one.
 
Obviously you are. "feel like reading a Mantle programing guide" is completely irrelevant to the discussion on which will have better support.

Do you want to take my bet or not? If you really believe an API AMD has to pay developers to use is going to have more support than an inherently better supported Direct X, you'd put your money where your mouth is.

I'm pretty sure you know better though.
You are pretty good at missing the obvious.
AMD does not pay developers.
And how come you deny what JA(DICE) tweeted makes your statement about supporting DX also null and void.

Your age isn't a factor, neither is how tough or smart you are. Getting that quote right also isn't a factor... You got the quote right, what changed?

Perhaps you should go back a few posts. I responded to someone claiming mantle was going to be the standard in 2 years. You're the one who responded by quoting me about how strong mantle was going to be in 2 years. I challenged that and you came back complaining of completely irrelevant misquotes and who's tougher, whish is also completely irrelevant.

Lets simplify this civil discussion. Lets assume DX12 comes out late next year. Do you think there will be more DX12 games or more Mantle games released in 2016?
And again you don't get it , Mantle is DX12 . So Mantle will progress in the form of DX12 and if AMD does it smart also as a stand alone API (platform and OS independant).

Nor do you need to know for the question I'm asking, which is very simple... I'll even make it into a yes or no question.

Do you think there will be more Mantle games released in 2016 than DX12?

I bolded the first part to illustrate that I'm merely asking for your opinion. My answer to this question is NO, I don't think there will be more Mantle games released in 2016. You can give your opinion without knowing first hand the exact number of games for each.

You are asking a question which you already know the answer to. The amount of Mantle games will only increase because engines Frostbite and Nitrous will already have made their impact on several releases. Since DX12 and Mantle are basically the same thing of course there will be more Mantle releases. Mantle in the form of the DX12 container.

To accept the idea that MS based DX12 off of Mantle we're going to need to see a whole lot more evidence than a winky face from a guy whose salary of the past couple years has been completely bankrolled by AMD.

I could be wrong here but I suspect there isn't a scrap of Mantle in DX12. Just as there isn't a scrap of Mantle in OGL, which has had the same features a full year before Mantle was even announced to the public amidst much fanfare.

I tell ya... AMD has, by far, the most remarkable marketing department in the tech world sans Apple. The things people post here and in other places are just fascinating and strangely familiar to the "it's magical" mindset we used to see in Apple fans.

I was talking about SA statement that it is Mantle not based on Mantle. But since you and some others believe that a company like MS suddenly knows everything to make a low lever driver out of thin air then blame the whole thing on AMD fanboys is not only laughable it is sad even that you don't seem to grasp what is in the realm of possibility.

comparing me or or the other folks to apple fanboys is a statement in itself that you have no clue.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top