Universities Banning iPads

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Would you look at that, universities around the country are banning the iPad. Who really cares why they are banning iPads, as long as they keep doing it, the ends justifies the means. :D

Princeton University has blocked around 20 per cent of iPads from being able to access the network, and George Washington doesn't support any Apple products, apparently. Cornell University's information-technology director Steve Schuster said they had similar problems when the iPhone launched, but is "working to ensure the iPad does not have devastating consequences to our network."
 
I post this using a pen from my Tablet PC which is a much better device for students.
 
and i laff at all with portable pc's, you left the house which means you loose

your are not [H]ard anymore
 
At first I thought it was bandwidth and thought, "WTF, fix the network then!" But the latest update on the article says that the problems are with the iPad itself and not related to bandwidth usage. If that's the case - and the problem really is Apple's fault - I can understand this.
 
OK, so aparently these iPads are SOOOOOO popular they're crippling a perfect Uni Wi-Fi setup? What about day-to-day changes in the laptop numbers? Do thosecripple the network too? I hate Apple and the Pad as much as the next tech geek, but this smells of BS BWR (banning for the wrong reasyn) and inproperly-implemented Wi-Fi setups.
Posted via [H] Mobile Device
 
At first I thought it was bandwidth and thought, "WTF, fix the network then!" But the latest update on the article says that the problems are with the iPad itself and not related to bandwidth usage. If that's the case - and the problem really is Apple's fault - I can understand this.

The last two pages wouldn't fully load on my phone so I guess I missed this too.

Way to build your product to specs, Apple :rolleyes:
Posted via [H] Mobile Device
 
OK, so aparently these iPads are SOOOOOO popular they're crippling a perfect Uni Wi-Fi setup? What about day-to-day changes in the laptop numbers? Do thosecripple the network too? I hate Apple and the Pad as much as the next tech geek, but this smells of BS BWR (banning for the wrong reasyn) and inproperly-implemented Wi-Fi setups.
Posted via [H] Mobile Device

Way to not read about what the problem actually is.
 
OK, so aparently these iPads are SOOOOOO popular they're crippling a perfect Uni Wi-Fi setup? What about day-to-day changes in the laptop numbers? Do thosecripple the network too? I hate Apple and the Pad as much as the next tech geek, but this smells of BS BWR (banning for the wrong reasyn) and inproperly-implemented Wi-Fi setups.
Posted via [H] Mobile Device

Yeah, please read the article. The iPads are causing DHCP problems, completely unrelated to total network load.
 
Yeah, please read the article. The iPads are causing DHCP problems, completely unrelated to total network load.

Yep. Going by the Princeton report this is Apple's fault.

So much for Apple stuff that "just works". Really it "just works sometimes, then breaks shit."

At least I can use this as ammunition when the higher ups start asking for iPads so that I won't ever have to support one.
 
Yep. Going by the Princeton report this is Apple's fault.

So much for Apple stuff that "just works". Really it "just works sometimes, then breaks shit."

At least I can use this as ammunition when the higher ups start asking for iPads so that I won't ever have to support one.

There's SO many tablet devices on the way that will outclass the iPad in various ways that hopefully by then you can just point them to a better alternative. Maybe an HP Slate? HP as a GRAND opportunity here is they can execute.
 
OK, so aparently these iPads are SOOOOOO popular they're crippling a perfect Uni Wi-Fi setup? What about day-to-day changes in the laptop numbers? Do thosecripple the network too? I hate Apple and the Pad as much as the next tech geek, but this smells of BS BWR (banning for the wrong reasyn) and inproperly-implemented Wi-Fi setups.
Posted via [H] Mobile Device

Way to not read about what the problem actually is.

Damn, you and many others beat me to it. I thought that at first but then when I RTFA, I was like ooooohhh. Sucks to be Apple but its a bug that will get fixed and the masses will be buying them anyway. I mean just imagine how many think like djBon and just assumed the problem is due to crappy networks their new shiny device is using.
 
At least I can use this as ammunition when the higher ups start asking for iPads so that I won't ever have to support one.

They already have them, just havn't told you yet lol

I wonder if apple will ack this issue and patch it. They have been bad about this sort of thing in the past, will be interesting to keep an eye on this
 
Has this been reproduced outside of Princeton's network? The article mentions that GWU doesn't support Apple products and Cornell is working to prevent issues, but neither mention whether or not it's the same issue Princeton is experiencing. Until then, we don't know if Apple's DHCP implementation is garbage or if there is some minor incompatibility with Princeton's network itself.
 
If this was also an issue with the iPhone, why is this the first time we're hearing about this?

In any case, it seems like a simple fix, and apparently Princeton is already working with Apple to get it worked out.
 
You know, I'd hazard a guess that your average NYC/LA Starbucks network sees more ipads than these university networks In a day. Wonder why we aren't hearing about problems there?
 
If this was also an issue with the iPhone, why is this the first time we're hearing about this?

In any case, it seems like a simple fix, and apparently Princeton is already working with Apple to get it worked out.

It's an issue with iPad/iPhone OS 3.2. Not the iPhone itself as OS 3.2 is iPad only right now correct?
 
It's an issue with iPad/iPhone OS 3.2. Not the iPhone itself as OS 3.2 is iPad only right now correct?
Cornell University's information-technology director Steve Schuster said they had similar problems when the iPhone launched
The Princeton report only talks about 3.2, though. Two different problems, perhaps?
 
If this was also an issue with the iPhone, why is this the first time we're hearing about this?

In any case, it seems like a simple fix, and apparently Princeton is already working with Apple to get it worked out.

I don't think that they said that it was a problem with iPhone per se, they simply refer to the OS as iPad/iPhone OS 3.2, at least they didn't seem to indicate that there was a problem with the iPhone per se.
 
You know, I'd hazard a guess that your average NYC/LA Starbucks network sees more ipads than these university networks In a day. Wonder why we aren't hearing about problems there?

I guess the question is, how closely does starbucks monitor their wifi?
 
Has this been reproduced outside of Princeton's network? The article mentions that GWU doesn't support Apple products and Cornell is working to prevent issues, but neither mention whether or not it's the same issue Princeton is experiencing.

Not sure what the definition of support is, but when you connect to the wireless network in any GWU facility there's a big link that for Apple users to click that takes them to a VPN client to access the network with. So I'm not really sure what the point of including GWU in this report is.
 
It's an issue with iPad/iPhone OS 3.2. Not the iPhone itself as OS 3.2 is iPad only right now correct?

Correct. Latest iPhone OS version is 3.1.3. I hope they can come out with a quick fix, I was really looking forward to OS 3.2 on my IPhone so I could run Netflix :(
 
k1pp3r said:
I guess the question is, how closely does starbucks monitor their wifi?

If the ipad dhcp client is bringing down.the dhcp server then starbucks lack of monitoring would compound the problem.
 
What do you want to bet Jobs has this fixed EXTREMELY quickly. Nothing like some of the top universities in the US banning your product to motivate engineers. :p
 
it makes me smile knowing that people who paid for the 500 dollar p.o.c. can not actually get any use of it almost anywhere. Except of course if they sit on their wireless router while using this thing.
 
lawl at least if its an ipad you cant see the logo from down the stairs. however taking notes on an iphone keyboard doesn't seem too fun imo.

imgres
 
Back
Top